George Pickens doesn't really do "subtle." If you've watched a single Pittsburgh Steelers game since he was drafted out of Georgia, you know exactly what I mean. He makes the kind of acrobatic, logic-defying catches that make you jump off your couch, but he also carries an intensity that occasionally boils over into the headlines. During a Week 5 matchup against the Dallas Cowboys in the 2024 season, that intensity manifested in a very specific, very visible way: a George Pickens eye black message that read "Always Fucking Open."
He wrote it in silver script across the black adhesive strips under his eyes. It wasn't a mistake. It wasn't a smudge. It was a loud, profanity-laced declaration of his confidence—or perhaps his frustration.
The NFL, a league famously nicknamed the "No Fun League" by players and fans alike, reacted exactly how you’d expect. They reached into Pickens’ wallet. But the story isn't just about a fine or a bad word. It’s about the collision of modern player branding, strict uniform policies, and the specific pressure cooker that is the Pittsburgh Steelers' wide receiver room.
The Fine Print: Why the NFL Stepped In
The league office isn't known for its sense of humor regarding uniform "flair." According to the NFL’s Rule 5, Section 4, Article 8, players are strictly prohibited from wearing any "personal messages" on their uniforms or person on game days unless it’s cleared through the league's official channels (like the "My Cause, My Cleats" initiative). This includes writing on tape, bandages, or, you guessed it, eye black.
The specific violation for the George Pickens eye black message fell under "Unsportsmanlike Conduct." Because the message contained a "profane" word, the league office handed down a fine of $10,030.
Honestly, the money is a drop in the bucket for a professional athlete, but the message was sent loud and clear. The NFL wants a clean product. They want a corporate-friendly aesthetic. Pickens gave them the exact opposite. He gave them raw, unfiltered ego.
The Cam Heyward Comparison
To understand how rigid the league is, look back at Cameron Heyward, Pickens’ own teammate. A few years back, Heyward wore eye black that honored his late father, Craig "Ironhead" Heyward, who died of cancer. Even for a cause as noble and personal as that, the NFL fined him. They eventually lowered the fine after a massive public outcry, but the precedent remained: the eye black real estate belongs to the league, not the player.
What Was Pickens Thinking?
You have to look at the context of that specific game. The Steelers were struggling offensively against the Cowboys. Pickens, who is arguably the most talented pure athlete on the roster, was being rotated out of the lineup more than usual. He played only 34 of 58 offensive snaps in that game. That's roughly 59%. For a WR1, those are bizarrely low numbers.
When a guy like Pickens writes "Always Fucking Open" on his face and then gets benched for 40% of the game, it creates a narrative. Fans started wondering if there was a rift between Pickens and head coach Mike Tomlin or offensive coordinator Arthur Smith.
Tomlin, in his classic "Tomlin-ism" style, brushed it off as "snap management" and "load management." He claimed they were just trying to keep Pickens fresh for the late-game push. But if you’re George Pickens, and you believe you’re the best player on the field, being "managed" feels a lot like being "minimized."
📖 Related: Jake Paul Mike Tyson Tattoo: What Most People Get Wrong
The Evolution of the Wide Receiver Diva
We've seen this movie before in Pittsburgh. This is the franchise that handled Antonio Brown’s peak and eventual exit. They dealt with JuJu Smith-Schuster’s TikTok dances on opposing logos. They traded Chase Claypool when the "distraction-to-production" ratio got out of whack.
The George Pickens eye black message is just the latest chapter in a long history of Steelers receivers pushing the envelope.
There's a specific psychology at play here. Wide receivers often feel like they are at the mercy of factors they can't control: the quarterback’s accuracy, the play-caller’s scheme, and the offensive line's ability to block. When things go wrong, the frustration usually comes out in body language or, in this case, Sharpie on the face.
Production vs. Personality
Here’s the thing: people tolerate the "extra" stuff when the production is there. During that Cowboys game, Pickens finished with 3 catches for 26 yards. When you put a bold claim like "Always Fucking Open" on your face and then produce 26 yards, the internet is going to eat you alive.
It’s one thing to be a "diva" when you’re putting up 150 yards and two scores. It’s another thing entirely when you’re a non-factor in a loss. The optics were bad, and the league’s fine just put an exclamation point on a frustrating weekend for the Steelers.
The NFL’s Double Standard on "Expression"
Some fans argue that the league is hypocritical. They’ll point out that the NFL markets "player personality" in commercials but penalizes it on the field. They see the George Pickens eye black message as a harmless expression of competitive fire.
"Let the kids play," is the common refrain on social media.
However, from the league’s perspective, it’s about the sponsors. The NFL is a multibillion-dollar machine fueled by corporate partnerships. If a camera zooms in on a star player and there’s an F-bomb staring back at millions of viewers (including kids), the league sees a threat to its "all-ages" brand.
It’s not about the message; it’s about the medium. If Pickens had said the same thing in a post-game press conference, he might have been fined for profanity, but it wouldn't have been a "uniform violation." Putting it on the eye black makes it part of the official broadcast "set."
👉 See also: What Place Is The Phillies In: The Real Story Behind the NL East Standings
A Pattern of Behavior or Just a Moment?
Is Pickens a "problem"? That's the question every sports talk radio host in Pennsylvania was asking for two weeks straight.
Earlier in his career, he was seen pouting on the sidelines when he wasn't getting targets. There was the infamous clip where he didn't block for Jaylen Warren on a potential touchdown run because he "didn't want to get rolled up on."
Then came the eye black.
Then came a late-game scuffle where he grabbed a Cowboys player’s facemask and threw him to the ground after the whistle.
When you stack these incidents together, the George Pickens eye black message starts to look less like an isolated joke and more like a symptom of a player who is struggling to handle the mental rigors of the NFL. But—and this is a big "but"—Pickens is also the guy who will make a one-handed catch that defies the laws of physics five minutes later.
How the Steelers Handled It
Mike Tomlin is a master of locker room diplomacy. He didn't publicly bash Pickens. He didn't suspend him. He basically called it a "non-story" and moved on.
But behind closed doors? You can bet there were conversations. The Steelers pride themselves on a certain "standard." While they've had colorful personalities, they generally don't love it when those personalities overshadow the team's performance.
Interestingly, Pickens did eventually apologize to his teammates—not necessarily for the message itself, but for being a distraction. He’s a young player. He’s 23. Most of us were making questionable decisions at 23; we just didn't have 4k cameras broadcasting our mistakes to 20 million people.
The Tactical Side: Is He Actually Always Open?
If we ignore the profanity for a second, was the George Pickens eye black message actually true?
✨ Don't miss: Huskers vs Michigan State: What Most People Get Wrong About This Big Ten Rivalry
If you look at the "Next Gen Stats" and film breakdown from that season, Pickens actually has a point. His "separation" numbers aren't always elite, but his "contested catch" rate is through the roof. In the NFL, "open" is a relative term. For a guy with Pickens' catch radius, being covered by a cornerback is often the same as being open.
He wins 50/50 balls at a rate that few others can match. So, in his mind, if the ball is in the air, he’s open. The frustration likely stems from a feeling that the Steelers’ offense—which has been notoriously conservative in recent years—doesn't take enough shots downfield to utilize his specific skill set.
Lessons from the Eye Black Incident
What can we actually take away from this? It’s more than just a funny meme or a fine.
First, the NFL is never going to budge on uniform policy. If you want to send a message, do it on a podcast or a pre-game shirt, not during the 60 minutes of game time.
Second, the "diva receiver" archetype is still very much alive, but the way it's managed has changed. In the 90s, this would have been a season-long drama. In 2026, it’s a 48-hour news cycle. We’ve become desensitized to players acting out.
Finally, for Pickens, this was a massive "brand" moment. Whether you liked it or hated it, everyone was talking about him. In the attention economy, that’s a win. But in the "winning football games" economy, it was a net negative.
How to Stay Out of the NFL’s "Fine Zone"
If you're an aspiring athlete or just a fan trying to understand the rules, here is the reality of the league's stance on personal expression:
- Stick to the Pre-Game: Players have much more leeway during warm-ups. If Pickens had worn a shirt with that message during the pre-game stretch, he likely wouldn't have been fined nearly as much, if at all.
- Use Official Channels: The "My Cause, My Cleats" weeks are the only time the NFL allows personalized gear. Outside of that, you are an employee in a very strict uniform.
- Watch the Language: The NFL is particularly sensitive to "broadcast-ready" content. Profanity is a guaranteed way to trigger an automatic fine.
- Focus on the "Whys": Before making a public statement on your gear, ask if the production matches the claim. Bold claims require bold stats.
The George Pickens eye black message will go down as one of those "Oh, yeah, remember that?" moments in Steelers history. It’s a perfect microcosm of his career so far: talented, defiant, slightly chaotic, and impossible to ignore. Whether he matures into a veteran leader or continues to push the boundaries of league rules is something only time—and perhaps Mike Tomlin’s patience—will tell.
For now, the lesson is simple: if you're going to tell the world you're "Always Fucking Open," you better make sure you catch the ball when it comes your way. Otherwise, you're just paying $10,000 for a very expensive piece of face paint.
Actionable Insight: If you're following the NFL's disciplinary trends, keep an eye on the "Uniform and Equipment" section of the weekly fine reports. The league has significantly increased the dollar amounts for "unauthorized messaging" over the last two seasons as they lean harder into a "clean" broadcast image for international markets. If you're a player, the safest bet for personal branding remains social media and post-game interviews, where the NFL's reach—and their rulebook—is slightly less restrictive.