If you were sitting in an NFL war room back in April 2022, the name George Pickens probably sparked a shouting match. He was the ultimate "what if" prospect. One scout would see the 6-foot-3 frame and the hands that seemed to have their own gravity, while another would be staring at the medical reports and the "character concern" notes highlighted in bright red ink.
The George Pickens draft profile was never about safe floors or incremental growth. It was about raw, unadulterated ceiling.
Honestly, looking back at his time in Georgia, it's kind of wild he even made it to the podium in Las Vegas. He tore his ACL in the spring of 2021. Most guys would have packed it in and spent the year doing rehab in a pool. Instead, Pickens grinded his way back onto the field in just eight months, playing the final four games of Georgia’s national championship run. That 52-yard bomb he caught against Alabama in the title game? That was the "I'm back" moment every NFL GM needed to see.
The Physicality That Made Him a Day 2 Steal
Pickens is a bit of a physical contradiction. He measured in at the combine at 6-foot-3 and 195 pounds, which is basically the "Lanky X-Receiver" starter pack. But don't let the thin frame fool you. This guy plays like he wants to physically harm the person across from him.
His scouting report was basically a love letter to his catch radius. He has 32 3/8-inch arms and a vertical leap that let him high-point balls most receivers wouldn't even jump for. When the ball is in the air, he doesn't just try to catch it; he attacks it.
The Numbers That Mattered
- 40-Yard Dash: 4.47 seconds (officially laser-timed).
- 10-Yard Split: 1.59 seconds.
- Vertical Jump: 33 inches.
- Broad Jump: 10 feet, 5 inches.
- Hand Size: 8 3/4 inches.
The 4.47 speed is deceptive. On tape, he looks faster because he doesn't waste movement. He’s got this "second gear" that kicks in when the ball is at its peak. It’s why he was so dangerous on those vertical routes that Georgia loved to run.
👉 See also: Lower.com Field Columbus Crew Way Columbus OH: What Most Fans Miss About the New Crew Stadium
Why Teams Were Actually Scared
So, if he was this talented, why did he slide to the 52nd pick? Why were the Steelers able to snag a first-round talent in the middle of the second?
Maturity. That’s the word that kept popping up in every George Pickens draft profile before the 2022 draft. There was the incident where he got ejected for fighting a Georgia Tech player. There was the time he squirted water at a Tennessee player on the sideline. In the eyes of some NFL teams, he was a "hothead."
Combine that with the fact that he only had 90 career receptions in college because of the ACL tear and some shaky quarterback play in Athens, and you have a high-risk gamble. He wasn't a polished route runner yet. He relied on his athleticism to bail him out of bad technique. In the NFL, that usually gets you shut down by veteran corners who know how to use their hands.
Tracking the College Production
Let’s be real—his stats don’t jump off the page like a Ja'Marr Chase or a Justin Jefferson. But you have to look at the context.
As a freshman in 2019, he was the man. He put up 49 catches for 727 yards and 8 touchdowns. He was PFF’s 17th-highest-graded receiver that year, rubbing shoulders with future stars like CeeDee Lamb. Then 2020 happened. A weird, shortened COVID season with a revolving door at quarterback meant he only played 8 games. He still led the team in touchdowns, but the momentum was stalled.
Then the ACL tear happened.
The fact that he came back to play in those final four games in 2021—recording 107 yards on just 5 catches—showed he had the "dog" in him. NFL teams love that. They'll take a guy with a slightly messy resume if he proves he’ll run through a brick wall to get back on the field.
What Scouts Got Right (And Wrong)
Most analysts compared him to Josh Reynolds or DeVante Parker. Looking back now, that feels a bit low. Pickens has shown a level of acrobatic body control that is closer to an A.J. Green or even a prime DeAndre Hopkins.
One thing the scouts hit the nail on was his blocking. He is a "relentless" blocker. There are clips from his Georgia days where he is literally pancaking cornerbacks into the turf. He treats every play like a chance to win a physical battle, whether he’s getting the ball or not.
However, they were right about the "boom or bust" nature. He is a player who thrives on the big play but can sometimes disappear if the quarterback isn't willing to trust him in 50/50 situations. He needs a QB with some "gunslinger" in them to really maximize that catch radius.
👉 See also: FA Premier League Transfers: Why the January 2026 Window Is Different
Actionable Insights for Evaluating Similar Prospects
If you're looking at current draft prospects and trying to find the "next George Pickens," here is what you need to look for:
- Recovery Speed: Don't automatically discount a player who tore an ACL if they return to the field in under 10 months. It shows a level of professional discipline that usually carries over to the NFL.
- Catch Radius Over Speed: A 4.47 40-yard dash is good, but a 33-inch vertical on a 6-foot-3 frame is better. Focus on how a player "attacks" the ball in traffic rather than just their raw track speed.
- The "Aggression" Factor: Look at the run-blocking film. If a wide receiver is willing to get his hands dirty in the run game, it’s a massive indicator of his competitive ceiling.
- Alpha Mentality: Sometimes the "character concerns" are just a byproduct of a player being hyper-competitive. Distinguish between a player who is a locker room cancer and one who just needs a professional environment to channel their intensity.
The story of George Pickens is a reminder that the draft isn't just about what a player has done; it's about what they are physically capable of doing once the training wheels come off. The Steelers bet on the physical tools, and everyone who passed on him in the first round has spent the last few years regretting it.
Keep an eye on the medical re-checks during the combine. Often, a player who "slides" due to injury is the biggest value play on the board if their recovery film shows even a glimpse of their pre-injury explosiveness.