You probably remember that one kid on the playground. The one with the mud-streaked face and a handful of garden soil halfway to their mouth. We all laughed, or maybe we were grossed out, but it turns out that kid might have been onto something ancient. We call it geophagy. It's the technical term for the deliberate consumption of earth, soil, or clay. While it sounds like a recipe for a stomach ache or a parasitic nightmare to the modern, sanitized ear, the benefits of eating dirt have been studied by anthropologists and biologists for decades. It’s not just "eating dirt." It’s a complex biological behavior seen across cultures and species.
Human history is caked in mud. Hippocrates, the father of medicine, wrote about it. Roman soldiers used "Terra Sigillata," which were basically tablets of medicinal clay stamped with a seal of authenticity. It wasn't a desperate act of starvation. It was pharmacy. Even today, if you walk through markets in parts of sub-Saharan Africa or rural areas in the Southern United States, you’ll find "white dirt" or kaolin clay sold for consumption. People aren't doing this because they're confused; they're doing it because their bodies are asking for it.
The Science Behind Geophagy
Why would a human being want to swallow a chunk of clay? Dr. Sera Young, an evolutionary anthropologist at Cornell University, has spent years digging into this. Her research, particularly in her book Craving Earth, suggests that the benefits of eating dirt aren't usually about nutrition in the way we think of a vitamin pill. For a long time, people assumed geophagy was a response to mineral deficiencies—like the body's way of screaming for iron or calcium. But the data is messy. Sometimes the soil actually binds to minerals and prevents your body from absorbing them.
So, if it’s not for the minerals, what is it for?
Protection. Think of clay as a biological sponge. Clay minerals, particularly those in the smectite family (like montmorillonite), have an incredible surface area. They are chemically "sticky." When you ingest these clays, they can bind to toxins, pathogens, and parasites in the gut. This is likely why geophagy is most common among pregnant women and young children. These are the two groups whose immune systems are either suppressed or developing, making them most vulnerable to foodborne toxins. By eating specific types of earth, they may be lining their digestive tracts with a protective barrier that keeps the bad stuff from entering the bloodstream.
📖 Related: How to Perform Anal Intercourse: The Real Logistics Most People Skip
The Gut-Soil Connection
We live in an era of "The Hygiene Hypothesis." We've bleached our floors, sanitized our hands, and processed our food until it's practically sterile. And yet, autoimmune diseases and allergies are skyrocketing. There is a school of thought—one supported by researchers like Jack Gilbert, author of Dirt is Good—that suggests our lack of exposure to the microbial diversity found in soil is making us sick.
Soil is alive. A single teaspoon contains billions of bacteria, fungi, and protozoa. When we talk about the benefits of eating dirt, we are indirectly talking about the "Old Friends" hypothesis. This theory posits that humans evolved alongside these soil microbes, and they play a crucial role in training our immune systems. Without them, our immune systems get bored. And a bored immune system is a dangerous one; it starts attacking pollen, peanuts, or your own thyroid.
Mud as Medicine: Real World Examples
In many cultures, eating earth is specifically tied to digestive health. In the Andean highlands, indigenous people have a long-standing tradition of dipping wild potatoes—which are often high in bitter, toxic glycoalkaloids—into a "clay sauce." This isn't just a culinary quirk. The clay binds to the toxins in the potatoes, making them safe to eat. Without the dirt, those potatoes could cause serious illness.
Then there’s the case of Kaolin. If you’ve ever taken Kaopectate for an upset stomach, you’ve basically "eaten dirt." The original formulation of that medicine used kaolinite, a type of clay. It works because the clay coats the stomach lining and absorbs the toxins produced by bacteria like E. coli. It’s a direct, modern application of geophagy that we’ve just rebranded with a pharmaceutical label to make it feel less "dirty."
👉 See also: I'm Cranky I'm Tired: Why Your Brain Shuts Down When You're Exhausted
But let's be real: you can't just go out to your backyard with a spoon. That’s a one-way ticket to a heavy metal poisoning or a round of hookworms. The soil people eat in traditional geophagy is usually sourced from specific depths and often processed by drying or baking to kill off pathogens while keeping the mineral and binding properties intact.
The Irony of Pica
Medicine often classifies geophagy under "Pica," a disorder characterized by eating non-nutritive substances. It's often grouped with eating ice or paint chips. But this classification feels a bit Western-centric to many researchers. When a pregnant woman in Kenya eats "odowa" (baked earth), she’s participating in a cultural tradition that has a clear biological rationale. Is it a disorder if it serves a protective function?
Interestingly, some studies have shown that people with iron-deficiency anemia are more likely to engage in geophagy. However, it's a bit of a "chicken or the egg" situation. Does the clay cause the anemia by blocking iron absorption, or does the anemia trigger a deep, ancestral craving for the earth in a misguided attempt to find minerals? We don't fully know yet. The complexity is the point.
Understanding the Risks
You shouldn't ignore the dangers. If you’re looking for the benefits of eating dirt, you have to balance them against some pretty gnarly risks.
✨ Don't miss: Foods to Eat to Prevent Gas: What Actually Works and Why You’re Doing It Wrong
- Lead and Arsenic: Most topsoil in urban or industrial areas is loaded with heavy metals. These don't leave your system easily.
- Parasites: Toxocariasis is a real threat. It’s a parasitic infection caused by roundworms found in soil contaminated by animal feces.
- Intestinal Blockage: Eating too much clay can literally clog you up, leading to a bowel obstruction that might require surgery.
- Tooth Wear: Dirt is abrasive. Regularly chewing it will grind your enamel down to nothing.
It’s about context. The "benefits" are highly dependent on the type of soil, the health of the person, and the specific environment. In a modern, urban setting, the risks almost always outweigh the potential microbial gains.
How to Get the Benefits Without the Bucket
If the idea of munching on a clod of earth makes you gag, but you want to fix your "too-clean" lifestyle, there are better ways. You don't need to eat a bowl of mud to satisfy your evolutionary need for soil contact.
- Gardening with Bare Hands: This is the most effective way to interact with soil microbes. The bacteria Mycobacterium vaccae, commonly found in soil, has been shown in studies to mirror the effects of antidepressants by stimulating serotonin production. You don't have to swallow it; just getting it under your fingernails and breathing in the moist earth (a smell called petrichor) does wonders for your microbiome and mental health.
- Farmer’s Market Produce: Stop scrubbing your organic carrots until they're surgical-grade. A little bit of leftover grit from a healthy, organic farm is actually a good thing. It’s a "micro-exposure" to the environment.
- Bentonite Clay Products: If you’re dead set on the detoxifying properties of clay, stick to food-grade bentonite clay sold by reputable sources. These are tested for heavy metals and pathogens. People use them in small amounts mixed with water to help with bloating or skin issues, but even then, it's something to do sparingly.
- Probiotics and Spore-Based Supplements: Modern science has started capturing these soil-based organisms (SBOs) in capsule form. Strains like Bacillus subtilis are essentially "dirt bacteria" that help regulate the gut. It’s geophagy for the 21st century.
Actionable Next Steps for the Curious
If you’re fascinated by the connection between the earth and your health, don't start digging up your lawn. Instead, take a more measured approach to re-earthing your life.
- Audit your cleaning supplies: If you’re using "99.9% antibacterial" everything, you’re killing the good guys along with the bad. Switch to gentler, fermented, or probiotic-based cleaners.
- Spend time in "high-biodiversity" areas: A park is fine, but an old-growth forest is better. The microbial diversity in the air and soil is much richer in undisturbed ecosystems.
- Consult a professional if you have cravings: If you find yourself genuinely craving dirt, ice, or chalk, see a doctor. It’s often a clinical sign of a mineral deficiency (like iron or zinc) that needs a supplement, not a mouthful of garden soil.
- Get your hands dirty: Start a small herb box or a garden. The physical act of touching soil has been proven to lower cortisol levels. It’s the most direct, safe way to reap the ancient benefits of eating dirt without the risk of a parasite.
The earth is our home, and for most of human history, it was also our medicine cabinet. While we've moved away from the literal act of geophagy in most modern societies, the biological need for a relationship with the soil remains. We are part of the ecosystem, not separate from it. Sometimes, getting a little dirty is exactly what the doctor ordered.