Let’s be real for a second. The standard, triangle-eyed spooky face is boring. We’ve seen it since the 1800s when Irish immigrants first started carving turnips—and eventually pumpkins—to ward off Stingy Jack. It's classic, sure. But in a neighborhood full of flickering orange gourds, the ones that actually stop people in their tracks are the funny jack o lanterns.
Laughter beats a jump scare every single time.
I’ve spent way too many October nights elbow-deep in pumpkin guts. What I've learned is that the funniest designs aren't usually the most "artistic" ones. They are the ones that tell a tiny, ridiculous story. It’s about subverting expectations. You expect a monster; you get a pumpkin that’s clearly had one too many cider donuts and is now regretting its life choices.
The Physics of a Good Laugh
Why do we find a carved vegetable funny? It’s usually the "human" element. We love projection. When you see a pumpkin with a "face" that looks like it just realized it forgot to turn the oven off, that’s relatability.
The most successful funny jack o lanterns usually fall into a few specific comedic buckets. You have the "Gourd-in-Distress," where a large pumpkin is seemingly eating a smaller one. Then there’s the "Biological Failure," which uses the natural deformities of the pumpkin—warts, weird stems, or lopsided growth—to create a character that looks like a grumpy uncle.
Think about the "Puking Pumpkin." It’s a staple of suburban Halloween displays for a reason. By using the discarded innards (the seeds and stringy guts) and spilling them out of a wide, agonizing mouth, you create a visual gag that is both gross and hilarious. It’s slapstick comedy in vegetable form.
Getting the Expression Right
If you want a funny face, forget the triangles. Use circles for eyes to create a look of perpetual shock. Give it eyebrows. Honestly, eyebrows are the most underrated tool in the carver’s kit. Slant them upward toward the middle for a worried look, or tilt them down for a "I’m not mad, just disappointed" vibe.
A tiny mouth on a massive pumpkin? Hilarious.
A massive mouth with one single tooth? Also hilarious.
👉 See also: Why the Man Black Hair Blue Eyes Combo is So Rare (and the Genetics Behind It)
I remember seeing a display at the Great Jack O'Lantern Blaze in New York where they didn't just carve faces; they carved personalities. One pumpkin was wearing actual sunglasses. Another had a toothpick in its mouth. These small, non-vegetable additions bridge the gap between "seasonal decor" and "character design."
Why Context is Everything
A single funny pumpkin is great. A scene is better.
Imagine a pumpkin sitting on a chair, holding a newspaper, with a pair of reading glasses perched on its stem. It’s a dad. It’s a "Dad-o-Lantern." This works because it’s unexpected. You’re walking through a dark neighborhood, bracing for ghosts, and you find a squash catching up on the morning news.
The "Cannibal" Trope
The most common request for funny jack o lanterns is the "Pumpkin Eating a Pumpkin" setup. It’s a classic for a reason. You take a medium-sized pumpkin, carve a massive, jagged mouth, and then shove a "munchkin" or "baby boo" pumpkin inside.
If you want to level this up, don't just put the small pumpkin in the mouth. Carve the small pumpkin to have a terrified expression. Tiny pin-prick eyes. A little "O" for a mouth. That narrative tension is what makes it stick in people's minds.
Modern Relatability: The "Zoom Meeting" Pumpkin
Since 2020, we’ve seen a rise in what I call "Modern Horror" funny pumpkins. These are gourds that represent our daily frustrations.
- A pumpkin with the "spinning wheel of death" carved into its forehead.
- A pumpkin wearing a headset looking absolutely drained.
- The "Low Battery" symbol.
These aren't traditionally "scary," but they resonate because they tap into a shared human experience. It’s irony. We use the spooky medium of pumpkin carving to mock the things that actually stress us out in real life.
✨ Don't miss: Chuck E. Cheese in Boca Raton: Why This Location Still Wins Over Parents
Real Advice from the Patch
If you’re going for a funny look, you need the right raw materials.
Most people hunt for the "perfect" pumpkin. Smooth skin, perfectly round, stands up straight. That’s a mistake if you want humor. Go for the weirdos. Look for the pumpkins with the "warts" (caused by edema or specific heritage seeds like the 'Knucklehead' variety). These bumps can become noses, tumors, or just a generally "gross" texture that adds to the character.
Long, curved stems are gold. A long stem can be a nose if you flip the pumpkin on its side. Suddenly, you have a Gonzo-style profile that no flat-faced pumpkin can compete with.
Pro Tip: If you’re doing a "Puking Pumpkin," don’t just use the guts from the pumpkin you carved. They dry out and look like hair after two hours. Go to the store and buy a bag of bean sprouts or use canned pumpkin puree for a "fresher," more disgusting look that stays moist through the evening.
The Science of "Funny" Lighting
Standard white tea lights are fine for spooky. For funny, you might want to experiment.
Using a color-changing LED can make a "sick" pumpkin look even greener. Or, if you’ve carved a pumpkin that’s supposed to be "surprised," placing the light source slightly above the eyes—rather than at the base—creates a weird, top-down shadow that makes the expression look even more unhinged.
Common Misconceptions About Carving
People think they need those flimsy orange-handled kits from the grocery store. You don't. In fact, those tiny saws are only good for detail work. For funny jack o lanterns that require deep grooves or varied textures, you’re better off using:
🔗 Read more: The Betta Fish in Vase with Plant Setup: Why Your Fish Is Probably Miserable
- Linoleum Cutters: These are perfect for "shaving" the skin without going all the way through. You can create different shades of light.
- Clay Loops: If you want to give your pumpkin "cheeks" or a rounded nose, these are essential.
- A Dry Erase Marker: Never use a Sharpie. If you mess up your "funny" expression, a Sharpie is forever. Dry erase wipes right off the pumpkin’s skin.
There’s also this myth that you have to cut the top off. If you’re doing a face, try cutting the hole in the back. It preserves the structural integrity of the pumpkin and prevents the "sagging" that happens when the lid starts to rot and fall in. Plus, it keeps the stem intact, which is often the funniest part of the whole vegetable.
The Longevity Problem
Nothing kills a joke faster than a moldy punchline.
Funny pumpkins often have more intricate "shaved" areas, which means they rot faster. The surface area exposed to oxygen is huge. According to various horticultural studies and the collective wisdom of "Pumpkin Masters," a bleach-water solution (about one tablespoon of bleach per gallon of water) can extend the life of your carving by a few days by killing off the surface bacteria.
Some people swear by petroleum jelly on the edges. Honestly? It’s messy. It catches dust and hair. Better to just accept that your masterpiece is temporary art. It’s part of the charm.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Carve
If you're ready to move past the generic ghost face, here is how you actually execute a funny design that works.
- Audit your pumpkin's personality. Before you cut, look at the pumpkin. Is it tall? Short? Does it have a "scar"? Let the shape dictate the joke. A flat, wide pumpkin is perfect for a "sleeping" face. A tall, skinny one is built for a "shocked" face.
- Focus on the "Human" elements. Add teeth. Not just jagged points, but square, human-like teeth. Use white pumpkin pieces or even toothpicks to create a "goofy" overbite.
- Incorporate props. This is the secret weapon of the pros. A pair of old glasses, a wig, a cigar (unlit, obviously), or a baby pacifier. These items turn a carved vegetable into a "character."
- Think about the "Reaction." If you have multiple pumpkins, make them interact. One pumpkin should look like it’s telling a joke, and the one next to it should look like it’s face-palming.
- Document it early. Since you're likely going for a "high-effort" funny look, take your photos the hour you finish. The "expression" of a pumpkin changes as it wilts. Sometimes a "frowning" pumpkin becomes even funnier as it shrivels, but usually, it just looks sad.
The goal isn't to win an art gallery prize. It's to make the delivery driver chuckle or have a kid point and laugh on their way to get candy. In a world that takes itself way too seriously, a squash with a goofy grin is a small, orange act of rebellion.
Next Steps for Success:
Start by sketching your idea on paper first, focusing specifically on the "eyebrows" and "teeth"—these are the two features that carry 90% of the comedic weight. Once you have a shape, find a pumpkin that matches the "vibe" of your sketch rather than trying to force a design onto a pumpkin that doesn't fit. Pick up a set of clay loops if you want to try "shaving" the skin for a three-dimensional effect that catches the light differently than a standard cut-out.