Nineteen ninety-five was a weirdly specific time for television. If you were a kid back then, you weren't just watching cartoons; you were witnessing the golden age of the "relatable" live-action sitcom. Right in the middle of that surge was Fudge the TV show, a series that felt like it was ripped directly from the pages of our dog-eared paperbacks because, well, it was.
Judy Blume is a legend. Period. But bringing Farley Drexel Hatcher to life—the kid everyone knows as Fudge—was always going to be a massive gamble. How do you cast a kid who is supposed to be equal parts endearing and absolutely destructive? ABC (and later UPN) took a swing at it, and for a specific generation of viewers, it became a Saturday morning staple that somehow captured the chaotic energy of New York City sibling rivalry without feeling like a canned lecture.
What Made the Fudge TV Show Actually Work?
It wasn't just about the name recognition. Honestly, a lot of book-to-screen adaptations in the mid-90s were pretty terrible. They often felt cheap or missed the internal monologue that made the books special. But Fudge the TV show had a secret weapon: the casting of Luke Tarsitano as Fudge and Jake Richardson as the perpetually exhausted Peter Hatcher.
Peter is the soul of the story. If you’ve ever had a younger sibling who seemed to get away with murder while you got grounded for breathing too loud, you felt Peter’s pain. The show leaned heavily into that "older brother as the martyr" vibe. It wasn't just a kids' show; it was a survival guide for the eldest child.
The production didn't shy away from the specific NYC setting either. Living in a cramped apartment with a kid who swallows turtles? That’s high stakes when you’re twelve. The show ran for two seasons, starting on ABC’s Saturday morning lineup before moving over to UPN. While it didn't have the decade-long run of something like Boy Meets World, it left a mark because it didn't treat kids like they were stupid. It treated them like people with real frustrations.
The Judy Blume Connection
Blume wasn't just a name on the credits. She was involved. Along with her son, Lawrence Blume, she helped ensure the tone stayed true to the "Superfudge" and "Tales of a Fourth Grade Nothing" spirit. This is probably why the show feels more authentic than other contemporary adaptations.
You can tell when a creator is protecting their work.
✨ Don't miss: Death Wish II: Why This Sleazy Sequel Still Triggers People Today
In the episodes, you see the mundane horrors of childhood. The birthday party disasters. The tooth-losing incidents. The constant feeling that your parents—played by Eve Plumb (yes, Jan Brady herself!) and Forrest Witt—are slightly overwhelmed by the sheer force of Fudge’s personality. It’s a dynamic that resonates even more now that the original viewers are parents themselves.
Why We Don't Talk About It Enough
Streaming has a way of burying things. If a show isn't on a major platform's front page, it basically ceases to exist in the public consciousness. Fudge the TV show has suffered from this digital erasure. While you can find snippets on YouTube or old VHS rips if you look hard enough, it hasn't had the "legacy sequel" or big 4K remaster treatment.
That’s a shame.
The show tackled the 90s aesthetic perfectly. Windbreakers. Big hair. The specific lighting of a multi-cam sitcom. It’s a time capsule. Beyond the nostalgia, it actually handled the transition of the Hatcher family moving from the city to the suburbs (Princeton, NJ) with a lot of nuance. It captured that "fish out of water" feeling for Peter, who finally had his own room but lost his identity as a city kid.
The Episode That Everyone Remembers
If you ask any fan about the show, they’ll probably mention the turtle. Or the "Toddler-Cottle" commercial.
The "Dribble" incident is the foundational myth of the Fudge universe. When Fudge eats Peter’s pet turtle, it’s not just a gross-out gag. It’s a betrayal. The TV show handled this with a mix of slapstick and genuine sibling pathos. Seeing it visualized—the panic, the hospital trip, the realization that Peter’s world just got flipped upside down because his brother wanted to see what a turtle tasted like—it was peak 90s TV.
🔗 Read more: Dark Reign Fantastic Four: Why This Weirdly Political Comic Still Holds Up
- The show successfully adapted Tales of a Fourth Grade Nothing, Otherwise Known as Sheila the Great, and Superfudge.
- Eve Plumb brought a "grown-up" sitcom credibility to the cast.
- Nassau County, New York, served as a primary filming location, giving it that authentic East Coast feel.
A Legacy of Sibling Rivalry
Most TV shows about families make the kids best friends by the end of the thirty minutes. Fudge the TV show was different. It acknowledged that sometimes, your brother is just an annoying person you happen to live with.
That honesty is rare.
It didn't always have a "The More You Know" moral at the end. Sometimes the moral was just: life is loud, your brother is a menace, and you’re probably going to have to deal with it until you move out. This cynical-yet-sweet balance is exactly what made Judy Blume's books bestsellers for decades, and the show translated that cynicism into a visual language that worked for the "Saved by the Bell" generation.
Where is the cast now?
Luke Tarsitano, who played the titular Fudge, largely stepped away from the spotlight after his teen years. Jake Richardson, our Peter, kept working for quite a while, appearing in shows like ER, Criminal Minds, and even a memorable turn in Garden State.
It's interesting to see how child actors from that era transitioned. Some stayed in the industry, while others chose a quieter life. For the fans, though, they'll always be the kids from 25 Central Park West.
Rethinking the "Kids Show" Label
Is it just a kids' show? Maybe on paper.
💡 You might also like: Cuatro estaciones en la Habana: Why this Noir Masterpiece is Still the Best Way to See Cuba
But looking back at Fudge the TV show through a 2026 lens, it’s a masterclass in economy. The writing was tight. The gags were physical without being entirely "Looney Tunes." It dealt with the anxiety of the 90s middle class—the pressure to be a "perfect" child while a whirlwind of chaos (Fudge) is literally tearing up the wallpaper.
The show also gave us Sheila Tubman. Sheila, played by Sarah S. Ellis, was the perfect foil for Peter. The "Sheila the Great" episodes allowed the show to expand its world, showing that everyone has their own secret fears, even the bossy girl next door who claims she’s not afraid of anything. It added layers. It wasn't just the Fudge show; it was an ensemble piece about growing up.
How to Revisit the Hatcher Universe
Since the show isn't currently sitting on a major streamer like Netflix or Disney+, finding it takes a bit of effort. But it’s worth the hunt for anyone interested in the history of children’s media or those who want to show their own kids what "quality" used to look like before everything became a loud, CGI-fest.
Practical Steps for Fans and Collectors:
- Check Physical Archives: Look for the old VHS releases. They were distributed by MCA/Universal Home Video back in the day. Sometimes these pop up on eBay or in local thrift stores for a few bucks.
- Digital Sleuthing: There are dedicated fans who have uploaded high-quality rips of the original broadcasts, including the 90s commercials, which honestly adds to the experience.
- Read the Source: If the show makes you nostalgic, go back to the books. Double Fudge, the later entry in the series, wasn't fully explored in the show, so there’s "new" content there for those who only know the TV version.
- Support Judy Blume: The author is still a vocal advocate for children's literature and intellectual freedom. Following her current projects or the 2023 documentary Judy Blume Forever gives great context on why stories like Fudge were so revolutionary to begin with.
The Fudge TV show might be a "forgotten" gem to some, but to those who lived through it, it remains the definitive version of the Hatcher family. It was messy, it was loud, and it was exactly like real life. Only with more swallowed turtles.