Money doesn't buy happiness, but in baseball, it usually buys a really good left-handed power bat or a guy who throws 101 mph with a nasty sinker. If you've been following the stove this winter, you know the free agent signings MLB fans obsess over aren't just about the dollar signs. It’s about the "fit." It’s about that one missing piece that turns a 84-win team into a World Series threat.
Honestly? Most of the time we get it wrong.
We crown the "winners" of the offseason in January, only to watch their $200 million investment hit .210 by June. Baseball is weird like that. This cycle has been especially chaotic. From Juan Soto's historic payday to the Arizona Diamondbacks swinging for the fences with Corbin Burnes, the landscape of the league has shifted. Let’s get into what actually happened and why some of these massive contracts might keep GMs up at night.
The Massive Deals Everyone is Talking About
The big one. The whale. Juan Soto.
If you thought the Shohei Ohtani saga was a circus, the Soto sweepstakes were a full-blown carnival. He eventually landed with the New York Mets on a deal that basically requires its own ZIP code. We are talking about $765 million total. Yes, you read that right. While Ohtani’s $700 million deal had those massive deferrals that make the "present day value" lower, Soto’s deal is a different beast entirely. It puts his AAV (Average Annual Value) at a staggering $51 million.
Steve Cohen basically looked at the luxury tax and said, "Hold my drink."
But it wasn't just the Mets. The Toronto Blue Jays—who always seem to be the bridesmaid in these big negotiations—actually landed a monster of their own. They locked up Dylan Cease for seven years and $210 million. It’s a huge gamble on a guy who can be the best pitcher in the world one week and lose the strike zone the next. Toronto is betting that his high-ceiling stuff is the antidote to their AL East woes.
📖 Related: Why Netball Girls Sri Lanka Are Quietly Dominating Asian Sports
Quick Look at the Heavy Hitters:
- Juan Soto: NY Mets ($765M over 15 years)
- Dylan Cease: Blue Jays ($210M over 7 years)
- Alex Bregman: Cubs ($175M over 5 years)
- Corbin Burnes: Diamondbacks ($210M over 6 years)
- Pete Alonso: Orioles ($155M over 5 years)
The Pete Alonso move to Baltimore is particularly fascinating. Most people thought he was a "Met for life" kind of guy. But the Orioles, who have been hoarding prospects like a dragon with gold, finally decided to spend. Seeing the "Polar Bear" hit homers into the Eutaw Street walkway is going to be a trip for New York fans.
Why Some Free Agent Signings MLB Teams Make Are Huge Risks
It’s easy to get hyped about a new star, but the "buyer's remorse" in this sport is real.
Take the Alex Bregman signing with the Cubs. $175 million for a third baseman entering his age-32 season is... a lot. Bregman is a winning player, no doubt. He brings that "Astros DNA" and a high-contact bat. But third base is a position that can age poorly. If his range starts to go and that exit velocity dips, that $35 million a year is going to look like a massive anchor on Chicago’s payroll by 2028.
Then there is the Corbin Burnes situation in Arizona.
Burnes is an ace. Period. The Diamondbacks landed him for $210 million, which felt like a steal compared to some projections. But then the unthinkable happened: Tommy John surgery in June. Now, Arizona is paying top-tier ace money for a guy who will miss most, if not all, of the 2026 season. It’s the nightmare scenario. You spend the money to win now, and your investment is in a sling before the All-Star break.
The "Value" Signings That Actually Win Pennants
Everyone looks at the $100M+ guys, but the smart teams—the ones that actually play in October—usually win in the margins.
👉 See also: Why Cumberland Valley Boys Basketball Dominates the Mid-Penn (and What’s Next)
The Detroit Tigers bringing in Gleyber Torres on a one-year, $15 million deal? That’s smart business. He’s a guy who can hit .300 and play a decent second base, and if the Tigers aren't in it by July, he’s a massive trade chip. It’s a low-risk, high-reward move that doesn't tie up the books for a decade.
Similarly, the Dodgers re-signing Edwin Diaz for $69 million over three years. Look, the Dodgers have all the money in the world, but adding a "shutdown" closer to that bullpen was basically the rich getting richer. It’s not a "value" play in the sense of being cheap, but it’s a surgical strike to fix a specific weakness.
A Few Under-the-Radar Moves:
- Michael King staying in San Diego: Three years, $75M. He proved he’s a legitimate starter, and keeping him was vital for that rotation.
- Kazuma Okamoto to the Blue Jays: Four years, $60M. A huge power threat from Japan that could be the steal of the winter if his bat translates to MLB pitching.
- Justin Verlander to the Giants: One year, $15M. It’s the Giants doing what they do—betting on a veteran arm to find one last season of magic in that pitcher-friendly park.
What People Get Wrong About the "Market"
You often hear people say the "market is broken" because contracts are getting so high. But it’s not just about the total dollars. It’s about the revenue streams.
With the RSN (Regional Sports Network) crisis still looming over a lot of mid-market teams, we’re seeing a massive gap. You have the "Haves" (Mets, Dodgers, Yankees, Phillies) and the "Have-Nots" who are terrified to offer more than a three-year deal. This is why you see guys like Kyle Tucker or Bo Bichette sitting on the market longer than they should. Teams are scared of the long-term commitment when they don't know what their TV deal will look like in 2027.
It’s also why we see so many "creative" contracts now. Player options, opt-outs, and heavy deferrals are the new norm. It’s basically a way for GMs to tell their owners, "We’re spending the money, but we have an escape hatch if everything goes sideways."
Actionable Insights for Fans and Analysts
If you are trying to judge whether your team's new signing is actually good, don't just look at the home run totals.
✨ Don't miss: What Channel is Champions League on: Where to Watch Every Game in 2026
Watch the "Walk-to-Strikeout" ratio. Free agents who have elite plate discipline (like Soto or Bregman) tend to age much better than "free swingers" who rely on raw athleticism. When the bat speed slows down, the guys who know the strike zone can still contribute.
Check the "Innings Pitched" floor. For pitchers, the most expensive thing you can buy is a "fragile" ace. A guy like Framber Valdez might not have the highest strikeout rate, but he eats innings. In the modern game, a guy who gives you 190 innings of 3.60 ERA ball is often more valuable than a "flamethrower" who spends half the year on the IL.
The "Contract Year" effect is real, but so is the "New Team" slump. Don't panic if your team's big signing hits .190 in April. Moving cities, learning a new clubhouse, and the pressure of a $100 million contract can mess with anyone's head. Give it until June before you start calling the local sports talk radio to complain.
To truly understand the impact of the latest moves, you should track how these players perform relative to their AAV. A player making $30 million needs to produce roughly 4.0 to 5.0 WAR (Wins Above Replacement) to "break even" in the eyes of most front offices. Keep an eye on the injury reports for the aging veterans on 5+ year deals; that's where the real "value" of the offseason is won or lost.
Check your team's luxury tax space before getting upset they didn't sign the next big star. Sometimes, the best move is the one you don't make, especially when the "asking price" includes a decade of financial commitment.