You've probably seen the commercials. They usually feature someone sitting on a couch, looking stressed about their bills, until a friendly narrator promises a fast track to a high-paying career in medical billing or cybersecurity. That's the face of for-profit education, a massive, multi-billion dollar industry that treats learning more like a product on a shelf than a public good.
Honestly, it’s a weird space.
Unlike Harvard or your local community college, for-profit schools are businesses. They have owners. They have shareholders. They have marketing budgets that would make a car dealership jealous. While traditional schools reinvest their "profit" back into the campus or research, these institutions are legally obligated to make money for the people who own them. It’s a fundamental shift in why a school exists in the first place.
How For-Profit Education Actually Works
At its core, for-profit education is about efficiency and market demand. These schools—think University of Phoenix, Grand Canyon University (though their tax status has been a legal rollercoaster), or the now-defunct ITT Tech—don't usually care about "liberal arts" or "well-rounded citizens." They care about job placement and enrollment numbers.
They’re nimble. If there’s a sudden shortage of dental assistants in Phoenix, a for-profit school can spin up a program in months, whereas a state university might take years to get through the red tape of faculty senates and state boards.
But there’s a catch. A big one.
Because they operate as businesses, their primary revenue source is almost always tuition. And since most people don’t have $20,000 sitting under a mattress, that tuition comes from federal student loans. There’s a rule called the 90/10 rule. Basically, it says these schools can’t get more than 90% of their revenue from federal student aid. That leaves 10% coming from private sources or, more often, veterans using the GI Bill. This created a gold rush where some schools aggressively targeted veterans because they were essentially "walking 10 percents" that allowed the school to unlock even more federal funding.
The Marketing Machine
Ever wonder why you get five phone calls within ten minutes of clicking a link about a degree? That's the "lead generation" engine. For-profit colleges often spend more on marketing and recruiting than they do on actual instruction.
A 2012 report by the Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions (HELP) Committee found that some of these companies were spending upwards of 23% of their revenue on marketing. Imagine if your local high school spent a quarter of its budget on billboards and Facebook ads instead of teachers. It’s a jarring reality of the business model.
📖 Related: Reading a Crude Oil Barrel Price Chart Without Losing Your Mind
The Good, The Bad, and The Predatory
It’s not all scams. Let’s be real. For a single mom working two jobs, a strictly online, asynchronous program from a for-profit school might be the only way she can realistically get a degree. These schools pioneered the "adult learner" experience. They figured out online portals and evening classes long before the "prestige" schools were forced to do it by the pandemic.
However, the reputation of for-profit education has been dragged through the mud for a reason.
Remember Corinthian Colleges? They went bankrupt in 2015 after the Department of Education found they were misrepresenting job placement rates. They were telling students they’d get jobs at top-tier firms when, in reality, those jobs didn't exist or the "placement" was a temp gig at a grocery store. This led to the "borrower defense to repayment" surge, where the government had to forgive billions in loans because the schools essentially defrauded the students.
The Quality Gap
Education experts like Tressie McMillan Cottom, author of Lower Ed, argue that these schools sell "insurance against poverty" to people who have the least amount of social capital. If you don’t have connections, you buy a degree that promises a door will open.
But does it?
Studies often show that degrees from for-profit institutions don't carry the same weight as those from public or private non-profits. In audit studies—where researchers send out fake resumes that are identical except for the school—graduates from for-profit colleges get fewer callbacks. Employers sometimes view these degrees as "bought" rather than "earned," which is devastating when you realize the student likely paid double what they would have at a community college.
Comparing the Costs (It's Not Pretty)
Let's talk numbers. Usually, for-profit tuition sits in this awkward middle ground. It’s more expensive than a state school but "looks" cheaper than a private Ivy because they hide the true cost in monthly payments or high-interest private loans.
- Community College: Maybe $3,000–$5,000 a year.
- State University: $10,000–$15,000 a year (in-state).
- For-Profit: Often $18,000–$25,000 a year.
The debt-to-income ratio is where the floor falls out. If you borrow $40,000 for a degree that lands you a $35,000-a-year job, you're in a debt trap. According to the National Center for Education Statistics (NCES), students at for-profit colleges have much higher default rates on their loans compared to any other sector. They are more likely to leave without a degree at all, saddled with debt and no increased earning power.
👉 See also: Is US Stock Market Open Tomorrow? What to Know for the MLK Holiday Weekend
Why Do People Still Enroll?
Convenience is a hell of a drug.
If you call a major state university, you might get a voicemail. If you click a "Learn More" button for a for-profit, a recruiter will call you, walk you through the FAFSA, help you sign the papers, and tell you that you start Monday. They remove the friction. For someone who has been told they aren't "college material," that level of hand-holding is incredibly seductive.
There's also the "prestige" camouflage. Many for-profits have names that sound like traditional, established universities. They use imagery of ivy-covered walls and graduation caps in their ads. Unless you're looking for the fine print that says "a for-profit institution," you might not even realize there's a difference.
The Regulatory War
The government has been trying to rein this in for decades. Under the Obama administration, the "Gainful Employment" rule was created. It basically said: "If your graduates don't make enough money to pay back their loans, we're cutting off your federal funding."
The industry fought back hard.
Lobbying groups like Career Education Colleges and Universities (CECU) spend millions to argue that they serve "underserved" populations that traditional schools ignore. The regulations get tightened, then loosened when administrations change, then tightened again. It’s a game of legal whack-a-mole. In 2023, the Biden administration moved to strengthen these rules again, focusing on transparency and making sure schools aren't leading students into a financial black hole.
Is It Ever Worth It?
Maybe. Sometimes.
If you are looking for a very specific certificate—like a specialized welding certification or a high-end coding bootcamp (which often operate on a for-profit model)—and the school has verifiable, audited data showing their grads actually get hired at a living wage, it can work.
✨ Don't miss: Big Lots in Potsdam NY: What Really Happened to Our Store
But you have to be a detective.
You have to look past the glossy brochures. Check the "College Scorecard" provided by the U.S. Department of Education. If the "median debt" is higher than the "median earnings" ten years after entry, run. Fast.
What to Look for Before You Sign
Don't trust the recruiter. Their job is to close the deal.
- Check Accreditation: Make sure it’s "regionally accredited," not just "nationally accredited." Ironically, regional is the gold standard that allows you to transfer credits to other major universities.
- The Transfer Test: Call the local state university and ask if they accept credits from the for-profit school you're considering. If they laugh or say no, that degree is an island—you can't build on it later.
- The Faculty: Are the teachers full-time professors or underpaid adjuncts working five jobs? Instruction quality matters.
- The 90/10 Ratio: Search for the school's financial disclosures. If they are hovering at 89% federal funding, they are one bad semester away from a total collapse.
Moving Toward a Decision
If you're looking at for-profit education, you're likely at a crossroads in your life. You want something better. That's a good thing. But the business of education is full of pitfalls designed to capture your future earnings before you've even made them.
Before you commit to a for-profit program, do the "Community College First" check. Almost every program offered by a for-profit school exists at a community college for a third of the price. The "speed" they promise is often just a condensed schedule that you could replicate yourself with some discipline.
Take a breath. Ignore the "only 2 seats left!" high-pressure sales tactics. Education is the most expensive thing you'll ever buy besides a house; you wouldn't buy a house because a guy on the phone told you to hurry up. Treat your tuition with the same skepticism.
Next Steps for You:
Go to the U.S. Department of Education College Scorecard and type in the name of the school you're considering. Look specifically at the "Graduation Rate" and "Salary After Completing." Compare those two numbers to your local community college. If the for-profit school’s numbers aren't significantly higher despite the higher cost, you have your answer. Finally, search for the school’s name followed by "litigation" or "class action" to see what former students are saying in court, not just on Yelp.