It was ugly. Honestly, there is no other way to describe the Florida vs FSU 2024 game without acknowledging the sheer, unadulterated chaos that unfolded at Doak Campbell Stadium on November 30. If you were looking for a clinic in modern, high-flying offense, you probably turned the TV off by the second quarter. But if you wanted to see what happens when two historic programs, both reeling from seasons they’d rather forget, decide to settle things in the mud? That’s exactly what we got.
Florida won. 31-11.
That score looks somewhat comfortable on paper, but it doesn't tell the story of the tension in Tallahassee that night. The Gators entered the game finally finding a bit of an identity under Billy Napier, who had just been confirmed to return for 2025. Meanwhile, Mike Norvell and Florida State were staring down the barrel of a 1-11 season—a collapse so statistically improbable for a pre-season Top 10 team that it felt like a fever dream for the Noles faithful.
The DJ Lagway Factor and Why It Changed Everything
You can’t talk about the Florida vs FSU 2024 matchup without focusing on DJ Lagway. The true freshman quarterback is basically the reason Billy Napier still has a job. Coming off a massive upset win over LSU and a strong showing against Ole Miss, Lagway brought a vertical threat to the Gators that Graham Mertz, despite his efficiency, just didn't quite provide.
Lagway didn't have to be perfect. He just had to be explosive.
He finished the night with some modest stats—completing about half his passes—but he hit the shots that mattered. The 77-yard bomb to Elijhah Badger was the backbreaker. It felt like the air just got sucked right out of the stadium. When you have a kid who can flick his wrist and put the ball 60 yards downfield, it changes how a defense has to play. Florida State’s secondary, which had been one of the few semi-functional units for them during the year, simply couldn't stay disciplined for four quarters against that kind of arm talent.
FSU’s defense actually played okay for a while. They really did. They forced some punts and kept it a one-score game heading into the halftime break. But the offense? Man, the FSU offense was a disaster.
Florida State’s Offensive Identity Crisis
If you’re an FSU fan, you’ve probably spent most of the last few months wondering how it got this bad this fast. Going from an undefeated regular season in 2023 to whatever this was is historically unprecedented. In the Florida vs FSU 2024 game, the quarterback situation was a microcosm of their entire year.
🔗 Read more: Why Funny Fantasy Football Names Actually Win Leagues
Brock Glenn and Luke Kromenhoek both saw time. Neither could get anything going.
The Gators' defense, led by Tyrane Thornton and a resurgent front seven, lived in the FSU backfield. Florida recorded five sacks. They forced turnovers. They made life miserable for a Seminoles offensive line that looked like it was playing on ice skates at times. It’s hard to win a rivalry game when you can’t run the ball for more than three yards a carry. It’s even harder when your passing game consists almost entirely of check-downs and prayers.
Basically, FSU was playing with a hand tied behind its back because they never replaced the production of Jordan Travis or the elite playmaking of Keon Coleman and Johnny Wilson. You saw the result. A lot of three-and-outs. A lot of frustrated fans in garnet and gold heading for the exits before the fourth quarter even started.
The Turning Point Most People Missed
Everyone talks about the Badger touchdown, but the real momentum shift happened on a sloppy sequence in the third quarter. Florida State had a chance to cut the lead to three. They had the ball in Florida territory.
Then came the penalties.
A false start. A holding call. Suddenly it’s 3rd and long, and the Gators bring a blitz that FSU wasn't ready for. The ensuing sack knocked them out of field goal range. Instead of a 14-11 game, it stayed 14-8, and Florida marched right down the field on the next possession to extend the lead. That's the difference between a team that’s starting to believe in its process and a team that’s just waiting for the clock to hit zero on a miserable season.
How Florida vs FSU 2024 Reshaped the Recruiting Trail
College football isn't just played on Saturdays; it's played in the living rooms of high school juniors and seniors. This specific edition of the Sunshine Showdown had massive implications for the state's recruiting rankings.
💡 You might also like: Heisman Trophy Nominees 2024: The Year the System Almost Broke
Florida was able to walk into the homes of top-tier recruits the following week and say, "Look at the trajectory." They could point to Lagway. They could point to the way the defense improved over the final month of the season.
- Florida’s Momentum: They finished the year strong, securing a bowl berth that felt impossible in September.
- FSU’s Rebuild: Norvell had to go back to the drawing board, firing both coordinators shortly after this game.
- The Portal: Both teams knew that Monday morning would start a different kind of war—the transfer portal.
For Florida, the win solidified that the "Napier Plan" might actually work if given enough time. For FSU, it was the rock bottom they needed to justify a total scorched-earth policy regarding their coaching staff and roster construction.
The Atmosphere in Tallahassee
I’ve been to a lot of these games. Usually, Doak is vibrating. The chop is deafening. But during the Florida vs FSU 2024 game, it felt... different. There was a weird mix of apathy and anger.
The "Fire Everyone" chants were audible on the broadcast.
When Florida’s Montrell Johnson Jr. broke off a late touchdown run to put the game iced away, the Gator fans who traveled to Tallahassee made it sound like a home game in Gainesville. It was a complete role reversal from the year before when FSU went into the Swamp and kept their playoff hopes alive.
What the Numbers Don't Show
If you just look at the box score, you see 31-11. You don't see the missed assignments. You don't see the three dropped interceptions by the FSU defense that could have changed the complexion of the first half. You don't see the way DJ Lagway was limping slightly in the fourth quarter but refused to come out.
Rivalry games are about grit. Florida had it. FSU was searching for it and couldn't find it.
📖 Related: When Was the MLS Founded? The Chaotic Truth About American Soccer's Rebirth
The Gators outgained the Seminoles by nearly 150 yards. They won the time of possession battle. They won the turnover battle. In the most basic terms of football, they were just the better-coached, more disciplined team on that particular Saturday.
Looking Ahead: The Aftermath
So, where do they go from here?
Florida heads into the offseason with a ton of hype. They’ve got their quarterback of the future. They’ve got a defense that finally stopped leaking points like a rusted pipe. The narrative around Billy Napier has shifted from "Warm Seat" to "Wait and See."
Florida State is in a much darker place. The 1-11 finish is a stain that won't wash off easily. Norvell has to prove that 2023 wasn't a fluke fueled solely by a veteran roster, but that he can actually build a program from the ground up again.
Actionable Insights for the 2025 Season
If you’re a fan or a bettor looking at these two programs following the Florida vs FSU 2024 outcome, keep these things in mind:
- Watch the Gators' O-Line: Lagway is great, but he was under pressure a lot. If Florida doesn't hit the portal hard for tackles, his sophomore year might be tougher than people think.
- FSU’s Total Reset: Expect at least 20+ new faces in Tallahassee via the portal. Do not judge the 2025 Noles based on the 2024 roster. It’s going to be a completely different team.
- The Coaching Carousel: Florida kept their staff mostly intact for stability. FSU is starting over. History says the team with continuity usually wins the following year's matchup, but keep an eye on who Norvell hires to run that offense.
The 2024 game wasn't a masterpiece. It was a demolition. Florida didn't just win a football game; they signaled a power shift in the state that had been tilting toward Tallahassee for two years. Now, the ball is back in Gainesville's court.
Whether they can keep it there is the only question that matters now.
Next Steps for Fans:
Start tracking the spring practice reports for both teams in March. Specifically, look at DJ Lagway’s command of the full playbook and whether FSU has found a quarterback who can throw a ten-yard out route with any consistency. The "Way-Too-Early" Top 25 rankings usually drop in January, but don't buy the hype until you see the final portal additions in May.