Jordan Travis was the heart of Tallahassee. Seriously. If you followed college football at all that year, you know the Florida State quarterback 2023 story isn't just about stats or a depth chart. It’s a Shakespearean tragedy played out on a grass field in the Florida panhandle.
One minute, the Noles are 10-0, Travis is a Heisman frontrunner, and fans are booking flights to the College Football Playoff. The next? A horrific leg injury against North Alabama on Senior Night changes everything. It didn't just end a season; it sparked a national debate that basically broke the sport's postseason system.
The Jordan Travis Era: More Than Just a Dual Threat
People forget how much Travis evolved. Back in 2020, he was mostly a runner who threw the ball when he absolutely had to. By 2023, he was a surgeon.
He finished his regular season with 2,756 passing yards, 20 touchdowns, and—this is the wild part—only 2 interceptions. He wasn't just "playing" quarterback; he was managing one of the most explosive offenses in the country. With targets like Keon Coleman and Johnny Wilson, Travis looked invincible.
Then came November 18.
It was a "cupcake" game. North Alabama. A night meant for celebrations and saying goodbye to legends. Late in the first quarter, Travis scrambled, got tackled awkwardly, and the stadium went silent. You could hear a pin drop in Doak Campbell. The air cast came out. The cart came out.
📖 Related: Matthew Berry Positional Rankings: Why They Still Run the Fantasy Industry
Honestly, the energy in that stadium never truly recovered.
Who Took the Reins? The Backup Carousel
When your superstar goes down, the "next man up" mantra sounds great in locker rooms, but it's a nightmare in reality.
Tate Rodemaker was the first guy up. He’d been in the program forever—a redshirt junior who had stayed loyal when most kids would have entered the transfer portal years ago. He actually did a decent job. He led the comeback against North Alabama and then went into the Swamp and beat the Florida Gators.
- Tate Rodemaker 2023 Stats: 510 yards, 5 TDs, 0 INTs.
But football is cruel. Rodemaker took a massive hit against Florida and ended up with a concussion. Suddenly, the Florida State quarterback 2023 situation went from "concerning" to "total panic."
Enter Brock Glenn.
👉 See also: What Time Did the Cubs Game End Today? The Truth About the Off-Season
Glenn was a true freshman. He was basically a kid thrown into a furnace. His first career start? The ACC Championship game against a nasty Louisville defense. He went 8-of-21 for 55 yards. It was ugly. It was gritty. But they won. FSU moved to 13-0 and won the conference.
The Snub Heard 'Round the World
This is where the Florida State quarterback 2023 narrative turns into a legal drama.
Despite being 13-0, the CFP Committee looked at FSU without Jordan Travis and said, "Nah." They dropped the Noles to #5, putting one-loss Alabama and Texas ahead of them. The reasoning? Without Travis, they weren't one of the "four best teams."
It was the first time an undefeated Power Five champion was left out.
The aftermath was a mess. Rodemaker decided to transfer. FSU had to play Georgia in the Orange Bowl with a depleted roster and Brock Glenn at the helm again. They lost 63-3. It was a blowout of historic proportions, but it’s hard to judge a team that had already had its soul ripped out by the committee.
✨ Don't miss: Jake Ehlinger Sign: The Real Story Behind the College GameDay Controversy
Why 2023 Still Matters for FSU Fans
If you're looking for the ripple effects, look at the transfer portal and the lawsuits. Florida State is currently suing the ACC to leave the conference, and a lot of that frustration stems from the feeling that they were devalued because of one injury.
Jordan Travis eventually got drafted by the New York Jets in the 5th round, but his recovery was slow. In early 2025, he actually announced his medical retirement because the leg just wouldn't get back to 100%. It's a heavy ending for a guy who gave everything to that program.
Actionable Takeaways from the 2023 FSU QB Saga
- Depth is everything: If you're building a roster in modern college football, your QB3 needs to be a guy you trust, not just a developmental project.
- The "Best" vs. "Most Deserving" Debate: This season proved that the CFP committee values "eye test" and roster health over actual wins and losses.
- Injury Management: The way Mike Norvell handled the transition from Travis to Rodemaker to Glenn showed a coach trying to protect his players while chasing a title, a balancing act that is nearly impossible.
If you want to understand why Florida State fans are so loud about the current state of college football, you have to look back at 2023. It was a perfect season that ended in a way no one saw coming, all because of a single play on a Saturday night in November.
Check out the official FSU athletics site or the 2023 season archives if you want to see the full play-by-play of how those games actually went down.
Next Steps for FSU Fans: You can research the ongoing litigation between FSU and the ACC to see how the fallout from 2023 is still affecting the school's future. You might also want to track Jordan Travis’s transition into coaching or mentorship, as he remains a massive figure in the Tallahassee community.