You’ve probably heard of Fisher Island. Or, wait—did you mean Fishers Island?
People mix them up constantly. One is a billionaire’s tropical paradise off the coast of Miami where you need a ferry and a golden ticket to enter. The other—the one we're talking about—is a rugged, seven-mile-long sliver of land sitting in the mouth of the Long Island Sound.
Fisher Island NY weather is its own animal.
It’s technically part of Southold, New York, but honestly, it feels much more like a runaway piece of Connecticut or Rhode Island. Because it’s an island floating between the Sound and the Atlantic, the climate behaves differently than the mainland. It’s "oceanic," which basically means the water is the boss.
If you're planning a trip or just curious why your weather app is lying to you, here is what’s actually happening out there on the eastern edge of the Sound.
The Maritime Microclimate Mystery
Most folks assume that if it’s 90 degrees in New York City, it’s 90 degrees on the island.
✨ Don't miss: Getting to Burning Man: What You Actually Need to Know About the Journey
Wrong.
The ocean has a high specific heat capacity. That’s a fancy way of saying the water takes a long time to warm up and a long time to cool down. In the summer, the surrounding water acts like a giant air conditioner. While people in Groton or Southold are melting in 85-degree humidity, Fishers Island is often sitting at a breezy 76 or 78 degrees.
The Summer Reality
- July Highs: Usually top out around 80°F to 84°F.
- The "Muggy" Factor: It gets humid, but the offshore winds usually keep it from feeling like a swamp.
- The Afternoon Breeze: Like clockwork, a southwest wind usually kicks up in the afternoon.
On the flip side, the island stays warmer later into the fall. While the mainland gets hit with early October frosts, the "warm" water (it's all relative, right?) keeps the air temperate. The first frost on the island usually doesn't hit until the very end of October.
Winter is Cold, But Not How You Think
Winter on the island is a test of character.
🔗 Read more: Tiempo en East Hampton NY: What the Forecast Won't Tell You About Your Trip
It isn't necessarily colder than the mainland—in fact, January lows often hover around 22°F, which is a bit milder than inland Connecticut. The problem is the wind.
March is actually the windiest month here, with averages around 17 mph, but gusts off the Atlantic can scream across the rocky till and make 35 degrees feel like 10. You aren't just dealing with temperature; you're dealing with raw, salty exposure.
Snow vs. Rain
Snow is hit or miss. Because the island is surrounded by "warm" salt water, many storms that dump a foot of snow on the mainland end up as a slushy, rainy mess on Fishers. You'll see about 3 to 4 inches of snowfall in January and February, but it rarely sticks around as long as it does in the Hudson Valley.
The Storm History Nobody Talks About
You can't talk about Fisher Island NY weather without mentioning the big one.
The Great New England Hurricane of 1938 absolutely hammered this place. It made its second landfall right near here, and the recorded wind speeds were terrifying. We're talking sustained winds of 109 mph.
💡 You might also like: Finding Your Way: What the Lake Placid Town Map Doesn’t Tell You
During that storm, the water surged over Money Pond. Boats were tossed onto the docks like toys. Even today, the island's landscape—the way the trees lean and the way the shoreline is shaped—is a direct result of being in the firing line for Atlantic nor’easters and hurricanes.
When a storm hits now, the ferry from New London, CT is the first thing to go. If the wind is blowing the wrong way, you are stuck. Period.
When to Actually Visit (The Expert Take)
If you want the "perfect" weather, go in September.
Most people aim for July, but July is actually the month with the most "wet days" (around 12 on average). September is the sweet spot. The water is at its warmest for swimming (usually mid-60s, which is as good as it gets), the crowds are gone, and the air is crisp but still hits the low 70s.
Plus, September has the most clear, sunny days.
Actionable Tips for Navigating the Island Weather
Don't trust a generic "New York" forecast. If you're heading out, follow these steps to stay ahead of the elements:
- Check the KGON Feed: Look at the weather data from Groton-New London Airport (KGON). It’s only a few miles away and is much more accurate for the island than a station in Southold.
- The 10-Degree Rule: Always pack a windbreaker or a light fleece, even in August. The temperature can drop 10 degrees the moment the sun goes down or the wind shifts.
- Ferry Monitoring: If gusts are predicted over 30-35 knots, start checking the Fishers Island Ferry District updates. They don't take risks with those heavy swells in the "Race" (the high-current area nearby).
- Sunscreen is Non-Negotiable: The reflection off the water and the white sand beaches means you’ll burn twice as fast as you would in a backyard.
Fisher Island NY weather is unpredictable, occasionally harsh, but mostly just refreshing. Just remember to respect the wind—it's the real owner of the island.