Let’s be real for a second. Most of what we think we know about the first time doing anal comes from either bad porn or playground rumors that have been passed down like some sort of weird, terrifying folklore. It’s a bit of a taboo subject, even in 2026. But honestly? It shouldn't be. Whether you're curious, nervous, or just trying to figure out if you need a specific type of lube, getting the facts straight is the difference between a great experience and a literal pain in the butt.
The anatomy involved is unique. Unlike the vaginal canal, the anus doesn't self-lubricate. It’s a one-way street by design, guarded by two sets of sphincter muscles that are basically the body's bouncers. If those bouncers aren't happy, nobody is getting in. That’s why the "just go for it" approach usually ends in a bad time.
Preparation is everything.
Why the first time doing anal feels so intimidating
It’s mostly the unknown. People worry about pain, they worry about "messes," and they worry about "doing it wrong." Dr. Evan Goldstein, a pelvic surgeon and founder of Bespoke Surgical, often points out that the biggest hurdle is actually psychological. When you're nervous, your body tenses up. When your body tenses up, those sphincter muscles clench shut. It’s a biological feedback loop that makes penetration difficult.
You've probably heard that it's supposed to hurt. That's a myth. Discomfort? Maybe a little bit of a "full" sensation. But sharp pain is a signal from your nervous system that something is wrong. You have to listen to that.
The science of the "O" factor
The reason people enjoy this isn't just about the taboo. It’s about nerve endings. The anus is packed with them. For those with a prostate, anal stimulation can lead to what’s often called the "male G-spot" orgasm, which many describe as more intense and full-bodied than a standard climax. For everyone else, the proximity to the back of the vaginal wall and the shared nerve pathways means it can trigger indirect stimulation that feels entirely different from anything else.
But you can't rush the biology. The external sphincter is under your voluntary control, but the internal one is autonomic. You can't just "will" it to open; you have to coax it.
Lubrication is not optional
If there is one hill to die on, it is this: use more lube than you think you need. Then add more.
Since there’s no natural moisture, friction is the enemy. It can cause micro-tears in the delicate mucosal lining. You want something thick. Water-based lubes are fine, but they dry out fast. Silicone-based options stay slippery much longer, though you can't use them with silicone toys because they’ll degrade the material.
- Water-based: Easy cleanup, toy-safe, but needs constant reapplication.
- Silicone-based: Long-lasting, very slick, but can stain sheets.
- Hybrid: A mix of both, often the "Goldilocks" choice for beginners.
Avoid anything with "tingling" or "warming" sensations for your first time doing anal. Those chemicals can be incredibly irritating to sensitive tissues. Keep it simple. Stick to high-quality, pH-balanced formulas.
The "Cleanliness" Conversation
Everyone thinks about it. Everyone is scared of it.
Here’s the truth: It’s the rectum. It’s where poop lives. However, the rectum is usually empty unless you actually have to go. Most experts, including those at the Mayo Clinic, suggest that a simple bowel movement and a shower are usually enough for most people to feel comfortable.
If you want extra peace of mind, some people use a bulb syringe or a small enema. Just don't overdo it. The gut has a delicate microbiome. Blasting it with gallons of water or harsh soaps is a recipe for irritation and can actually make the tissue more prone to tearing. Keep it light. Be gentle. Honestly, putting a towel down is the easiest way to stop worrying and start focusing on the actual experience.
Communication and the "Stop" Rule
You need a partner you trust. This isn't the time for a random hookup who doesn't listen.
Establish a "red light" system. If it hurts, you stop. Not "slow down," not "wait a minute," but stop. You can try again in a few minutes, or you can decide it's not happening today. That's okay. Consent isn't just a one-time "yes"; it’s a constant, ongoing conversation.
Start small (Literally)
Don't go from zero to sixty. Start with a finger. Use plenty of lube.
The goal here is to get used to the sensation of something being there. Use "external" play first. Massaging the area helps blood flow and relaxes the muscles. When—and only when—the person receiving feels ready, move to a single, well-lubricated finger.
Wait for the "push-back" feeling to subside. There’s a reflex where the sphincter initially resists. If you wait a few seconds, it usually relaxes. That’s your cue to proceed.
Position matters more than you think
Gravity is your friend or your enemy here.
Many people find that lying on their stomach with a pillow under their hips is the easiest way to start. It allows for a shallow angle of entry. Others prefer "spooning" because it feels more intimate and less clinical.
The "cowgirl" or "cowboy" position (on top) is actually great for the person receiving because it gives them total control over the depth, speed, and angle. If it feels like too much, you just lift up. Simple.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Using Numbing Creams: This is a big one. Numbing sprays or creams (like lidocaine) seem like a good idea, but they are actually dangerous. Pain is your body’s way of saying "hey, we're tearing something." If you can't feel the pain, you won't know if you're causing actual damage.
- Going Too Fast: This isn't a race. The tissues need time to stretch and accommodate.
- Forgetting the "Exit" Protocol: When you're done, be gentle. The muscles have been stretched and might feel a bit sensitive or "weird" for an hour or so.
What about the "Day After"?
You might feel a little bit of "fullness" or a mild urge to use the bathroom. That’s normal. What isn't normal is heavy bleeding or sharp, stabbing abdominal pain. If that happens, see a doctor. But for 99% of people, if you used enough lube and went slow, you’ll feel totally fine by the next morning.
Moving forward with confidence
It’s just another way to experience intimacy. It doesn't have to be a huge, dramatic event. By stripping away the stigma and looking at the actual physiology, it becomes much less scary.
Actionable Steps for Success:
💡 You might also like: Why Foods That Give You Gas Are Actually a Sign Your Gut Is Working
- Buy a high-quality silicone or hybrid lubricant before you even think about starting. Cheap stuff isn't worth the risk.
- Practice solo first. Using a small, smooth toy or a finger in the shower helps you understand your own body's limits without the pressure of a partner being there.
- Trim your nails. This is a practical one—scratches are no fun.
- Focus on breathing. Deep, diaphragmatic breaths help relax the pelvic floor muscles. If you hold your breath, you clench.
- Set the mood. Stress is the ultimate muscle-tightener. Ensure you have plenty of time and won't be interrupted.
The first time doing anal is a learning experience. It might not be perfect the first time, and that is perfectly okay. Most couples find that it takes a few tries to really find the rhythm and techniques that work for them. Focus on the connection, stay relaxed, and remember that communication is the most important tool in your kit.