Everyone thinks they’ve got a "lock" when it comes to the first touchdown. You see the star running back, you see the juicy +500 odds, and you think it’s free money. Honestly? It's usually a trap. Betting on the first person to cross the pylon is a chaotic, high-variance mess that humbles even the sharpest statistical models.
But there is a logic to the madness.
If you want to get serious about first td scorer predictions, you have to stop looking at who scores the most touchdowns and start looking at who scores first. These are two completely different skill sets in an NFL playbook.
✨ Don't miss: Kobe Black and Yellow Shoes: What Really Happened with the Bruce Lee Legacy
The Red Zone Reality Check
Most casual fans look at a player’s season total and call it a day. "Derrick Henry has 15 touchdowns, so he's obviously the best bet." Well, not necessarily. In the 2025 season, we saw fascinating splits that prove volume doesn't always equal "first." For instance, James Cook in Buffalo became a first-score machine, hitting the first TD of the game six times since the start of 2024. That’s top-tier efficiency. Meanwhile, guys like Josh Allen are always lurking, but their value often gets swallowed up by the books.
You've gotta look at the opening script.
NFL coaches like Andy Reid or Kyle Shanahan spend all week obsessing over the first 15 to 20 plays of a game. These plays are practiced until they’re robotic. If a team has a tendency to lean on a specific "Z" receiver or a tight end in those scripted plays, that’s where the gold is. In 2025, the Buffalo Bills led the league by scoring 9 touchdowns on their opening drives. If you weren't looking at Buffalo players for your first td scorer predictions during that stretch, you were basically throwing money away.
Who Actually Gets the Ball?
The data from the 2025-2026 season tells a specific story about "The Alphas" versus "The Opportunists."
- Kyren Williams (Rams): He’s been a monster, scoring the first TD in 4 different games this season alone.
- Davante Adams: Now with the Rams, he’s still the king of the 10-yard line. The Rams WRs combined for 16 touchdowns inside the 10-yard line—more than any other unit in the league.
- Hunter Henry: Here’s a sleeper for you. While his overall target share for the Patriots hovered around 18%, that number skyrocketed to 33.8% inside the red zone.
When the field shrinks, the targets narrow. If you're betting on a deep-threat receiver who relies on 50-yard bombs, you're hoping for a miracle. If you're betting on a tight end with a massive frame who the QB trusts when the windows get tight, you're playing the percentages.
Why the Coin Toss Actually Matters
It sounds like a joke, right? It’s a 50/50 flip. But the coin toss dictates who gets the ball first, and in this market, that is everything. Some teams are "defer" junkies. They want the ball to start the second half. If you’re betting on a player from a team that always kicks off, you are essentially betting that their defense will force a punt or a turnover immediately. That’s a lot of extra "ifs" added to your ticket.
Check the home/away splits too. In 2025, Philadelphia was almost unstoppable at home in the red zone, converting at a 70.37% clip. Away from home? Still good, but the rhythm is different.
The Math Behind the Odds
You’ll see +400, +800, maybe even +2200 for a defensive score. The implied probability of a +500 bet is roughly 16.6%. The books are usually pretty good at this, but they struggle with "usage shifts."
👉 See also: Khris Middleton Game Log: Why the Veteran's Role is Shifting in 2026
Take D'Andre Swift and Kyle Monangai in Chicago. By the end of 2025, it was a near 50/50 split in the backfield. However, Swift had a massive advantage on "outside zone" runs—a scheme the Rams (his Divisional Round opponent) struggled against, allowing 4.7 yards per carry. When you find a specific schematic weakness like that, your first td scorer predictions suddenly have an edge that the raw season stats won't show you.
Stats to Obsess Over
Don't just look at yards. Look at:
- Red Zone Target Share: Who does the QB look at when they're 15 yards out?
- Goal Line Carries: Is the "lead back" getting pulled for a "vulture" like a Taysom Hill type?
- First Drive TD%: Does the OC have a "hot start" reputation?
Breaking Down the Positions
Running backs are the "safe" play, but the value is rarely there. Quarterback sneaks have become the bane of the FTD (First Touchdown) bettor's existence. Josh Allen and Jalen Hurts are basically goal-line running backs who happen to throw the ball. If you're betting a Bills or Eagles RB, you have to factor in the very real possibility that the QB just tucks it and runs it in himself from the 2-yard line.
📖 Related: Why the Seattle Seahawks Record 2013 Still Haunts the Rest of the NFL
Wide receivers offer the best "bang for your buck" if they are the primary red zone target. Look at Puka Nacua. Even with Davante Adams in town, Nacua was targeted 18 times in a single playoff game. That kind of volume in a high-powered offense is a signal you can't ignore.
How to Actually Build a Winning Strategy
Stop betting on five different players in one game. You're just competing against yourself. Instead, pick a game where you have a "strong conviction" about how the first ten minutes will go.
If you think a team like the Seahawks—who scored 4 TDs from their own territory in 2025—is going to come out firing, look at their explosive playmakers like Zach Charbonnet or Jaxon Smith-Njigba. Charbonnet, for instance, had a stretch where he scored the first TD of the game in two consecutive weeks. He’s a "hot hand" player.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Slate:
- Audit the Inactives: If a starting left tackle is out, the run game might stall. This shifts the first TD likelihood toward the passing game.
- Track First Possession Data: Use sites like BettingPros or Sharp Football to see which teams actually score on their first drive. The Patriots and Bills were elite at this in 2025.
- Shop the Lines: One book might have a player at +600 while another has them at +850. In a market this volatile, those 250 points are the difference between a winning season and a losing one.
- Watch the Weather: High winds kill the passing game. If it’s blowing 20mph in Buffalo, stop looking at the WRs and start looking at the guys who move the pile.
Predicting the first score is partly science and partly just surviving the chaos. You can't account for a random 60-yard fumble return, but you can account for who a coach trusts when the game script is fresh and the stakes are high. Focus on the scripted plays, the red zone share, and the coin toss tendencies. That's how you move from guessing to actually predicting.
Next Steps:
Go check the "First Drive TD%" for the teams playing this weekend. Identify the top two teams that consistently score on their opening possession. Once you have those teams, look at their last three games to see which specific player received the first touch inside the 20-yard line. That player is your primary target for your next set of wagers.