Green Bay was freezing. Thousands of fans packed the Titletown District outside Lambeau Field last April, shivering in the Wisconsin spring, all waiting to see if the hype around the first round NFL Draft 2025 would actually deliver. It did, but not in the way the mock drafts predicted. Everyone spent months obsessing over whether a "weak" quarterback class would sink the league's interest. Instead, we got a night defined by "trench warfare" and a defensive resurgence that we haven't seen in nearly a decade.
The Tennessee Titans didn't overthink it. They stayed at number one and took Cam Ward. Honestly, it was the most predictable move of the night. Ward, coming off a massive year at Miami where he posted an FBS-best 92.9 PFF grade, was the only "sure thing" under center. But after that? The script basically flew out the window.
The Travis Hunter Chaos and the Trade That Shook the Top Five
If you want to understand why this draft felt so different, you have to look at the Jacksonville Jaguars. They didn't just pick; they hunted. In a massive draft-day trade, the Jaguars moved up to the second spot, sending a haul to Cleveland to secure Travis Hunter.
Hunter is a unicorn. You've heard it a million times, but seeing a guy get drafted to play both wide receiver and cornerback in the top three is historic. Most pundits thought he’d be a distraction or that his workload would be unmanageable. Jacksonville bet the house that he’s the best pure athlete to enter the league since Deion Sanders.
While Hunter grabbed the headlines, the New York Giants were arguably the smartest team in the building. They sat at three and took Abdul Carter, the Penn State edge rusher. It was a "bully ball" move. By pairing Carter with Brian Burns and Kayvon Thibodeaux, the Giants signaled that they don't care about the modern "pass-happy" meta; they just want to ruin every opposing quarterback's Sunday.
Trenches over Targets
Check out how the top of the board actually shook out. It wasn't the receiver-fest we saw in 2024.
- Tennessee Titans: Cam Ward, QB (Miami)
- Jacksonville Jaguars: Travis Hunter, WR/CB (Colorado)
- New York Giants: Abdul Carter, EDGE (Penn State)
- New England Patriots: Will Campbell, OT (LSU)
- Cleveland Browns: Mason Graham, DT (Michigan)
New England taking Will Campbell at four was a "meat and potatoes" pick. Campbell had some scouts worried about his 32-inch arms—people love to obsess over arm length—but his tape at LSU was dominant. He allowed only one sack all of 2024. If you have Drake Maye, you protect him. It’s that simple.
Why the Quarterback "Slide" Was the Real Story
The biggest shocker of the first round NFL Draft 2025 wasn't who got picked, but who didn't. Specifically, Shedeur Sanders.
📖 Related: Ashton Jeanty Michael Myers Stance: Why the NFL Tried to Kill It (And Failed)
Early in the cycle, people were mocking Shedeur to go number one overall. There were rumors of "Deion-led" interference and specific team preferences. But as the night wore on, the cameras kept cutting to the green room, and Shedeur was still there. He didn't just slide out of the top ten; he fell out of the first round entirely.
NFL front offices were clearly spooked by the perceived "lack of depth" in the 2025 QB class. Aside from Cam Ward, only one other quarterback heard his name called on Thursday night: Jaxson Dart.
The Giants, after already grabbing Abdul Carter at three, decided to get aggressive. They traded back into the end of the round (pick 25) to snag the Ole Miss signal-caller. It’s a fascinating "low-risk, high-reward" move. Dart has a huge arm and was the highest-graded passer in this class according to some metrics, but he’s likely going to sit behind a veteran like Russell Wilson for a year.
The Winners and the Head-Scratchers
The Chicago Bears are basically trying to build a Super Bowl team in a single offseason. Taking Colston Loveland, the Michigan tight end, at pick ten was a masterstroke for Caleb Williams' development. Loveland is a mismatch nightmare. If you’re a defensive coordinator, how do you cover DJ Moore, Rome Odunze, and Loveland at the same time? You probably don't.
On the flip side, the Carolina Panthers taking Tetairoa McMillan at eight felt... safe? McMillan is huge (6'4") and catches everything, which Bryce Young desperately needs. But he isn't a burner. In a league that prizes elite speed, taking a "possession" guy in the top ten is a gamble.
Late Round Values
- Pittsburgh Steelers: Derrick Harmon (DT, Oregon) at 21. Absolute steal. He’s a mountain of a man who fits that gritty Pittsburgh identity perfectly.
- Baltimore Ravens: Malaki Starks (S, Georgia) at 27. Of course the Ravens got the best safety in the draft at the end of the round. It’s what they do.
- Philadelphia Eagles: Jihaad Campbell (LB, Alabama) at 31. High-energy, high-IQ player who instantly improves their second level.
What This Means for Your Dynasty Roster
If you’re a fantasy football nerd or just a die-hard fan, the takeaway from the first round NFL Draft 2025 is clear: the era of the "safe" offensive tackle and the "dominant" interior lineman is back.
We saw seven of the first twelve picks go to the offensive or defensive lines. That's a massive shift from the 2024 draft, where six quarterbacks went in the first twelve.
🔗 Read more: Wind Direction at Wrigley Field Today: Why the Friendly Confines are Anything But Friendly
The immediate impact players are going to be guys like Ashton Jeanty (Raiders, pick 6) and Tyler Warren (Colts, pick 14). Jeanty is a bell-cow back who Boise State fans know is a touchdown machine. Putting him in a Pete Carroll-influenced offense in Vegas is a fantasy dream. Warren, meanwhile, became the Colts' number one passing option almost the second he stepped onto the practice field.
Actionable Takeaways for Fans
- Keep an eye on the Giants' defense. They are built to hit people. Hard. If you play IDP fantasy leagues, Abdul Carter is your rookie LB1.
- Don't sleep on the "fell-off" QBs. Shedeur Sanders falling to the Browns on Day 3 (eventually) doesn't mean he's a bust; it means the league valued the 2025 class differently.
- Watch the waiver wire for tight ends. Loveland (Bears) and Warren (Colts) are going to see massive target shares early because their teams lack established depth at the position.
The 2025 draft proved that NFL GMs are getting more disciplined. They stopped chasing the "next big thing" at quarterback and started rebuilding the foundations of their rosters. It wasn't the flashiest night in Green Bay, but for the teams that invested in the trenches, it might be the most important one in a decade.
If you're tracking these rookies, the next step is monitoring their snap counts in the preseason. Often, first-rounders like Mykel Williams (49ers) or Mason Graham (Browns) will start in rotational roles before becoming full-time starters by October. Set your alerts for training camp reports—that’s where the real depth charts are written.