We’ve all been there. You’re staring at a screen, a bank statement, or maybe a moving box, just trying to figure this out while your brain feels like it has forty-seven tabs open and half of them are frozen. It’s that specific brand of paralysis where the "this" could be anything from a career pivot to why your dishwasher is making that rhythmic thumping sound.
Honestly, the world doesn’t make it easy. We’re constantly told that the answer is just one Google search away, but usually, that search leads to ten more questions and a sponsored ad for something you don't need.
Decision fatigue isn't just a buzzword. It’s a physiological wall. Researchers like Barry Schwartz, who wrote The Paradox of Choice, have spent years proving that having more options actually makes us more miserable and less likely to take action. When you're trying to figure this out, you aren't just looking for an answer; you're navigating a minefield of "what ifs" and "could bes."
The Biology of the "Stuck" Brain
Your prefrontal cortex is a bit of a gas guzzler. It handles complex planning and decision-making, but it runs out of fuel faster than any other part of your brain. When you spend three hours trying to figure this out—whatever your "this" happens to be—you’re literally depleting the glucose your brain needs to function.
You get cranky. You get tired. You end up ordering takeout because the thought of choosing between pasta and stir-fry feels like a Herculean task.
It’s not laziness. It’s biology.
Dr. Roy Baumeister, a social psychologist known for his work on ego depletion, suggests that our willpower and decision-making capacity are finite resources. Think of it like a phone battery. Every time you weigh a pro against a con, you lose 1%. By the time you’re deep into the "trying to figure this out" phase, you’re at 4% power, the screen is dimming, and you’re probably going to make a bad call or no call at all.
Why Information Overload Kills Progress
We live in an era of "infobesity." We consume more data in a day than someone in the 15th century did in a lifetime. That’s a lot of noise. When you’re trying to figure this out, you usually start by gathering data.
- You read blogs.
- You watch YouTube tutorials.
- You ask that one friend who always seems to have their life together.
- You scroll through Reddit threads from 2014.
But there’s a tipping point. It's called the "Inverted U-Curve" of information. Up to a certain point, more information helps you make a better choice. Past that point? Every new fact you learn just makes you more confused and less confident. You start doubting the good information you already had.
🔗 Read more: The Recipe With Boiled Eggs That Actually Makes Breakfast Interesting Again
The Myth of the "Perfect" Solution
One of the biggest hurdles when trying to figure this out is the obsession with optimization. We don't just want a solution; we want the best solution. We want the most cost-effective, time-efficient, aesthetically pleasing, and socially validated outcome possible.
That’s a lot of pressure.
Herbert Simon, a Nobel Prize-winning polymath, coined the terms "maximizers" and "satisficers." Maximizers are the people who need to check every single option before deciding. Satisficers have a set of criteria, and the moment they find something that meets those criteria, they stop looking and commit.
Guess who's happier?
Satisficers. Every single time.
If you’re stuck trying to figure this out, you might be acting like a maximizer. You’re searching for a 10/10 solution in a world where a 7/10 is usually more than enough to get the job done and keep you moving forward.
Breaking the Cycle of Overthinking
So, how do you actually move the needle? It’s not by thinking harder. Usually, it’s by thinking less and doing more.
Action creates information. Thinking only creates more thoughts.
💡 You might also like: Finding the Right Words: Quotes About Sons That Actually Mean Something
The Rule of Three Options
When you have twenty paths, you go nowhere. When you have one path, you feel trapped.
Three is the magic number.
Whittle your choices down to three. Any three. Even if you have to pick them somewhat arbitrarily. Once you’re looking at just three possibilities, the mental fog starts to clear. Your brain can actually compare A to B to C without short-circuiting.
Set a "Micro-Deadline"
Open-ended problems expand to fill all available time. If you give yourself "the weekend" to figure this out, you will spend forty-eight hours in a state of low-grade anxiety.
Instead, set a timer for twenty minutes. Tell yourself that at the end of those twenty minutes, you have to make a "draft" decision. It’s not permanent. It’s just the direction you’re going to test first.
Real-World Examples of Figuring It Out
Look at how successful companies handle massive uncertainty. Amazon uses a framework called "One-Way vs. Two-Way Doors."
A "Two-Way Door" is a decision that is easily reversible. If you walk through it and don't like what you see, you can just walk back. Most of the things we stress about when trying to figure this out are two-way doors. We treat them like one-way doors—permanent, life-altering, terrifying—but they rarely are.
If you’re trying to figure out a new workout routine, or a software for your business, or what color to paint the guest room, those are two-way doors. Just pick one. If it sucks, change it later.
📖 Related: Williams Sonoma Deer Park IL: What Most People Get Wrong About This Kitchen Icon
The Role of Intuition (Yes, Really)
We’ve been taught to be hyper-rational. We love spreadsheets. We love data. But your gut—that "vibe" you get—is actually just your brain performing high-speed pattern recognition based on years of lived experience.
In a study by researchers at the University of New South Wales, they found that unconscious intuition can significantly speed up decision-making and increase accuracy in certain tasks. When you’re trying to figure this out and your logic is looping, stop. Sit quietly. What does the "quiet voice" say? Often, you already know the answer; you’re just waiting for a spreadsheet to give you permission to believe it.
Dealing With the Fear of Being Wrong
Let’s be real: the reason you’re stuck trying to figure this out is probably because you’re afraid of making a mistake. You don’t want to waste money. You don't want to look stupid.
But staying stuck is a mistake in itself. It’s a "Type II error"—the error of omission. You’re losing time, energy, and opportunity cost while you wait for a certainty that doesn't exist.
Accept right now that you might get it wrong. It's okay. The most successful people aren't the ones who always make the right choice; they’re the ones who make a choice and then work hard to make that choice right—or pivot quickly if it isn't.
Actionable Steps to Move Forward
If you are currently in the thick of trying to figure this out, here is your immediate roadmap:
- Audit your inputs. Close the tabs. Stop reading new articles. You likely have enough information already. More data is now becoming a distraction rather than a tool.
- Define the "Good Enough" threshold. Write down three things the solution must do. If a solution does those three things, it’s a candidate. Forget the "nice-to-haves" for now.
- The Coin Flip Test. This is an old trick but it works. Assign an option to heads and one to tails. Flip it. When the coin is in the air, you’ll suddenly realize which one you’re rooting for. That’s your answer.
- Take the smallest possible step. Don't try to solve the whole problem. What is the five-minute version of the solution? If you're trying to figure out a new career, don't quit your job today—just send one email to someone in that field.
- Physical movement. Your brain and body are connected. If you're mentally stuck, go for a walk. Change your environment. The "Aha!" moment rarely happens while staring at the problem; it happens when you're in the shower or walking the dog.
Trying to figure this out is a part of the process, not a sign of failure. The goal isn't to never be confused; it's to get better at navigating the confusion. Stop waiting for the clouds to part perfectly. Just start walking into the mist. You’ll find that as you move, the path right in front of your feet becomes a lot clearer.