You know that feeling when you're staring at a Sunday puzzle and the 14-across just won't click? Watching Hallmark’s signature sleuth series feels a lot like that, but with more murder and better sweaters. If you’ve spent any time on the Hallmark Movies & Mysteries channel, you’ve definitely seen Lacey Chabert trading her Mean Girls persona for a pen and a clipboard as Tess Harper. She plays a crossword editor who somehow finds herself knee-deep in police investigations. It’s a specific niche. It’s also surprisingly addictive.
But here is the thing: watching crossword mysteries movies in order actually matters for the character arcs. While each movie features a standalone crime, the slow-burn tension between Tess and Detective Logan O’Connor (played by Brennan Elliott) is the real reason people keep tuning in. If you jump in at movie four, you’ve missed the "he thinks she’s a nuisance" phase and went straight to the "they might actually get coffee" phase. Nobody wants to skip the build-up.
The Chronological List of Crossword Mysteries
Hallmark didn't drop twenty of these at once. They trickled out starting in 2019. Here is exactly how they landed.
1. A Puzzle to Die For (2019)
This is the pilot, basically. We meet Tess Harper, the crossword editor for the The Sentinel. The inciting incident? A gallery owner is murdered, and a crossword puzzle found at the scene seems to predict the crime. This is where Tess first butts heads with Logan. He's a by-the-book detective; she’s a "I notice patterns in letters" kind of person. It shouldn't work, but it does. Honestly, the chemistry is what saved this from being just another procedural.
2. Proposing Murder (2019)
Released just a few months after the first, this one ups the stakes. An old friend of Tess’s—who happens to be a prominent scavenger hunt creator—is killed. What’s cool here is how the movie uses the mechanics of a proposal and a hunt to hide clues. It’s a bit more emotional than the first one because Tess has a personal connection to the victim.
3. Abracadaver (2020)
Magicians. Seriously. This one takes place at a magic club where a performer dies during a "bullet catch" trick. It’s flashy. It’s a bit campy. But it marks a turning point where Logan starts to actually respect Tess's deductive skills instead of just rolling his eyes when she shows up at a crime scene.
✨ Don't miss: Who was the voice of Yoda? The real story behind the Jedi Master
4. Terminal Descent (2021)
This is where the series gets a bit more modern. We’re talking about a "supercomputer" and artificial intelligence. A tech CEO is found dead in an elevator, and Tess has to compete against a computer program designed to solve puzzles. It’s a bit of a "Man vs. Machine" vibe, which was a fun departure from the more traditional settings of the previous films.
5. Riddle Me Dead (2021)
The most recent entry. Tess is invited to be a guest on a popular game show. Then, of course, the host is murdered. It’s a classic "behind the scenes of TV" mystery. This one feels the most polished of the bunch, and the ending leaves fans hanging just enough to want a sixth movie—which, as of now, remains a hot topic of debate among the Hallmark faithful.
Why the Order Actually Changes the Experience
You could probably watch Abracadaver and understand the plot of the murder. But you wouldn’t understand why Tess and Logan are staring at each other like that.
The subplots involve Tess's Aunt Candace (the legendary Barbara Niven) and Logan's father, Chauncey (played by John Kapelos). These secondary characters provide the heart of the show. Over the course of the five films, you see a genuine friendship form between the two families. If you watch them out of order, the evolution of Logan’s skepticism into genuine partnership feels jarring.
Also, let’s talk about the puzzles. The writers actually worked with real crossword creators, including the famous Will Shortz, who has a cameo in the first film. As the series progresses, the "puzzle logic" used to solve the crimes gets slightly more complex. In the first movie, it’s a bit on the nose. By Riddle Me Dead, the clues are woven into the narrative much more seamlessly.
🔗 Read more: Not the Nine O'Clock News: Why the Satirical Giant Still Matters
Behind the Scenes: The Chabert and Elliott Connection
One reason this series ranks so high for viewers is the lead duo. Lacey Chabert and Brennan Elliott have a history. They’ve starred together in several other projects, most notably All of My Heart. This "pairing" is a staple of the Hallmark brand. They have a shorthand that makes the dialogue feel less scripted and more like a real bickering couple.
Brennan Elliott has often mentioned in interviews that he enjoys the "procedural" aspect of these movies more than the standard rom-coms. It’s a bit grittier—well, as gritty as Hallmark gets. There’s no gore, but there is genuine suspense.
Addressing the "Mystery 101" Comparison
Whenever people search for crossword mysteries movies in order, they usually stumble upon Mystery 101 or Aurora Teagarden. It’s easy to lump them all together. However, Crossword Mysteries is distinct because of its focus on linguistics and logic. While Aurora Teagarden is about a librarian who loves true crime, Tess Harper is about the structure of information.
The pacing is also different. The Crossword series tends to move a bit faster. There's less "small town fluff" and more focus on the clock. It feels more like a 90s detective show than a cozy mystery novel.
Is there a sixth movie coming?
This is the big question. As of early 2026, there hasn't been an official "green light" for a sixth installment, but the actors haven't ruled it out either. Hallmark underwent a massive rebranding and talent shift over the last couple of years, with some actors moving to other networks like GAF (Great American Family). However, Chabert remains the "Queen of Hallmark," so the door is never truly closed.
💡 You might also like: New Movies in Theatre: What Most People Get Wrong About This Month's Picks
Honestly, the series feels incomplete without a final resolution to the Tess and Logan "will they/won't they" arc. We've seen them solve five murders, but we haven't seen them go on a proper date without a dead body showing up.
Quick Reference Summary
If you're planning a weekend binge, here is the shorthand list to keep on your phone:
- Movie 1: A Puzzle to Die For
- Movie 2: Proposing Murder
- Movie 3: Abracadaver
- Movie 4: Terminal Descent
- Movie 5: Riddle Me Dead
How to Get the Most Out of Your Binge Watch
If you want to actually enjoy these like a pro, don't just have them on in the background while you fold laundry.
First, pay attention to the crossword clues shown on screen. Many of them are actual Easter eggs. Sometimes the answer to a clue in Tess's notebook is a subtle nod to a previous movie or a hint about the killer's motive that hasn't been revealed yet.
Second, watch the relationship between Logan and his father. It’s one of the most underrated parts of the series. John Kapelos brings a lot of gravitas to the role, and the "retired cop" dynamic adds a layer of realism to how Logan handles Tess's interference.
Your next steps for a perfect Crossword Mysteries experience:
- Check the Hallmark Movies Now app: This is usually the easiest place to find all five films in one spot without waiting for a TV marathon.
- Look for the cameos: Keep an eye out for Will Shortz in the first film. It’s a "blink and you’ll miss it" moment for puzzle nerds.
- Note the timeline: Notice how the technology changes from 2019 to 2021. The shift from traditional puzzles to the AI-driven plot in Terminal Descent reflects real-world shifts in how we consume media.
- Track the "Pen" count: Count how many times Tess uses a pen to solve a puzzle in a high-stress situation. It’s her version of a cowboy drawing a gun.
Starting with A Puzzle to Die For is the only way to go. It sets the foundation for everything else. You get the logic, the layout of the city, and the initial spark between the leads. Once you finish the fifth movie, you’ll be joined with the rest of the fanbase in hoping that 2026 finally brings us the sixth installment we’ve been waiting for.