Walk up to the corner of Church and Carlton Streets in downtown Toronto and you’ll feel it. Even if you aren't a hockey fan, there is a certain weight to the air. You are standing at the Maple Leaf Gardens location, a spot that served as the undisputed cathedral of Canadian sports for nearly seventy years. But if you're looking for a dusty, abandoned ruin, you're going to be pretty surprised.
The building is still there. It's massive.
Today, it is a weird, beautiful hybrid of a massive flagship Loblaws grocery store and the Mattamy Athletic Centre. It’s a place where you can buy organic kale exactly where Bill Barilko scored the 1951 Stanley Cup-winning goal. Honestly, the juxtaposition is kind of jarring at first. You see the original yellow brick, that iconic Art Deco facade, and the marquee, but instead of "Leafs vs. Canadiens," it might be advertising a sale on rotisserie chicken or a Ryerson (now Toronto Metropolitan University) Rams game.
It’s easy to forget that when Conn Smythe built this place in 1931, people thought he was absolutely insane. We’re talking about the height of the Great Depression. Money was nonexistent. Yet, he raised the funds, hired Ross and Macdonald, and saw the thing built in just five months. Five months! You can't even get a permit for a deck in Toronto that fast these days.
The Physical Geography of 60 Carlton Street
The Maple Leaf Gardens location isn't just a random pin on a map; it was chosen with a very specific, ruthless business logic. Smythe wanted it near the subway line (though the Yonge line didn't open until 1954, the plans were the talk of the town) and close enough to the downtown core to draw the business crowd. Specifically, it sits at 60 Carlton Street, Toronto, ON M5B 1J2.
If you’re navigating there now, you’ve got a few options:
👉 See also: Why the Marlins Won World Series Titles Twice and Then Disappeared
- The TTC: Take the Yonge-University line to College Station. Walk east for about two minutes. You can't miss it.
- Driving: Don't. Or, if you must, be prepared for the nightmare that is downtown Toronto parking. There is an underground lot, but it’s often packed.
- Walking: If you’re at the Eaton Centre, just head north on Yonge and turn right at Carlton. It’s a ten-minute stroll.
What’s wild is how the interior has been gutted while the "box" remains. When the Leafs left for the Air Canada Centre (now Scotiabank Arena) in 1999, the building sat in a sort of purgatory. There were talks of it becoming a mall, a museum, or just being torn down. Thankfully, the heritage designation saved the exterior. When you walk into the Loblaws on the ground floor, look up. They used thousands of the original blue, grey, and white chairs to create a massive mural of a maple leaf. It’s a subtle, classy nod to the ghosts of the rafters.
Why This Specific Spot Changed Toronto
Before the Gardens, the Toronto St. Patricks (who became the Leafs) played at the Mutual Street Arena. It was small. It was cramped. It wasn't "Toronto." By moving to the Maple Leaf Gardens location, Smythe basically declared that hockey was the new religion of the city.
The building didn't just host hockey. Think about the cultural footprint here.
- The Beatles: They played here on all three of their North American tours (1964, 1965, and 1966).
- Elvis Presley: His only concerts outside of the United States happened right here.
- Muhammad Ali: He fought George Chuvalo in 1966.
- Political Rallies: Every major Canadian prime minister of the 20th century likely stepped foot on a stage at 60 Carlton.
It was a multipurpose hub before "multipurpose" was a buzzword. But the hockey history is the bedrock. This is where Foster Hewitt climbed into the "gondola" to broadcast Hockey Night in Canada. If you’re a purist, you can still visit the site of the gondola, though the original was tragically destroyed during renovations.
The Modern Layout: Grocery Carts and Goal Creases
If you are visiting the Maple Leaf Gardens location today, you have to understand the "vertical split."
✨ Don't miss: Why Funny Fantasy Football Names Actually Win Leagues
The ground floor is the Loblaws. It is widely considered one of the best grocery stores in the world—not because of the produce, but because of the architecture. There’s a massive wall of cheese. There’s a canteen. But more importantly, there are markers on the floor and walls. If you look closely near the back of the store, there’s a gold leaf marker embedded in the floor. That marks exactly where center ice used to be. You’ll see people stopped there with their shopping carts, just staring at the floor. It’s sort of a pilgrimage.
Above the grocery store is the Mattamy Athletic Centre. This is where the magic still happens. They managed to put a full-sized NHL rink on the top floor. To do this, they had to reinforce the entire structure to hold the weight of the ice and the fans. When you’re watching a TMU Rams game or a PWHL Toronto game there, you’re sitting under the original domed ceiling.
The lighting is better now. The seats are more comfortable. But the acoustics? Still incredible. That low roar of a crowd in the Gardens is something that modern arenas, with their glass suites and corporate acoustics, just can't replicate.
Common Misconceptions About the Gardens
A lot of tourists—and honestly, some locals—get a few things wrong about the Maple Leaf Gardens location.
First, people often think the building was completely demolished and rebuilt. It wasn't. It was an "adaptive reuse" project. The shell is original. The roof is original.
🔗 Read more: Heisman Trophy Nominees 2024: The Year the System Almost Broke
Second, there’s a myth that the Stanley Cup banners are still there. They aren't. They were moved to the Scotiabank Arena. However, the spirit of those banners is arguably more present at 60 Carlton than at the new rink. The new arena feels like a business hub; the Gardens feels like a memory box.
Third, people assume it's just a grocery store. I've seen tourists walk to the front door, see the "Loblaws" sign, and walk away disappointed. Go inside! Take the escalators up to the second and third floors. There is a small gallery of sports memorabilia and photos that chronicle the building's history. It’s free. It’s better than most museums.
Realities of the Neighborhood
The area around the Maple Leaf Gardens location has changed a lot. It used to be a bit rougher around the edges. Now, it’s a high-density student and condo hub. You’ve got Toronto Metropolitan University wrapping around it. You’ve got the gay village just a few blocks north at Church and Wellesley.
This means the "vibe" is no longer just "blue-collar hockey fans." It’s students with laptops, chefs from the local restaurants, and tourists trying to find the spot where Neil Young recorded part of Massey Hall (actually, that's nearby, but you get the point).
If you're visiting, grab a coffee at one of the spots on Church Street and just sit on the benches outside the Gardens. You’ll see the bronze statues and the plaques. You’ll see old-timers pointing out windows to their grandkids. It’s one of the few places in Toronto where the past and the present aren't fighting each other; they’re just hanging out.
Actionable Steps for Your Visit
If you want to actually "experience" the location rather than just seeing it, do this:
- Look for the Gold Circle: Go into the Loblaws, head toward the back-right section (near the aisles of canned goods), and find the center ice marker. It's a small brass circle. Stand on it.
- Check the Mattamy Schedule: Don't just look at the building. See if there’s a hockey game or a volleyball match happening upstairs. Getting inside the upper bowl is the only way to truly appreciate the scale of the original roof.
- The South Wall: Check out the "Wall of Fame" near the escalators. It has a timeline of every major event, from the circus to the Jackson 5.
- The Food: This Loblaws is famous for its prepared foods. Grab lunch and eat it in the seating area overlooking the street. It’s one of the best people-watching spots in the city.
- The Archive: If you're a real nerd, the City of Toronto Archives has the original blueprints and construction photos. It's a short trip from the Gardens and adds a whole new layer of appreciation for how they built this thing in the 30s.
The Maple Leaf Gardens location is a survivor. In a city that loves to tear down its history to build glass condos, 60 Carlton stands as a rare win for preservation. It’s a grocery store, yes. It’s a gym, sure. But for anyone who knows the history, it’s still the place where the ghosts of hockey past are most likely to be found. Go there. Stand at center ice. Imagine the roar. You'll get it.