You know that feeling. It’s 2:00 AM. You’re staring at a blurry screenshot of a website that shouldn't exist, or maybe a weird audio file found on a discarded hard drive. Most people call it a rabbit hole. For some of us, it’s a hobby. If you’ve spent any time on r/InternetMysteries, you’ve likely seen the lifecycle of a digital enigma—from the initial "what is this?" post to the eventual (and often disappointing) discovery that it was just an ARG or a broken server script. But r/InternetMysteries isn't the only place where the weird stuff lives. Honestly, it’s just the tip of the iceberg.
Finding subreddits like internet mysteries requires knowing where the different "flavors" of weirdness actually congregate. Some people want the high-production value of an Alternate Reality Game. Others want the gritty, uncomfortable reality of unsolved cold cases or the technical anomalies of the early web.
Why We Search for Subreddits Like Internet Mysteries
The internet is huge. Terrifyingly so. We think we see the whole thing through Google or TikTok, but those are just the well-lit hallways of a massive, dark mansion. Subreddits like internet mysteries tap into our primal need to solve puzzles. It’s "The X-Files" for the fiber-optic age.
💡 You might also like: Why You Can't Connect Bluetooth to Car Radio Units and How to Fix It Fast
Take the case of Geedis. For years, people on Reddit tried to figure out the origin of a weird, yellow-clothed character found on a sheet of stickers from the 80s. It wasn't a world-ending conspiracy. It wasn't a cult. It was just a weird little guy. But the journey to find his creator—eventually traced back to a specific artist and a line of "Land of Ta" stickers—showed exactly why these communities matter. They turn collective boredom into a supercomputer of research.
If you’re looking for more, you have to branch out.
The Best Alternatives for Real Digital Sleuthing
r/UnresolvedMysteries
This is the "big brother" of the mystery world. While r/InternetMysteries focuses on digital oddities, r/UnresolvedMysteries is where you go for deep, long-form write-ups on people who vanished or crimes that make no sense. It’s strictly moderated. No creepypastas allowed. No "my friend's brother saw a ghost." It’s all about the facts. If you want a 4,000-word analysis of the Isdal Woman or the Somerton Man, this is your home.
r/ARG (Alternate Reality Games)
Sometimes the mystery is intentional. That’s where r/ARG comes in. If you find a YouTube channel posting binary code in the descriptions or a Twitter account that only tweets coordinates, it’s probably a game. A lot of people get frustrated when a "real" mystery turns out to be an ARG, but if you go into r/ARG, you’re looking for that specific thrill. It’s the community that solved the Sombra clues for Overwatch and decoded the Cicada 3301 puzzles.
r/DeepIntoYouTube
This one is less about "solving" things and more about the sheer absurdity of the platform. It’s a repository for videos with fewer than 200 views that have been online for years. You’ll find everything from a guy filming his toaster for ten minutes to bizarre, unlisted corporate training videos from the 90s. It captures the same "uncanny" vibe as r/InternetMysteries but without the pressure to find a "solution."
r/NonFunctioningPixels
A smaller, more niche community. It focuses on digital decay. Ever visited a website and found a page that feels... wrong? Dead links that lead to weird placeholders? This sub is for the architectural ghosts of the internet.
The Technical Side of the Mystery
People often forget that many subreddits like internet mysteries are actually populated by people with serious technical skills. We aren't just talking about enthusiasts. We're talking about OSINT (Open Source Intelligence) experts.
When a weird mystery pops up, the first thing these users do isn't "guessing." They check the WHOIS data of the domain. They run the images through EXIF data extractors to see where the photo was taken. They use tools like the Wayback Machine to see what the site looked like in 2004.
If you want to be more than a lurker, you should look into r/OSINT. It’s not a "mystery" sub per se, but it teaches you the tools of the trade. Knowing how to use TinEye for reverse image searching or how to track a crypto wallet can turn you from a spectator into the person who actually solves the case.
Why Most Mysteries Are Just "Internet Noise"
Let’s be real for a second. Most "mysteries" are boring.
A lot of what gets posted in subreddits like internet mysteries ends up being one of three things:
- Mental Health Crises: Sometimes, a "weird website" is just a blog run by someone experiencing a schizophrenic episode. It’s sad, not supernatural.
- Marketing: Brands have caught on. They know we love a mystery. They’ll create a "creepy" TikTok account just to announce a new horror movie.
- Bot Scrapers: A lot of the "coded" text found on weird subreddits is just bots talking to bots to rank for SEO or scrape data.
Distinguishing between these and a "genuine" mystery—like the Lake City Quiet Pills or the Cicada 3301 puzzles—is what separates a pro from a newbie. You have to be skeptical. If something looks too perfectly "spooky," it probably is. Real internet mysteries are usually mundane at first glance and only get weirder the more you look.
How to Stay Safe While Exploring
Don't be a hero. Seriously.
💡 You might also like: Finding a Doppler Radar Where I Am: Why Your Weather App Always Seems to Lie
When you dive into subreddits like internet mysteries, you’re going to find links to the "Dark Web" or strange IP addresses.
- Use a VPN. Don't let your home IP be visible to a server that might be run by someone who doesn't want to be found.
- Virtual Machines are your friend. If you’re downloading a file from a "mystery" site, run it in a VM first.
- Don't touch the "Dark Web" without Tor. And even then, be careful. Most of it is just scams and boring forums, but there’s no reason to take risks for a Reddit thread.
- Respect the "No Witch Hunting" rules. This is huge. Reddit has a bad history with this (remember the Boston Marathon bombing?). Don't dox people. Don't harass someone because you "think" they’re the person in the video.
Moving Beyond Reddit
If you’ve exhausted the best subreddits like internet mysteries, where do you go?
The hunt continues on platforms like 4chan's /x/ board (though, fair warning, it’s a toxic swamp 90% of the time). There are also dedicated forums like Unexplained Mysteries or the Unsolved Canada boards for specific geographic interests.
YouTube has also become a massive hub for this content. Creators like Nexpo, Nick Crowley, and Barely Sociable do incredible deep-dives that often start as small threads on these very subreddits. Watching their process—how they find archives, how they interview witnesses—is a masterclass in digital investigation.
Practical Steps for Your Next Rabbit Hole
If you're ready to jump back in, don't just scroll. Participate. The magic of these communities isn't in the "content," it's in the collaboration.
First, pick a specific niche. Are you interested in "lost media" (shows or games that no longer exist)? Go to r/lostmedia. Are you into weird radio signals? Check out r/numberstations.
Second, learn the basic toolset. Bookmark the Wayback Machine. Learn how to use Yandex for reverse image searches (it’s often better than Google for this). Install a browser extension that lets you view image metadata easily.
Finally, stay grounded. It’s easy to see patterns where none exist. This is called apophenia. Just because two websites use the same shade of blue doesn't mean they're part of a secret government project. Most of the time, the simplest explanation is the right one. But that 1%? The 1% that actually defies explanation? That’s why we keep looking.
Check out the "Top of All Time" posts on r/InternetMysteries to see what a "resolved" case actually looks like. It’ll give you a benchmark for what's real and what's just noise. Then, head over to r/TraceAnObject. It’s a subreddit run by Europol where they post backgrounds of images from horrific crimes in hopes that a "digital sleuth" can identify a specific toy, a brand of soda, or a window view. It’s the ultimate way to turn this hobby into something that actually helps people.
🔗 Read more: Why your tv remote control universal setup is probably failing (and how to fix it)
Stay curious, keep your VPN on, and don't believe everything you read in a "spooky" font.