You're sitting at a rickety wooden table in a dimly lit corner of a Valentine saloon, the smell of cheap oat whiskey and unwashed cowpokes thick in the air. Opposite you sits a man who looks like he hasn't slept since the Civil War, clutching a hunting knife that’s seen better days. He starts thumping that blade between his fingers, a rhythmic thwack-thwack-thwack that makes your own knuckles ache just watching. This is the brutal reality of the Five Finger Fillet RDR2 mini-game. It’s stressful. It’s fast. Honestly, it’s probably the easiest way to lose a digit in the entire frontier, but if you want that 100% completion mark or just need to blow off some steam after a botched stagecoach robbery, you’ve got to know where to go.
Arthur Morgan (and later John Marston) can find these tables scattered across the map, but they aren't always active. You can’t just walk in at 3:00 AM and expect a game to be running; these guys have lives, sort of. Mostly, they drink.
Where to Play Five Finger Fillet RDR2 Right Now
If you're looking for a game, your first stop should almost always be Valentine. It's the quintessential starting point. Head over to the smaller saloon—the one where the brawls usually start—and you’ll see the table in the back. This is the "Classic" location. It’s accessible early in Chapter 2, making it the go-to spot for players trying to knock out those early Gambler challenges.
The atmosphere in Valentine is unmatched. You've got the mud, the rain, and the constant threat of a lawman breathing down your neck. But if Valentine is too "civilized" for you, ride north. Strawberry has a table right by the general store, tucked away on a little porch. It feels more intimate here, surrounded by the towering trees of Big Valley. Usually, the competition in Strawberry feels a bit more calculated, though that’s probably just the mountain air talking.
Don't forget Van Horn Trading Post. This place is a dump, let's be real. There’s no law, everyone’s angry, and the Five Finger Fillet table is often occupied by some of the meanest-looking NPCs in the game. Playing here feels dangerous because, well, it is. If you accidentally bump into someone on your way to the table, the whole town might decide to start a firing squad.
Lastly, check your Gang Camp. Whether you're at Horseshoe Overlook, Clemens Point, or Shady Belle, there’s often a table set up. The stakes are lower—usually just a couple of bucks—but it’s a great way to hear unique dialogue from Lenny, Micah, or Bill. Beating Micah at Five Finger Fillet is, quite frankly, one of the most satisfying things you can do in the entire 60-hour campaign.
The Mechanics of the Game
It’s a rhythm game, basically. You aren't actually aiming the knife; you’re following a button prompt sequence that gets progressively more complex as the rounds go on. Most players fail because they look at the knife. Don't do that. Keep your eyes on the button prompts at the bottom of the screen.
The most common version is the Minnie Mouse (the simple one-button tap), but as you bet more money or face tougher opponents, you’ll move into the Fillet and Flank or the Big Dot variations. These require you to memorize a sequence like $A \rightarrow B \rightarrow A \rightarrow Y$ (on Xbox) or $X \rightarrow O \rightarrow X \rightarrow \Delta$ (on PlayStation).
Once you memorize the pattern, the game stops being about reflexes and starts being about muscle memory. You can actually "buffer" your inputs. If you press the buttons in the correct order faster than the animation plays out, Arthur will just blur through the motions like a caffeinated surgeon. It looks cool, and it wins you money.
👉 See also: Microsoft Solitaire Daily Challenges: Why People Still Can’t Stop Playing Them
Why Location Matters for Gambler Challenges
If you're stuck on Gambler Challenge 7, where you have to win Five Finger Fillet in three different locations, you need a roadmap. You can't just play the same guy over and over. You have to hit Valentine, then ride to Strawberry, then maybe take a long trek to Van Horn.
The difficulty varies slightly by location, too. Van Horn tends to have "faster" opponents who don't mess up their turns. In the camp, your fellow outlaws are a bit more forgiving. If you’re struggling with the timing, start at the camp to get your rhythm down before heading into the wild.
Strategy and Hidden Details
Did you know you can actually watch your opponent's turn to learn the sequence? Most people check their phones or look away during the NPC's turn, but the button prompts appear then, too. If you pay attention, you'll know exactly what you need to press before your turn even starts.
🔗 Read more: Why the Connections Aug 13 Puzzle Was Such a Massive Headache
Also, keep an eye on the "Lap" counter. To win, you need to complete more laps than your opponent within the time limit. If you’re playing a high-stakes game, speed is everything. A single "nick"—where Arthur stabs his own finger—will reset your current lap and cost you precious seconds. It's better to go slightly slower and be accurate than to spam buttons and end up with a bloody glove.
There is a weird glitch (or maybe it’s a feature?) where sometimes the table in Valentine will be empty for days. If that happens, try sleeping at the hotel or leaving the area and coming back. The game needs to "reset" the NPC schedule.
Actionable Tips for Mastery
If you want to stop losing money and start winning every time, follow these steps:
- Mute the game audio. Sometimes the "thud" of the knife can throw off your internal rhythm. Playing in silence allows you to focus purely on the visual prompts.
- Practice the "Classic" pattern. In most early rounds, the pattern is just alternating between the "bottom" button and the others in a clockwise circle. Learn that circular motion with your thumb.
- Bet small first. Don't go for the $10 games until you've cleared the table twice at $1. It builds confidence and lets you see the faster patterns without the risk of losing your shirt.
- Watch the opponent. As mentioned, the buttons for your turn are the exact same as theirs. Use their turn as a "preview" mode.
Once you’ve cleared out the table in Van Horn, you’ve basically peaked. There isn't a secret boss or a golden knife waiting for you, but the satisfaction of not having a single scar on your digital hand is reward enough. Grab your horse, head to the nearest saloon, and start tapping. Just try not to get into a gunfight on your way out. It ruins the vibe.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Sanctum of Prophecy Golden Scapegoat is Still the Weirdest Drop in Elden Ring
To truly master the game, focus on the Strawberry location next, as the lighting there makes the button prompts significantly easier to see during the daytime than the smoky interiors of the Valentine saloon. Move between these spots systematically to clear your challenges and move on to the more frustrating tasks like Blackjack or Dominoes.