Paper matters. It really does. You might think any old spiral notebook from the grocery store pharmacy aisle will do the trick, but if you’re actually trying to build a habit, the friction of scratchy paper or ink bleeding through the page will kill your momentum faster than you can say "writer’s block." Finding the right journals to write in isn't just about aesthetics or looking like a brooding poet in a coffee shop. It’s about ergonomics, tactile feedback, and whether that specific binding can actually handle being tossed into a backpack for six months straight without disintegrating into a pile of confetti.
Most people fail at journaling because they buy a "fancy" book that feels too precious to mess up. They stare at the cream-colored, gold-edged pages and feel like they have to write something profound. That’s a trap.
The Paper Weight Obsession (and Why GSM Matters)
If you’ve ever used a Sharpie or a heavy fountain pen and watched the ink soak through three pages like a grease stain, you know the pain of low GSM. GSM stands for Grams per Square Meter. Basically, it’s how thick the paper is. Most cheap notebooks are around 70 to 80 GSM. That’s fine for a grocery list. It’s terrible for a legacy journal.
You want 100 GSM or higher. 120 GSM is the sweet spot for people who love felt-tip pens like the Papermate Flair or the Stabilo Point 88. At 160 GSM, you’re basically writing on cardstock. Brands like Archer & Olive have built an entire cult following around 160 GSM paper because you can literally paint on it with watercolors and it won't buckle. But it’s heavy. Thick. It makes the journal feel like a brick. Some people hate that. They want the "crunchy" feel of thinner paper that’s been filled with ink. It's a vibe.
Dot Grid vs. Lined: The Great Debate
Lines are bossy. They tell you exactly where to go and how big your handwriting should be. For a lot of us, that's a security blanket. But if you’re looking at journals to write in for the sake of mental clarity, the dot grid is often the superior choice.
Invented largely to support the "Bullet Journal" method popularized by Ryder Carroll, the dot grid provides a subtle ghost of a guide. You can write straight, sure. But you can also suddenly draw a flowchart, a habit tracker, or a tiny sketch of your cat without a horizontal line cutting through the middle of the drawing like a barbed-wire fence. It offers freedom.
- Lined: Best for long-form brain dumps and stream-of-consciousness venting.
- Dot Grid: Best for planners, creators, and people who find blank pages terrifying but lines too restrictive.
- Blank: For the chaotic neutrals. Unless you have the steady hand of a surgeon, your lines will start to slant downward until your entry looks like a literal slide into madness.
The Brands That Actually Hold Up
Let's talk about the heavy hitters. You've heard of Moleskine. Everyone has. They’re the Apple of journals. Sleek, recognizable, and available in every airport bookstore on the planet. But honestly? The paper quality has dipped over the last decade. If you use a fountain pen, a Moleskine will betray you with feathering and bleed-through.
If you want the "pro" version of a Moleskine, look at Leuchtturm1917. They’re German. They’re precise. They include a table of contents (index) at the front and numbered pages. That sounds like a small thing until you’re trying to find that one entry from three months ago where you actually had a good business idea. Being able to look at your index and see "Business Ideas: Page 42" is a game-changer.
👉 See also: The White Buttoned Shirt Men Actually Need (and Why Most Get It Wrong)
Then there’s the Midori MD. This is Japanese minimalism at its peak. The paper is slightly toothy, meaning it has a bit of friction. It’s not "slick." For some, writing on Midori paper is a borderline religious experience. It’s cream-colored, lay-flat, and usually comes with a simple wax paper cover. It feels like an artifact.
The Psychology of the "Messy Journal"
There is a massive misconception that a journal needs to be a work of art. You see these "Studygram" influencers with their perfect calligraphy and stickers. Forget them. That isn't journaling; that’s scrapbooking.
The most effective journals to write in are the ones that look like a mess. Dr. James Pennebaker, a social psychologist at the University of Texas at Austin, has spent decades researching "Expressive Writing." His studies show that writing about stressful or traumatic experiences for just 15 to 20 minutes a day can improve immune function and reduce doctor visits. But here’s the kicker: the writing doesn't have to be pretty. It doesn't even have to be grammatically correct.
Pennebaker’s research suggests that the act of "labeling" emotions and creating a narrative is what heals the brain. If you’re worrying about your handwriting, you aren't accessing the parts of your brain that need the most help. Buy a journal that you feel comfortable "ruining."
Softcover vs. Hardcover
Hardcovers are durable. They provide their own writing surface, which is great if you’re journaling on a train or in bed. They protect the corners of the paper. But they’re heavy.
Softcover journals, like the Moleksine Cahiers or the Field Notes series, are "pocketable." Field Notes has a massive community of enthusiasts who love the 3.5 by 5.5-inch format. They fit in a back pocket. Jim Coudal, one of the founders of Field Notes, often talks about how these notebooks are meant to be used and used hard. They get dog-eared. The staples might get a little rusty. The cover gets sweaty. That’s the point. A journal that stays pristine on a shelf is a failed journal.
👉 See also: Por qué tu juego de cuchillos cocinero te está arruinando las cenas (y qué comprar de verdad)
Why You Should Care About Binding
Smyth-sewn binding is the gold standard. Instead of just gluing pages to a spine—which eventually causes the book to crack and pages to fall out—Smyth-sewn journals sew groups of pages (signatures) together.
This allows the journal to lay completely flat. There is nothing more annoying than trying to write near the "gutter" (the middle fold) of a notebook while the left side keeps trying to spring shut on your hand. If a journal doesn't lay flat, don't buy it. Life is too short to fight your stationery.
Leather, Vegan Leather, and Cloth
Texture matters. If you’re going to touch something every single day, you should like how it feels.
- Full-grain leather: Smells great, lasts forever, develops a "patina" (it gets darker and shinier where you touch it). Brands like Galen Leather or Traveler's Company are famous for this.
- Bookcloth: Feels academic and tactile. It’s "grippy." Baronfig uses a lot of cloth covers that feel great but can pick up stains if you spill your coffee.
- PU Leather (Vegan): This is basically plastic. It’s durable and water-resistant, but it doesn't "age." It just gets scratched.
Actionable Steps to Start Today
Don't overthink this. If you are paralyzed by choice, follow this exact path to get started without the "perfectionist" baggage.
📖 Related: Slow Cooker Pork Chili Verde: Why Your Tomatillos Might Be Ruining Dinner
1. Pick your "Entry Point" Journal. If you’re a beginner, go with a Leuchtturm1917 Medium (A5) Dot Grid. It’s the "Goldilocks" of journals. Not too big, not too small, paper is solid, and it has the index.
2. Choose ONE Pen. Don't buy a 24-pack of colors. Grab one Pilot G2 0.7mm or a Uniball Signo. Reliability is the key here. If the pen skips, you’ll stop writing.
3. The "Two-Minute Rule." Commit to writing for two minutes. That’s it. You can write "I don't know what to say" for two minutes straight. Usually, by the 90-second mark, something real will pop out.
4. Date Every Page. Context is everything. Ten years from now, you won't care what you ate for lunch, but you will care that you were feeling anxious about a promotion on a rainy Tuesday in March.
5. Forget the "Aesthetic." Cross things out. Spatter coffee on the page. Tape in a movie ticket. Use your journals to write in as a laboratory for your life, not a museum.
The "best" journal is the one that is currently open in front of you. Everything else is just details. Whether you choose a $30 Italian leather-bound tome or a $2 composition book, the value isn't in the paper—it's in the honesty you leave behind on the page. Get a book. Grab a pen. Start now.