Finding a decent pair of Jessie and Bullseye toys shouldn't be a headache, but somehow, it is. If you've ever spent forty minutes scrolling through eBay or wandering the aisles of a Target, you know the struggle. Some look like they were painted by someone in a very big hurry. Others are so stiff they can't even sit on the horse.
Cowgirl Jessie and her trusty steed Bullseye are the heart of the Toy Story franchise's western aesthetic. Since Toy Story 2 dropped back in 1999, the market has been flooded with every possible version of these two characters. We’re talking about everything from the high-end "Signature Collection" replicas that cost a small fortune to those tiny, solid plastic figurines you find in a checkout lane bucket.
Honestly, the quality varies wildly.
You want something that actually captures the soul of the characters. Jessie needs that specific "Yee-haw!" energy in her expression, and Bullseye needs to look like he’s ready to gallop into the sunset, not like a generic brown pony. For collectors or parents who just want a toy that won't snap in half by Tuesday, knowing which brand to trust is basically a full-time job.
The Reality of the Disney Store vs. Thinkway Replicas
For a long time, the gold standard for Jessie and Bullseye toys was the Thinkway Toys Signature Collection. These were marketed as "definitive" replicas. They used the actual digital data from Pixar to get the proportions right. If you hold a Signature Jessie, you’ll notice the yarn hair is thick and the pull-string voice box has that iconic, slightly scratchy analog sound.
But here is the catch: Thinkway isn't producing these like they used to.
This has created a massive secondary market. If you’re looking for a mint-in-box Signature Bullseye today, be prepared to pay three times the original retail price. Why? Because the scale is perfect. Most Bullseye toys are either too small—making Jessie look like she's riding a Great Dane—or too bulky. The Thinkway version includes "galloping" sound effects triggered by movement, which is a neat bit of tech that actually holds up.
The Disney Store (now often branded under shopDisney) has its own "Interactive" line. These are the ones you see most often now. They’re good. Not perfect, but good. The coolest feature here is the IR sensor. If you put the Disney Store Jessie near a Buzz or Woody from the same line, they’ll actually "talk" to each other. It’s a bit gimmicky, but for a kid, it’s basically magic.
👉 See also: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
Materials Matter: Plastic vs. Ragdoll Authenticity
In the movies, Jessie is a ragdoll with a plastic head. Bullseye is a plush. When you’re buying Jessie and Bullseye toys, you have to decide if you want movie accuracy or "playability."
Hard plastic figures, like those made by Mattel for their 7-inch scale line, are great for posing. You can stand them up on a shelf without them flopping over. They’re durable. You can drop them on a driveway and they’ll probably survive with just a scuff. But they don't feel like the characters. There’s something fundamentally wrong about a Jessie who doesn't have soft limbs.
Then you have the soft-body versions. These are the ones people love.
- The Hat Problem: Almost every Jessie toy has a hat that falls off. It’s a universal law of physics. Some versions use a small elastic strap, which looks terrible in photos but keeps the hat from being lost under the couch.
- The Hair: Yarn hair is authentic. Molded plastic hair is easier to clean. If you're giving this to a toddler who frequently has jam on their hands, go with the plastic.
- Bullseye’s Legs: Cheap Bullseye toys have legs that are basically stuffed sausages. They won't support any weight. Better versions have a wire armature inside or a more rigid stuffing that allows the horse to actually stand while Jessie is on his back.
I’ve seen some "boutique" versions of Bullseye that use a faux-suede material. It feels amazing. It catches the light just like the animation. However, those are dust magnets. If you're a "display only" collector, it’s worth the hassle. If this is for a playroom, stick to the standard polyester blends.
Why Scale Is the Biggest Headache for Collectors
You’d think it would be simple. A company makes a Jessie, they make a Bullseye, they should fit together. Wrong.
Mattel’s "Basic" line often packages them separately. If you buy the 12-inch "large scale" Jessie, she’s often too heavy for the companion Bullseye. You end up with a horse that does a face-plant every time you try to seat the rider.
The most successful pairing is the Thinkway Toy Story Collection. It’s the only one where the height of the saddle and the spread of Jessie’s legs were designed in tandem. Most other brands treat them as two separate products that happen to be in the same box. If you're looking for that iconic "Ride like the wind!" pose, you specifically need a Jessie with a "split" leg design or a soft, flexible crotch area. Hard plastic legs that are molded together will never sit on a horse properly. They just kind of hover awkwardly above the saddle.
✨ Don't miss: Shamea Morton and the Real Housewives of Atlanta: What Really Happened to Her Peach
The Rise of the Imaginext and Smaller Scale Sets
Not everything has to be life-sized. Fisher-Price's Imaginext line has a version of Jessie and Bullseye that is surprisingly detailed for being only three inches tall.
These are the tanks of the toy world.
Imaginext toys are virtually indestructible. Their Bullseye has a "kicking" action when you press a button, which adds a layer of play that the high-end collector dolls lack. These are perfect for younger kids who are just getting into Toy Story through the later films or the shorts. They don’t have the "creepy" factor that some of the older, poorly-painted dolls have.
Speaking of "creepy," we need to talk about the bootlegs.
Because Jessie and Bullseye toys are so popular, there are thousands of knock-offs circulating on sites like AliExpress or at flea markets. You can spot them a mile away if you look at the eyes. Official Pixar merch has very specific "eye-lights"—those little white dots that give the character life. Bootlegs usually have flat, dead eyes or pupils that aren't centered. Plus, they often smell like a chemical factory. Stick to licensed products from Mattel, Thinkway, or Disney. It’s safer and they actually hold their value.
What Most People Get Wrong About "Vintage" Jessie Toys
Just because a Jessie toy says "1999" on the butt doesn't mean it's worth a fortune.
During the Toy Story 2 era, manufacturers produced millions of these. The "Woody’s Roundup" aesthetic was everywhere. The real value is in the "pull-string" functionality. If the string is snapped or the voice box has slowed down to a demonic-sounding crawl due to battery corrosion, the value drops to almost zero.
🔗 Read more: Who is Really in the Enola Holmes 2 Cast? A Look at the Faces Behind the Mystery
If you find a vintage Bullseye, check the stirrups. They are the first thing to break. They’re usually made of a thin plastic or vinyl that gets brittle over twenty years. A Bullseye without stirrups is like a car without wheels—it just looks incomplete.
How to Spot a High-Quality Bullseye
Look at the hooves.
In the movie, Bullseye has "ANDY" (or later, "BONNIE") written on the bottom of his hooves, but it's split up. One letter per hoof. High-quality Jessie and Bullseye toys will replicate this detail. If the hooves are just blank plastic, the manufacturer was cutting corners.
Also, check the saddle. Is it molded into the horse’s body, or is it a separate piece of material? A separate, textured saddle is always a sign of a better-engineered toy. It allows for more realistic movement and generally looks better on a shelf.
Actionable Maintenance for Your Toys
- Battery Care: If you have a talking Jessie, never store her with batteries inside for more than a few months. Alkaline batteries leak, and once that acid hits the circuit board, your Cowgirl is silenced forever.
- Yarn Hair Triage: If Jessie’s hair starts to fray, do not brush it. You'll just pull the fibers apart. Use a small amount of fabric softener mixed with water to gently smooth it down with your fingers.
- Dusting Bullseye: Since he’s mostly plush, don't use a damp cloth. It’ll just grind the dirt in. Use a lint roller or a vacuum attachment with a brush to keep his "fur" looking clean.
When you finally get a set of Jessie and Bullseye toys that look right, it changes the whole vibe of a collection. There’s a specific warmth to those characters. They represent the "western" roots of the story that Woody sometimes forgets. Whether you’re hunting for a Signature Series mint-in-box or just a sturdy Mattel set for a toddler's birthday, pay attention to the scale and the materials. A horse that can't stand and a cowgirl who can't sit are just paperweights. Get the ones that let you actually recreate the movie magic.
To ensure your collection stays in top shape, always store these figures away from direct sunlight. UV rays are the enemy of red plastic—it'll turn Jessie’s iconic hat into a weird shade of pink in less than a year. Keep them in a cool, dry place, and they'll keep saying "Yee-haw" for decades.