You know that feeling when you finish a game and just sit there staring at the credits, feeling kinda hollow? That was me with Night in the Woods. It wasn’t just the art style or the fact that Mae Borowski is a relatable disaster. It was the way the game captured the specific, crushing weight of returning to a dying hometown where everything is different but somehow exactly the same.
Finding games like Night in the Woods isn't actually about finding another platformer with talking animals. Not really. It’s about finding that specific "vibe." You want that mixture of existential dread, small-town secrets, and characters who feel like people you actually went to high school with.
Honestly, it’s a tough itch to scratch. Most games try too hard to be "indie" or "quirky." But some titles actually get it right. They understand that the magic isn't in the mystery—it's in the quiet moments between the plot points where you're just walking home in the dark.
The Specific Magic of the Narrative Adventure
What made Night in the Woods stick? It’s the dialogue. Scott Benson and Bethany Hockenberry wrote characters that didn't sound like video game NPCs. They sounded like people who were tired, broke, and trying to find a reason to get out of bed.
If you’re looking for that same DNA, you have to look at games that prioritize "character over mechanics."
A Short Hike: The Palate Cleanser
A Short Hike is tiny. You can beat it in ninety minutes. But in those ninety minutes, it captures the "hanging out" energy of Mae and her friends perfectly. You play as Claire, a bird visiting her aunt at a provincial park. You’re waiting for a phone call. That’s it. That’s the tension.
The game doesn't demand anything of you. You wander. You talk to a goat who lost their watch. You learn to fish from a grumpy neighbor. It feels like a Saturday afternoon in Possum Springs before everything went sideways. It’s a game about the journey, and it’s arguably the most "comfy" experience you’ll find in this genre.
Oxenfree: When the Vibe Goes Supernormal
If the part of Night in the Woods you loved most was the spooky, "something is wrong in the woods" mystery, then Oxenfree is the obvious next step.
📖 Related: Why Titanfall 2 Pilot Helmets Are Still the Gold Standard for Sci-Fi Design
Night School Studio did something brilliant here. They created a walk-and-talk system that feels natural. Characters interrupt each other. They trail off. They react to what you’re doing while you’re doing it. It’s a ghost story, sure, but it’s actually a story about a group of teenagers who don’t really like each other very much trying to survive a night on an abandoned island.
Alex, the protagonist, has a lot of Mae’s DNA. She’s cynical. She’s grieving. She’s trying to navigate a complicated relationship with her new step-brother. When the radio dial starts picking up voices that shouldn't be there, the horror works because you actually care about these kids.
Why "Vibe" is Harder to Code Than Combat
Most "games like Night in the Woods" fail because they think the "indie" aesthetic is enough. It's not. You need the grit. You need the sense that the world existed before you pressed "Start" and will keep decaying after you turn the console off.
Kentucky Route Zero: The Heavy Hitter
This is the one people always recommend, and for good reason. Kentucky Route Zero is less of a game and more of a magical realist play. It’s weird. It’s deeply Southern. It deals with debt, capitalism, and the literal ghosts of industry.
If Possum Springs felt like a town losing its soul to the closing of the mines, Kentucky Route Zero is the fever dream that happens after the town is already gone. The dialogue is poetic. The visuals are striking. It’s not "fun" in the traditional sense, but it is profound. You play as Conway, an antique delivery driver looking for an address that doesn't seem to exist. Along the way, you meet a skeleton crew of people who have been left behind by the world. It’s heavy, but if you liked the social commentary of Mae’s dad talking about the union, this is your game.
Mutazione: Small Town Drama with Plants
Imagine if Mae moved to a weird tropical island instead of back to her parents' basement. That’s Mutazione.
You play as Kai, a teenage girl traveling to a secluded, mutant-filled community to visit her dying grandfather. It’s a "mutant soap opera." The core loop involves planting musical gardens to help people heal, but the real draw is the town gossip.
👉 See also: Sex Fallout New Vegas: Why Obsidian’s Writing Still Outshines Modern RPGs
Everyone in Mutazione has a history. There are affairs, old grudges, and secrets buried in the swamp. It mirrors the way Night in the Woods makes you feel like an outsider slowly becoming part of a community’s rhythm. The art style is lush and hand-drawn, making it a visual treat for anyone who appreciated the autumn colors of Possum Springs.
The Games People Miss (But Shouldn't)
There are a few titles that don't get mentioned as often in the "games like Night in the Woods" conversation because they look different on the surface. But look closer. The heart is the same.
Disco Elysium: The Adult Version
Hear me out. Disco Elysium is an RPG, but it’s 99% reading. You play as a middle-aged, alcoholic detective who has lost his memory.
Wait.
Doesn't that sound like a potential future for Mae?
The game is hilarious, devastating, and deeply political. It tackles the "nothingness" of existence with a wit that rivals the funniest moments in the Snack Falcon. The way the protagonist’s internal thoughts argue with him feels very similar to Mae’s internal struggles with her "shapes." It’s much more complex, but the emotional payoff is massive.
Fireside: The Power of Conversation
Released more recently, Fireside is a game about... well, sitting by a fire. You’re on a journey, and at the end of each day, you camp out. Other travelers join you.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Disney Infinity Star Wars Starter Pack Still Matters for Collectors in 2026
You trade items. You talk.
The mechanics are simple, but the writing focuses on the "smallness" of life. It captures that specific feeling of a late-night conversation where you end up telling a stranger something you’ve never told your best friend. It’s short, sweet, and understands that the best parts of life are often the ones where nothing "exciting" is happening.
Navigating the Emotional Landscape
When you're looking for these types of experiences, you're usually chasing a feeling of melancholy mixed with hope.
- Look for "Narrative-First" labels. If the Steam page talks more about the "branching dialogue" than the "combat system," you're on the right track.
- Check the soundtrack. Games like Night in the Woods rely heavily on atmosphere. If the composer is someone like Alec Holowka (who did the original NITW score) or has a similar lo-fi, synth-heavy vibe, the game will likely hit that same emotional note.
- Ignore the "Animals" trope. Just because a game has a cat protagonist doesn't mean it's like Night in the Woods. Stray is a great game, but it's not a NITW-like. It’s a sci-fi adventure. Focus on the themes of "coming of age" and "economic anxiety" instead.
Where to go from here
If you're staring at your library wondering what to download next, start with Oxenfree if you want the mystery, or A Short Hike if you just want to feel okay for an hour. If you’re ready to have your heart broken and put back together in a slightly different shape, go for Kentucky Route Zero.
The reality is that Night in the Woods was a lightning-in-a-bottle moment. It captured a very specific era of the 2010s—the feeling of being over-educated, under-employed, and stuck in a loop. But the games listed above carry that torch. They remind us that even when the world feels like it's falling apart, there's usually someone willing to go grab a pizza with you and talk about the stars.
To get the most out of these games, try playing them in short bursts during the evening. These aren't "grind for 10 hours" games. They are "sit with a cup of tea and listen" games. Pay attention to the background details—the posters on the walls, the way the wind moves the trees, the subtle changes in the music. That's where the real story is usually hiding.
Don't rush to the "true ending." In games like these, the "true ending" is just the point where you have to say goodbye to the characters. Take your time wandering the virtual streets. Talk to every weirdo you find. You might just find exactly what you were looking for when you first stepped off the bus in Possum Springs.