If you walked into a Hot Topic back in 2016, you probably saw them. Row after row of black boxes with that distinct red and white circus-style lettering. At the time, Five Nights at Freddy's 2 Funko Pops were just another wave of plastic collectibles hitting the shelves. Nobody really knew they’d become the "holy grail" items for horror fans.
Scott Cawthon’s second game changed everything for the franchise. It introduced the Withered animatronics and the shiny, creepy Toy variants. Naturally, Funko jumped on that. They released a massive wave of figures that captured the distinct look of the 1987 prequel.
But things got weird fast.
Some of these figures stayed in production for years. Others? They vanished. Now, if you're trying to complete a set of Five Nights at Freddy's 2 Funko Pops, you're not just looking at a trip to the mall. You’re looking at eBay bidding wars and checking for counterfeit "fakes" coming out of overseas warehouses. It's a mess, honestly. But it’s a fun mess if you know what to look for.
Why the Toy Animatronics Are So Hard to Find
There is a specific reason why the Toy Freddy, Toy Bonnie, and Toy Chica figures are a nightmare to track down today. When FNAF 2 first dropped, the community was obsessed with the new designs. They were sleek. They were plastic. They had those weird rosy cheeks. Funko nailed the aesthetic, but the distribution was uneven.
Take Toy Freddy, for example. He wasn't just a common release you could find at every Target. He was a Walmart exclusive.
Retailer exclusives are the bane of a collector's existence. If your local Walmart didn't stock him, or if a "scalper" (we all know the type) cleared the shelf on day one, you were out of luck. Years later, that $10 piece of plastic is now worth five or ten times that amount on the secondary market. It’s wild how that works. The demand for the "New" Freddy Fazbear hasn't dipped, especially since the movie brought a whole new generation of kids into the fandom who want the "vintage" merch.
Then you have Toy Bonnie. He was an FYE exclusive. Think about that. How many FYE stores are even left in your local mall? Not many. Because the store footprint was smaller, the production run was naturally more limited. If you have a vaulted Toy Bonnie sitting on your shelf in a mint condition box, you’re basically holding onto a piece of gaming history.
The Withered Mystery
Collectors always ask about the Withered animatronics. It’s the biggest "what if" in the Funko community. Technically, the main FNAF 2 wave focused heavily on the Toys and the "Shadow" variants. We got a Shadow Freddy (a Hot Topic exclusive that is now legendary) and a Shadow Bonnie.
But where are the Withered versions?
Funko sort of bypassed the true Withered designs from the second game in the traditional Pop line for a long time. We got "Twisted" ones and "Nightmare" ones, but the broken-down, faceless Withered Bonnie? He remains one of the most requested figures in the history of the line. Instead, fans had to settle for the Mystery Minis or custom-made figures. It’s a glaring hole in many collections.
Identifying Real vs. Fake FNAF 2 Pops
This is where it gets dangerous for your wallet. Because the value of Five Nights at Freddy's 2 Funko Pops has skyrocketed, the market is flooded with "bootlegs."
🔗 Read more: Black Flash Sound Effect Roblox: Why That One Audio Still Rules the Leaderboards
I’ve seen them all over Mercari and AliExpress. They look almost right. But "almost" doesn't count when you're dropping $80 on a rare figure. You have to look at the feet and the serial numbers. A real Funko Pop from the FNAF 2 era will have a production code (like JJL or DRM followed by a date) printed either on the bottom of the box or the bottom of the figure’s foot.
If that code doesn't match the box, or if the paint job looks a little too "glossy," walk away.
- The Box Art: Check the "Pop!" logo. On fakes, the yellow gradient is often off, or the white border around the character image is too thick.
- The Eyes: Funko has a very specific way of doing the black circular eyes. On bootlegs, they often look slightly sunken or are placed too far apart.
- The Weight: Real Pops have a bit of heft. Bootlegs feel like cheap, hollow plastic.
I remember talking to a collector at a convention in Orlando who bought a "Shadow Freddy" for $100, only to realize later the box was a high-quality scan. The figure inside was a repainted common Freddy. It’s brutal out there. Always ask for photos of the bottom of the box before you hit "Buy It Now."
The Puppets and the Puzzles
You can't talk about the second game without mentioning the Marionette—or The Puppet. This figure is a standout in the Five Nights at Freddy's 2 Funko Pops lineup. Unlike the bulky bear designs, the Puppet is thin and lanky. It actually requires a stand to stay upright, which is a detail some people lose over time.
If you’re buying a loose (out of box) Puppet, make sure the clear plastic stand is included. Without it, the figure just face-plants.
The Puppet was part of the common release wave, but because it’s such an iconic character (being the soul behind the animatronics and all), it’s highly sought after. It’s one of those figures that didn't seem rare in 2016 but is now a cornerstone of any serious display.
Why the Resale Market is Crashing (and Rising)
The value of these figures is like a roller coaster. When the FNAF movie was announced, prices doubled. When the movie actually came out, prices tripled.
But here’s a tip: wait for the "lull."
Usually, about six months after a big media release, casual fans start offloading their collections. That is the best time to hunt for Five Nights at Freddy's 2 Funko Pops. You’ll see listings pop up from people who just want to clear space in their closets.
Also, keep an eye on "vaulted" status. Once Funko "vaults" a figure, they destroy the molds. They aren't making more Toy Chicas. What is out there is all there will ever be. That scarcity is what drives the $150 price tags you see on specialized collector sites like Pop Price Guide (PPG) or HobbyDB.
💡 You might also like: How to Build an Ender Dragon Portal Without Getting Stuck in Creative Mode
Building a Collection Without Going Broke
You don't need to buy everything at once. Honestly, that’s how you end up with "buyer's remorse."
Start with the commons. Balloon Boy (BB) is usually one of the more affordable figures from the FNAF 2 era. He’s annoying in the game—stealing your batteries and laughing—but his Pop figure is actually pretty well-detailed. From there, move to the exclusives.
Check local comic book shops. Often, these shops have "trade-in" bins where they don't realize the specific value of a Walmart exclusive Toy Freddy. I once found a Flocked (fuzzy) Springtrap—which isn't strictly FNAF 2 but is from that era of releases—for $15 because the box was slightly dented.
Pro tip: The "damaged box" discount is your best friend. If you’re an "out of box" (OOB) collector, you can save 40% to 60% on these figures just by buying ones with crushed corners. The plastic inside is usually perfectly fine.
The Future of the Line
Will Funko ever go back and redo these? Probably. We’ve seen "Classics" lines before. But they won't be the same. The original Five Nights at Freddy's 2 Funko Pops have a specific "first edition" charm. The newer ones often have different finishes or updated sculpts that don't quite capture that 2014-era nostalgia.
If you’re looking to get started, here is your immediate action plan:
📖 Related: Snake and ladder game online: Why the world's oldest board game is suddenly everywhere again
- Download a Tracking App: Use the Funko App or HobbyDB to see the current "Market Value" so you don't get ripped off.
- Verify the Seller: If buying on eBay, only buy from sellers with 99% or higher feedback. Ask for a "timestamp" photo (a photo of the Pop with their username and today's date on a piece of paper).
- Check Local Listings: Facebook Marketplace is a goldmine. Parents often sell their kids' "old toys" for cheap without realizing they’re sitting on a $100 Toy Bonnie.
- Inspect the Paint: Especially on Toy Chica. Her beak and "Let's Party" bib are prone to factory errors. Look for the cleanest one you can find.
Collecting these isn't just about the money. It's about owning a piece of the game that redefined indie horror. Just be smart about it. Don't let the "hype" dictate your budget. The figures aren't going anywhere, and if you're patient, you'll find that Toy Freddy for a price that doesn't require a bank loan.
Stick to the verified sellers, learn to spot the fake boxes, and focus on the characters you actually like. That’s the real way to build a collection you won't regret in five years.
Next Steps for Your Collection:
Check the bottom of any FNAF Pops you already own for the production code (e.g., FAC-000000-00000). Cross-reference this code with the official Funko database to ensure authenticity. If you are hunting for Toy Freddy or Toy Bonnie specifically, set "Saved Search" alerts on secondary markets for "Damaged Box" listings to snag them at a fraction of the "Mint" price. Finally, join a dedicated FNAF collecting group on Reddit or Discord; these communities often trade figures at cost rather than at inflated resale prices.