You probably think of Edgar Allan Poe as the master of the macabre, the guy with the raven on his shoulder and a pen dipped in gloom. But in 1827, he was just a broke, anonymous teenager in Boston. He had zero fame. No money. He barely had a name—actually, he didn't even use his real one. He published his first book under the pseudonym "a Bostonian." That tiny, fragile pamphlet is now the most sought-after Edgar Allan Poe first edition in existence. It’s called Tamerlane and Other Poems.
Only about 40 or 50 copies were ever printed. Most ended up in the trash or used as kindling because, frankly, nobody cared. Today? If you find one in your attic, you've basically hit the Powerball.
Collectors don't just want these books because they're old. They want them because Poe represents the birth of the American short story and the detective genre. Owning a piece of that origin story is the ultimate flex in the bibliophile world. But the market for a high-end Edgar Allan Poe first edition is shark-infested waters. You need to know exactly what you’re looking at, or you’ll end up spending five figures on a 19th-century reprint that’s worth about fifty bucks.
The Impossible Hunt for Tamerlane
Let’s talk about the big one. Tamerlane and Other Poems. It’s a 40-page pamphlet. It’s thin. It’s ugly. It looks like a tax document from two centuries ago. When it was released by Calvin F. S. Thomas, it didn't even make a ripple in the literary world. Thomas was a jobbing printer who mostly did labels and flyers. He had no idea he was printing a cornerstone of American literature.
Because the paper was so cheap and the binding was non-existent (just a paper wrapper), most copies disintegrated. For decades, bibliographers weren't even sure if it actually existed. Then, in 1859, a copy surfaced in London. Since then, only 12 copies have been accounted for. Most are locked away in institutions like the New York Public Library or the Huntington.
The last time a Tamerlane hit the auction block in a major way was at Christie’s in 2009. It sold for $662,500. Honestly, in today’s market, a fine copy would likely shatter the million-dollar mark. It’s the "Inverted Jenny" of books.
If you see a copy of Tamerlane at a garage sale, it’s a facsimile. Always. There were dozens of reprints made in the 1920s and 30s as commemorative items. They look old to the untrained eye. They aren't. Real copies have specific "points"—bibliographical tells—like the specific typeface used on the title page and the exact weight of the paper stock.
Beyond the Pamphlet: The Tales and The Raven
Maybe you don't have a million dollars. Most people don't. That leads us to the 1845 editions, which are the "attainable" holy grails.
💡 You might also like: How to Watch The Wolf and the Lion Without Getting Lost in the Wild
The Raven and Other Poems and Tales were both published in 1845 by Wiley and Putnam. These are the books that actually made Poe a household name. If you're looking for a primary Edgar Allan Poe first edition that looks like a "real" book, this is where you start.
But there’s a catch. Wiley and Putnam often bound these two books together in a single volume. While a "combo" volume is valuable, the true collectors want the individual issues in their original green or yellowish paper wrappers. Why? Because paper wrappers are fragile. Finding a copy that hasn't been rebound in leather by some Victorian owner who thought they were "improving" it is incredibly rare.
When a book is rebound, it loses its "original state." To a hardcore collector, a rebound Poe is like a classic Mustang with a Honda engine. It still runs, but the soul is gone.
What to Look for in a 1845 First Edition
- The Copyright Page: Check the names of the stereotypers. In the first printing of Tales, you want to see "T.B. Smith, Stereotyper" and "H. Ludwig, Printer."
- The Adverts: In the back of these books, there are usually catalogs of other books the publisher was selling. The specific list of books advertised can tell you if you have a first or second state of the first edition.
- Condition of the Spine: These were "perfect bound" with glue, not sewn. They fall apart if you look at them wrong. A copy with an intact spine is worth triple a copy with a cracked one.
The Narrative of Arthur Gordon Pym
Poe only wrote one full-length novel. It’s a weird, hallucinatory sea voyage called The Narrative of Arthur Gordon Pym of Nantucket (1838). It wasn’t a hit. In fact, Poe himself later called it "a very silly book."
Despite his own hating on it, this Edgar Allan Poe first edition is a powerhouse. The first American edition was published by Harper & Brothers. You’re looking for a dull, ribbed cloth cover, usually in black or green.
Wait. There's a trick here. The British edition came out shortly after the American one. While the American is technically the "true" first, the British one is sometimes preferred by collectors because the title was changed and it often has a more interesting shelf presence. However, if you're a purist, you want the NYC imprint.
Check the date. It should say 1838 on the title page. If there's no date, or a later date, you’re looking at a reprint. Also, look for the 14 pages of ads at the end. If they’re missing, the value drops.
📖 Related: Is Lincoln Lawyer Coming Back? Mickey Haller's Next Move Explained
The Forgery Problem and the "Fake" Firsts
The market is messy. Because Poe is so valuable, people have been faking his stuff for a century. Not just the books, but signatures too.
You’ll often see "First Edition" listed on eBay for books printed in 1880 or 1890. Here’s the reality: Poe died in 1849. Anything printed after 1849 is a posthumous edition. While some early collected works (like the 1850 Redfield edition edited by Rufus Griswold) have value, they are not first editions of his individual works.
Griswold, by the way, was Poe's nemesis. He wrote a scathing obituary and then proceeded to edit Poe's works while trashing his reputation. It's one of the great ironies of literary history. Collectors still buy the 1850 The Works of the Late Edgar Allan Poe because it’s the first time many of the stories were collected, but don't pay "Tamerlane prices" for it.
How to spot a fake signature:
- The Ink: 19th-century ink was acidic. It often eats into the paper slightly or turns a brownish hue (iron gall ink). If the signature looks like it was written with a modern Sharpie or a ballpoint, run away.
- The Flow: Poe had a very controlled, almost architectural handwriting. Forgers often make it too "spooky" or shaky.
- The Location: Poe rarely signed his books. He was usually too poor to own many of them. Most "signed" Poe books are actually "association copies"—books owned by people he knew, rather than signed by the man himself.
Why the Market is Exploding Right Now
In the last five years, the value of high-end literary first editions has skyrocketed. Why? Diversification. Investors are moving away from just stocks and crypto and putting money into "tangible assets."
A Edgar Allan Poe first edition is a blue-chip asset. It’s like owning a Picasso. There is a finite supply. They aren't making any more 1827 pamphlets. As more copies get sucked into museum collections, the number of copies available for private ownership shrinks.
Supply down. Demand up. You know the drill.
But it’s also about the "vibe." Poe’s influence on pop culture—from The Fall of the House of Usher on Netflix to every detective show ever made—keeps him relevant. He isn't some dusty poet nobody reads. He’s the guy who invented the logic we use to solve crimes.
👉 See also: Tim Dillon: I'm Your Mother Explained (Simply)
Actionable Steps for the Aspiring Collector
Don't just go out and buy the first thing you see. You'll get burned. Collecting at this level requires a mix of detective work and patience.
Verify with a Professional
If you are spending more than $1,000, the book needs to be vetted by a member of the ABAA (Antiquarian Booksellers' Association of America) or the ILAB. These organizations have strict ethics codes. If a dealer isn't a member, ask why.
Check the Paper
Learn what "foxing" is. It’s those little brown spots on old paper caused by oxidation or mold. A little foxing is fine; it proves age. But "washed" pages—where someone used chemicals to clean the book—actually lower the value because they damage the fibers.
Start with the 1850 Redfield Set
If you want the "Poe experience" without the $50,000 price tag, look for the 1850-1856 Redfield sets. They are the first "collected" editions. They look beautiful on a shelf, they feel old, and they’re historically significant because they contain the first appearances of several essays. You can usually find a decent set for a few thousand dollars.
Focus on "The Gift"
Poe published many of his most famous stories in "annuals" or "gift books" before they appeared in his own volumes. For example, The Pit and the Pendulum first appeared in The Gift for 1843. These are technically the first printings. They are often much cheaper than his standalone books but just as important to the bibliography.
Document Everything
Provenance is king. If a book was once owned by a famous collector or has a "bookplate" from a known library, keep that paperwork. It adds a layer of security and value that a "blind" copy doesn't have.
Invest in a copy of The First Editions of Edgar Allan Poe by Merle Johnson or similar bibliographical guides. Knowledge is the only thing that prevents you from buying a very expensive piece of scrap paper. The hunt for an Edgar Allan Poe first edition isn't just about money; it’s about preserving a piece of the American gothic soul.