You're halfway through a Green Papaya salad or a steaming bowl of Phở and you realize the bottle is empty. That pungent, salty, funky liquid—the backbone of Southeast Asian cooking—is gone. It’s a minor kitchen tragedy. You might be tempted to just throw in some extra salt and call it a day, but please, don't do that.
Fish sauce is weird. It’s essentially just fish (usually anchovies) and salt left to ferment in wooden barrels for months until they break down into a thin, amber liquid. It smells like a locker room but tastes like pure gold. If you’re looking for a fish sauce substitute, you aren't just looking for salt. You're looking for glutamate. You're looking for that fermented "umami" punch that lingers on the back of your tongue.
Honestly, finding a replacement depends entirely on why you’re looking. Maybe you’re vegan. Maybe you have a shellfish allergy (though most fish sauce is just finfish, cross-contamination is a real risk). Or maybe, like most of us, you just forgot to go to the store.
Why Soy Sauce Alone Usually Fails
Most people grab the Kikkoman and think they’ve solved the problem. It doesn't work. Soy sauce is salty and earthy, sure, but it lacks the "stink" and the oceanic depth of nuoc mam or nam pla. If you use straight soy sauce, your Pad Thai will taste like... well, soy sauce.
If you're going to use soy sauce as a fish sauce substitute, you have to doctor it. A 1:1 swap makes the dish too dark and too sweet. To get closer to the real thing, try mixing soy sauce with a splash of lime juice or even a tiny bit of minced anchovy if you have them in a tin. The acidity helps cut the heavy bean flavor of the soy.
Actually, the best way to use soy sauce here is to find a "light" soy sauce (not low sodium, but the Chinese "light" variety) and mix it with a pinch of salt. It’s still not perfect, but it’s a start.
The Vegan Holy Grail: Dried Shiitakes and Seaweed
If you’re plant-based, you’ve probably tried those store-bought vegan fish sauces. Some are okay. Most are just flavored water. To get a real fish sauce substitute that doesn't involve animals, you have to go DIY.
The secret is the combination of dried shiitake mushrooms and kombu (dried seaweed).
- Simmer a piece of kombu and a handful of dried shiitakes in a cup of water.
- Reduce it until it’s concentrated.
- Add plenty of sea salt.
The seaweed provides that briny, "from the sea" flavor profile, while the mushrooms provide the heavy-hitting guanylate and glutamate. Famous vegan chef Andrea Nguyen has often pointed out that fermented soybean pastes can also bridge this gap. If you have some Miso in the back of the fridge, whisk a teaspoon of it into some warm water. It has that fermented funk that mimics the aging process of fish sauce surprisingly well.
Worsted-what? The Worcestershire Connection
This is the one that surprises people. Worcestershire sauce is basically British fish sauce. Seriously. Read the label. The primary flavoring agent in Lee & Perrins is fermented anchovies.
Because it’s fermented and fish-based, it carries the same chemical DNA as Thai fish sauce. However, it’s also packed with vinegar, molasses, tamarind, and cloves. It’s much more complex and "spicier" in a warm way.
If you use Worcestershire as a fish sauce substitute, use it sparingly. It works best in heavy, simmered dishes like stews or braises where the clove and cinnamon notes can blend in. Don't use it in a fresh Dipping Sauce (Nuoc Cham); the vinegar profile will be all wrong and it’ll look muddy.
The Secret Weapon: Liquid Aminos or Maggi Seasoning
If you haven't used Maggi Seasoning, you're missing out. It's a Swiss invention that became a staple across Vietnam and Europe. It’s a hydrolyzed vegetable protein extract. It’s pure umami.
Maggi is saltier and more "savory" than soy sauce. In many Vietnamese households, Maggi is actually preferred for certain dipping applications. It lacks the fishy aroma, but it hits the same pleasure centers in the brain.
Liquid Aminos (like Bragg’s) are a similar deal. They are slightly sweeter and less intense than Maggi but serve as a fantastic fish sauce substitute for those avoiding gluten or soy-heavy diets.
Anchovy Paste: The Most Accurate Shortcut
Since fish sauce is made from anchovies, why not just go to the source?
If a recipe calls for a tablespoon of fish sauce, you can often substitute a half-teaspoon of anchovy paste. Mash it into your aromatics (garlic, ginger, onions) while they sauté. The heat melts the paste, and the "fishy" flavor mellows out into a savory richness.
📖 Related: Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara: Why This One Tube Still Dominates the Beauty World
This is particularly effective in Italian-leaning dishes or even stir-frys. It provides the exact same protein breakdown as the liquid sauce. Just be careful with the salt—anchovy paste is incredibly potent.
Why the "Funk" Matters
We need to talk about the smell. That pungent aroma is volatile. When you cook fish sauce, the "stink" actually evaporates, leaving behind a mellow, nutty sweetness.
If your fish sauce substitute is missing that aroma, your brain might feel like something is "off" even if the salt levels are right. This is where a drop of shrimp paste or even a bit of fermented bean curd can help. These ingredients are intense. Use a toothpick-sized amount. It adds that missing "depth" that makes people go, "I don't know what's in this, but it's delicious."
Quick Reference for Common Substitutions
- For Curries: Use Soy sauce + a squeeze of lime. The coconut milk masks the differences.
- For Stir-frys: Use Oyster sauce. It’s thicker and sweeter, but it has the seafood element.
- For Salad Dressings: Use extra salt + a finely minced oil-packed anchovy.
- For Soups: Use a combination of soy sauce and dried mushroom broth.
The Salt Factor
One major mistake people make is forgetting that fish sauce is roughly 20-25% salt. It is saltier than almost any soy sauce on the market. If you swap 1:1 with soy sauce, you will likely need to add an extra pinch of kosher salt to reach the same flavor peak.
Salt is a flavor enhancer. Without enough of it, the other spices in your Thai or Vietnamese dish—the galangal, the lemongrass, the chili—won't pop. They'll just taste muted and "muddy."
The Nutritional Side of the Swap
Some people look for a fish sauce substitute because they’re watching their sodium. Honestly? It’s tough. Fish sauce is a high-sodium ingredient by design.
If you’re heart-healthy, your best bet is to use a "No-Fish" sauce made from coconut aminos. Coconut aminos are tapped from the sap of coconut blossoms. They are naturally lower in sodium and have a surprisingly dark, savory flavor. The downside? They are quite sweet. You’ll want to increase the lime juice or vinegar in your recipe to balance out that sugar.
Final Insights for the Home Cook
Don't panic. Cooking is about balance, not perfection.
If you are out of fish sauce, your goal isn't to replicate the exact chemical composition of fermented anchovies. Your goal is to balance Salt, Acid, and Umami. ### Your Action Plan
- Check your pantry for "hidden" umami. Do you have Parmesan rinds? Tomato paste? Anchovies in a tin? Miso? All of these contain the glutamates you need.
- Combine sources. Don't just use soy sauce. Use soy sauce and a little Worcestershire. Or soy sauce and a bit of mushroom powder. Layering the flavors creates a more convincing "fake" fish sauce.
- Taste as you go. Fish sauce is often added at the end of cooking to preserve its brightness. If you're using a substitute like soy or miso, add it earlier so the flavors have time to meld and the "raw" bean taste cooks off.
- Buy in bulk next time. Seriously. A good bottle of Red Boat or Megachef lasts for a year in the fridge. It’s worth the cabinet space.
If you really want to get close to the professional standard, keep a small jar of "Mushroom Seasoning" (the yellow bag found in most Asian markets) in your spice drawer. It is essentially granulated umami. A half-teaspoon of that mixed with some salt and water is the closest "emergency" fish sauce substitute you will ever find.
Cooking is an experiment. Even if the dish doesn't taste exactly like the one you had in Hanoi, as long as it has that hit of salt and savory depth, you've succeeded.