If you were hoping for a storybook ending to a messy season, the final score of the Dallas Cowboys game on January 4, 2026, probably felt like a cold bucket of water. The Cowboys walked into MetLife Stadium needing a win to salvage some dignity. They walked out with a 34-17 loss to a New York Giants team that had only won three games all year.
It was ugly. Really ugly.
But looking at the scoreboard doesn't tell you half of it. This wasn't just another loss; it was a total system failure that effectively ended the Mike McCarthy/Brian Schottenheimer era and sent Jerry Jones into a tailspin. By the time the fourth quarter rolled around, the Cowboys weren't just losing the game—they looked like they’d forgotten how to play football.
Breaking down the final score of the Dallas Cowboys game
The game started with a glimmer of hope, which is usually how the Cowboys hurt you the most. After an early Dak Prescott fumble—a snap he just straight-up dropped—the defense actually held firm. They forced a field goal. Then Brandon Aubrey, who has basically been the only reliable part of this team, tied it up.
KaVontae Turpin then did what he does best. He ripped off an 84-yard kickoff return that set up Jaydon Blue for a 14-yard touchdown. For a few minutes there, Dallas was up 10-6. You could almost hear the collective sigh of relief from North Texas.
Then the wheels came off.
👉 See also: Last Match Man City: Why Newcastle Couldn't Stop the Semenyo Surge
The Giants, led by rookie Jaxson Dart, started slicing through the Dallas secondary like it was made of wet paper. A 96-yard drive by the Giants right before halftime was the turning point. Daniel Bellinger caught a 29-yard touchdown pass that made it 16-10 at the break. Dallas never led again.
Why the defense collapsed (again)
You can’t talk about the final score of the Dallas Cowboys game without talking about the penalties. It was a circus. Kenneth Murray got flagged for a late hit out of bounds that gave New York a first down on a drive that should have been dead. Later, Caelen Carson got hit with a 33-yard pass interference call on a 3rd-and-19.
3rd-and-19!
When you give a struggling rookie quarterback those kinds of gifts, you're going to lose. Jaxson Dart finished with 230 yards and two touchdowns. He looked like a Pro Bowler because the Cowboys' defense was too busy fighting each other and the refs. At one point, Donovan Ezeiruaku literally ripped the helmet off a Giants lineman during a scrum. It was undisciplined, chaotic, and frankly, embarrassing for a franchise that calls itself "America's Team."
The Dak and Milton dilemma
Dak Prescott's day was short and weird. He went 7-for-11 for 70 yards before being pulled. Some say it was an injury precaution, others think the coaching staff just wanted to see what Joe Milton III could do.
✨ Don't miss: Cowboys Score: Why Dallas Just Can't Finish the Job When it Matters
Spoiler: Milton didn't do much.
He threw a late interception to Bobby Okereke that basically iced the game. While Milton has the "cannon" arm everyone loves to talk about, his 38.3 passer rating in this game proved he isn't ready to take the keys to the kingdom.
- Final Score: Giants 34, Cowboys 17
- Total Yards: Giants 380, Cowboys 286
- Turnovers: Dallas 2, New York 1
- Sacks: Cowboys 4, Giants 0 (The only bright spot was Jadeveon Clowney)
Jadeveon Clowney actually had a monster game with three sacks. It’s almost tragic that a career-high performance from a veteran pass rusher was wasted on a game where the offense couldn't stay on the field for more than four minutes at a time. The time of possession was heavily skewed, with New York holding the ball for over 33 minutes.
What this means for the 2026 offseason
The final score of the Dallas Cowboys game wasn't just a number; it was a death knell for the current roster construction. Jerry Jones spoke to reporters afterward looking like he’d seen a ghost. He mentioned that the team needs to make a "dramatic difference" this offseason.
That’s "Jerry-speak" for a fire sale.
🔗 Read more: Jake Paul Mike Tyson Tattoo: What Most People Get Wrong
The Cowboys are currently about $34 million over the salary cap. They have 22 pending free agents. Logic suggests they’ll try to keep George Pickens, who has been a revelation, and maybe Javonte Williams. But everyone else? They might be packing their bags. Missing the playoffs for two straight years is unacceptable in Dallas, especially when you finish 7-9-1.
That tie earlier in the season against the Packers looks even worse now. If they had won that game, maybe the vibe going into the Giants finale would have been different. But "maybe" doesn't win Super Bowls, and it definitely doesn't save jobs.
The road ahead
Dallas is looking at a brutal 2026 schedule. They have to play the 49ers (who have beaten them four times in a row), the Seahawks, and the Texans. If they don't fix the culture of penalties and defensive lapses, next year's scores won't look much better.
The fan base is exhausted. Honestly, can you blame them? You spend all year riding the roller coaster only to watch the season end with a blowout loss to a division rival that was mathematically eliminated weeks ago.
The first step for the front office is figuring out the coaching situation. Then comes the cap-casualty list. It's going to be a long, loud winter in Frisco.
To stay ahead of the roster changes, monitor the waiver wire and cap-cut announcements throughout February. The team will likely prioritize defensive interior help and a veteran corner to pair with Trevon Diggs. Watch for the official 2026 NFL Draft order to see where Dallas lands after this slide; they'll need a blue-chip prospect to reset the defensive identity.