You've probably said it a thousand times. Maybe you were describing a desperate scramble for a promotion, or how your local sports team barely eked out a win. "We fought tooth and nail," you say. It sounds gritty. It feels primal. But if you actually stop to visualize what that means—literally using your incisors and your keratin claws to tear at an opponent—it’s actually pretty gross.
Language is weird like that.
We use these idioms as conversational shorthand without ever realizing we’re referencing a legal battle from the 1500s or a biological survival mechanism that dates back to before humans even had words. Honestly, the story of why we still talk about teeth and nails in the age of digital warfare and boardroom meetings is a wilder ride than most people think. It’s about survival, legal loopholes, and the stubborn way humans refuse to let go of their most animalistic instincts.
The 16th-Century Legal Drama You Didn't Know About
Most people assume this is just a "caveman" phrase. It’s not. Well, not entirely. While the physical act of biting and scratching is obviously ancient, the written record of "tooth and nail" pops up in a very specific context in the mid-1500s.
One of the earliest recorded uses in English comes from a 1560 work by a guy named Nicholas Udall. He was a playwright and a schoolmaster, and he used the Latin-derived toto corpore, basically meaning with the whole body. But the English translation he helped popularize was "with tooth and nail."
It wasn’t just poetic.
Back then, if you were in a physical altercation, the law cared deeply about how you fought. Using weapons suggested premeditation. But fighting with your natural "equipment"—your teeth and your nails—was seen as a sign of desperate, spontaneous self-defense. It was the ultimate "I had no other choice" move. If you’re down to your fingernails, you’re clearly at the end of your rope.
It’s Actually a Translation of an Ancient Latin Joke
If we’re being real, Udall didn't just invent it. He was riffing on the Latin phrase toto corpore et cavis unguibus.
Literally: With the whole body and with hollowed nails.
The Romans were big on rhetoric. They loved the idea of a person being so committed to an argument or a fight that they’d revert to a feline state. Think about a cat. A cat doesn't give up. A cat uses every single biological tool it has to win a scrap. When Cicero or other Roman orators wanted to describe someone being incredibly stubborn, they’d evoke this image of a beastly struggle.
Fast forward a few centuries, and the phrase gets picked up by writers like Du Bartas and eventually makes its way into the common vernacular of the 1800s. By the time the Victorian era rolled around, the phrase had been polished up. It moved from the literal dirt of a street fight into the metaphorical halls of Parliament. You weren't literally biting the opposition, but you were sure as hell fighting them with the same intensity.
Why Biology Makes This Phrase So Relatable
There's a reason this specific idiom stuck while others—like "fighting with hilt and blade"—faded away into the history books. It’s because it’s hardwired into our amygdala.
When humans are under extreme duress, the "fight or flight" response kicks in. If you can’t fly, and you don’t have a tool, what do you have? You have your grip and your bite. Primatologists have noted this in almost all Great Apes. When a struggle becomes a matter of life or death, the sophisticated social rules of the troop vanish.
👉 See also: Mar-a-Lago: Why the Trump Palm Beach Home Is Way More Than Just a Club
It’s the "cornered animal" effect.
Biologically, our fingernails aren't great weapons anymore. We don't have the claws of a leopard. Our teeth are relatively flat compared to a wolf's. But the intent is what the phrase captures. It's the psychological state of total commitment. When you say you're fighting tooth and nail for a relationship or a job, you're telling the world that you've bypassed your logical, prefrontal cortex and tapped into something much older.
It’s visceral. You feel it in your chest when you say it.
The Misconceptions: No, It’s Not About "Tooth and Nail" Pliers
I've heard this theory at bars and in YouTube comments sections: that the phrase comes from carpentry. The idea is that you're using a "tooth" (a gear or a saw) and a "nail" (a fastener).
That is 100% false.
It’s a classic example of folk etymology—where people try to find a logical, modern explanation for an old phrase that sounds confusing. There is no historical evidence linking this to construction. It has always been about the anatomy of the human (or animal) body.
Another weird one? That it refers to the "tooth" of a gear and the "nail" of a clutch. Again, nope. The phrase predates the Industrial Revolution by centuries. Don't believe the Reddit threads on this one. Stick to the anatomy.
Real-World Examples of the "Tooth and Nail" Mentality
Look at the 1995 Rugby World Cup.
The South African Springboks were massive underdogs against the New Zealand All Blacks. The game wasn't just about sports; it was about a country trying to find its identity post-apartheid. They didn't just play; they fought with a desperate, grinding intensity that sports historians still talk about today. They were, in every sense of the word, fighting tooth and nail. They weren't the more talented team, but they were the more tenacious one.
Or look at the legal battle over the patent for CRISPR gene editing.
Jennifer Doudna and Zhang Feng's respective institutions have been locked in a "tooth and nail" struggle for years. We're talking about billions of dollars in future revenue and the Nobel Prize on the line. They aren't throwing punches, but the legal filings are aggressive, relentless, and use every possible "natural" advantage to win.
This is the modern evolution of the phrase. The "claws" are now high-priced attorneys, and the "teeth" are technicalities in patent law.
The Nuance of Tenacity vs. Aggression
It’s easy to confuse fighting tooth and nail with just being a jerk. But there’s a nuance here that expert communicators understand.
Aggression is about attacking.
Tenacity (fighting tooth and nail) is about refusing to be defeated.
One is offensive; the other is defensive. When you fight tooth and nail, you’re usually the underdog. You’re the one with your back against the wall. That’s why we usually find the phrase inspiring rather than scary. It’s the "Rudy" story. It’s the small startup taking on Google. It’s the person recovering from a "terminal" illness who defies the doctors' odds.
How to Actually Apply This Mentality (Without Biting Anyone)
So, how do you use this? Not the phrase, but the actual spirit of it?
In a world that loves "quiet quitting" and "low-effort" hacks, there is still immense value in absolute, unmitigated tenacity. But you have to be smart about it. Fighting tooth and nail on a project that is fundamentally broken is just a waste of energy.
- Pick the right hill. Don't use this level of intensity for a Friday afternoon email chain. Save it for the stuff that actually defines your career or your life.
- Identify your "nails." In a modern context, your nails are your unique skills—the things you can "grip" onto when things get slippery. This could be your ability to synthesize data or your knack for public speaking.
- Know when the fight is over. The downside of the tooth-and-nail mentality is that it’s hard to turn off. Animals only stop when the threat is gone or they're dead. Humans have to be better at recognizing a stalemate.
The Future of the Phrase
Will we still be saying this in 2126? Honestly, probably.
Even as we move further into a world of AI and automation, our physical bodies remain the primary way we experience the world. We still have teeth. We still have nails. As long as humans have a physical form, the metaphor of using that form to survive will resonate.
It’s a reminder that beneath our clothes, our degrees, and our smartphones, we are still creatures capable of incredible, desperate, and beautiful struggle.
Actionable Next Steps for the Tenacious
If you find yourself in a situation where you need to fight tooth and nail—whether it's for a cause you believe in or a personal goal—keep these three things in mind to ensure your effort isn't wasted:
- Audit your resources immediately. Before you start the "fight," look at what tools you actually have. If you don't have "weapons" (money, status, power), identify your "teeth and nails" (stamina, niche knowledge, community support).
- Document the struggle. In modern disputes, the "nail" that often wins is the paper trail. Whether it’s a workplace dispute or a creative disagreement, having a record is the modern equivalent of a firm grip.
- Rest strategically. You cannot fight at 100% intensity forever. Even the most desperate animal has to sleep. If you’re in a long-term "tooth and nail" battle, you have to schedule periods of total disengagement to avoid burnout.
The phrase isn't just a cliché. It’s a roadmap for the underdog. Use it wisely.