Female Pirates of History: What Most People Get Wrong About Life Under the Black Flag

The ocean is a big place. It’s even bigger when you’re a woman in the 1700s trying to outrun the Royal Navy while living in a space no larger than a studio apartment with eighty sweaty, vitamin-deficient men. We've all seen the Hollywood version. You know the one—the flowing corsets, the perfect hair, the sassy quips. Honestly? It was mostly just damp. And salt-crusted. And incredibly dangerous. When we talk about female pirates of history, we aren't just talking about a few outliers who got lucky. We are talking about women who navigated the most rigid gender hierarchies of their time by literally sailing right past them.

Most people think of piracy as a boys' club. It wasn't. While the Golden Age of Piracy was definitely male-dominated, women weren't just "along for the ride." They were strategists. They were brawlers. They were, in the case of some, the absolute CEOs of massive criminal enterprises that would make a modern logistics company look disorganized.

The Caribbean Duo Everyone Knows (And One Big Myth)

Anne Bonny and Mary Read. These names are the bedrock of female pirates of history lore. But here’s the thing: most of what we "know" comes from a single 1724 book called A General History of the Pyrates by Captain Charles Johnson. Historians are still arguing over whether Johnson was a real guy or just a pen name for Daniel Defoe. Because of this, the line between biography and pulp fiction is thinner than a tattered sail.

Anne wasn't some poor waif. She was the illegitimate daughter of a wealthy lawyer in Charleston. She was headstrong. She supposedly stabbed a servant girl with a table knife when she was a teenager, though that might be one of those "legend-building" embellishments. She ended up in New Providence, the pirate capital of the Bahamas, where she met Calico Jack Rackham.

Jack wasn't a great pirate. He was actually kind of a loser in the grand scheme of Caribbean outlaws. But Anne liked him.

Then there’s Mary Read. Mary had been dressing as a man since she was a kid—initially to scam money out of a grandmother, then to join the British military. She was a veteran. She knew how to use a sword better than most men on any deck. When she ended up on Rackham’s ship, the William, she and Anne became the most competent people on board.

When the "pirate hunters" finally caught up with them in 1720, the men were all below deck, too drunk to fight. Only Anne, Mary, and one other man stayed on deck to defend the ship. Mary was so disgusted by the men's cowardice that she actually fired her pistol down into the hold, killing one of her own crewmates just to make a point. They were eventually captured and sentenced to hang, but both "pleaded their bellies"—they were pregnant. In British law, you couldn't execute a pregnant woman.

Mary died of a fever in prison. Anne? She just... disappeared. Some say her rich dad bought her freedom. Some say she went back to South Carolina. We’ll never actually know. That’s the thing about history; sometimes the trail just goes cold in a damp Jamaican jail cell.

📖 Related: Charlie Gunn Lynnville Indiana: What Really Happened at the Family Restaurant

The Most Powerful Pirate in History Was a Woman

Forget Blackbeard. Forget Drake. If we are talking about sheer scale, the most successful of all female pirates of history was Zheng Yi Sao.

She lived in the early 19th century in China. She started as a sex worker on a floating brothel in Canton. By the time she retired, she commanded the Red Flag Fleet. We aren't talking about one ship. We are talking about 1,800 vessels and somewhere between 40,000 to 60,000 pirates. To put that in perspective, the entire British Royal Navy at the time was roughly 100,000 people spread across the entire planet. She dominated the South China Sea.

She was a legal genius.

She created a code of laws that would make a drill sergeant sweat. If you gave an order that didn't come from her? Beheaded. If you stole from the common fund? Beheaded. If you raped a female prisoner? Beheaded. She understood that a mob of 60,000 people only works if there is absolute discipline.

How she actually won

Most pirates end up swinging from a rope or dying of scurvy. Zheng Yi Sao didn't. When the Chinese government realized they couldn't beat her—even with help from the British and Portuguese navies—they offered her a deal.

Amnesty.

She negotiated a retirement package that let her keep her loot. She opened a gambling house. She died at 69, wealthy and peaceful. That is the ultimate "win" in the pirate world. She didn't just break the glass ceiling; she turned it into a fleet and conquered the coast.

👉 See also: Charcoal Gas Smoker Combo: Why Most Backyard Cooks Struggle to Choose

Beyond the Golden Age: The Irish Sea and the Baltic

We have to look further back than the 1700s to see the full scope of this. Grace O’Malley (Gráinne Mhaol) is the 16th-century Irish chieftain who basically told Queen Elizabeth I to stay out of her water.

Grace was born into a seafaring family. When her father told her she couldn't go to sea because her long hair would get caught in the ropes, she chopped it all off. That earned her the nickname "Bald Grace." She spent decades raiding the English and rival Irish clans.

There is a famous story about her meeting Elizabeth I in London. Grace refused to bow because she didn't recognize Elizabeth as the Queen of Ireland. They spoke in Latin because it was the only language they both knew. Imagine that: two of the most powerful women in the world, sitting in a palace, haggling over shipping lanes and kidnapped relatives in a dead language.

Scandinavian Shields

Then you have the legendary figures like Alfhild. Was she real? Maybe. She’s mentioned in Gesta Danorum, a 12th-century work of Danish history. The story goes she became a pirate to avoid an unwanted marriage. She led a crew of young women who dressed as men.

Whether Alfhild was a historical person or a folk hero doesn't change the fact that the Viking Age had a concept for this: the Shieldmaiden. Archeology is starting to back this up. In 2017, DNA testing on a famous 10th-century Viking warrior grave in Birka, Sweden, proved the skeleton was female. She was buried with swords, axes, and two horses. She was a high-ranking military strategist. For centuries, historians just assumed she was a man because she had weapons. They were wrong.

Why did they do it?

The motivation for female pirates of history wasn't usually some romantic quest for "freedom" in the way we see it in movies. It was often a cold, hard calculation.

1. Economic survival: In the 17th and 18th centuries, a woman’s legal existence was basically tied to her father or husband. Piracy offered a "clean slate."
2. Escaping Law: Some, like Mary Read, were already living on the margins.
3. Power: For someone like Zheng Yi Sao, it was a way to rise from the very bottom of society to a position where even emperors had to respect her.

The ship was a meritocracy. Mostly. If you could pull a rope, fire a swivel gun, and didn't complain about the maggoty biscuits, the crew generally didn't care what was under your coat. Life was short anyway.

✨ Don't miss: Celtic Knot Engagement Ring Explained: What Most People Get Wrong

The Logistics of Living as a Woman on a Pirate Ship

It wasn't easy. You’ve got zero privacy. You’re sharing a deck with men who aren't exactly known for their refined manners.

To survive as female pirates of history, many women adopted "male" personas. This wasn't just about clothes; it was about survival. If you were recognized as a woman, you were often seen as "bad luck" or a distraction that would cause infighting among the crew. Many pirate codes—like the ones written by Bartholomew Roberts—explicitly forbade bringing women or boys on board under penalty of death.

So, you disguised yourself. You learned to curse. You learned the "mariner's shuffle." You worked twice as hard to prove you weren't a liability.

What we get wrong about the "Pirate Look"

Forget the leather bustiers. A real pirate woman in the 1700s would be wearing:

• Slops: Baggy, knee-length trousers.
• A Tars jacket: Heavy wool to protect against the spray.
• Checkered shirts: Standard maritime wear.
• Grease: Lots of it. To keep the skin from cracking in the salt air.

It was a gritty, dirty, smelly existence. But for a woman who faced a life of domestic servitude or precarious poverty on land, the smell of rotting seaweed and gunpowder probably smelled a lot like autonomy.

Navigating the Legacy

When we look at female pirates of history, we see a reflection of whatever era is doing the looking. In the Victorian era, they were "fallen women" or "monsters." In the 1970s, they were feminist icons. Today, we see them as complex figures who operated in a "gray zone" of morality.

They weren't "good" people. They were thieves. Sometimes they were murderers. But they were also incredibly resilient. They navigated a world that had no place for them, and they did it by carving out their own space with a cutlass.

Actionable Insights for History Buffs and Researchers

If you want to move beyond the surface-level myths and really understand the world of these women, here is how you should approach your research:

• Check the primary sources: Look for the High Court of Admiralty records. These are the actual trial transcripts. When Anne Bonny and Mary Read were tried, the witnesses were real people—sailors they had robbed—giving sworn testimony. This is where the "real" pirate talk is found, not in novels.
• Study the "L'Olonnais" effect: Understand that 18th-century writers loved to sensationalize. If a story sounds too much like a romance novel, it probably is. Look for the mundane details: how they handled the "quartermaster" system or how they distributed prize money.
• Look at Maritime Law: Research "Coverture." Understanding the legal "non-existence" of women on land helps explain why the lawless sea was so attractive.
• Follow the Archeology: Keep an eye on shipwreck excavations in the South China Sea and the Caribbean. New tech is allowing us to identify personal belongings that give us clues about who was actually on those ships.

The history of piracy is still being written. Every time a new wreck is found or a colonial ledger is digitized, we get a clearer picture. These women weren't just footnotes; they were the ones making the ink.