You’ve heard it. I’ve heard it. We’ve all sat on the couch with a box of tissues while someone—usually a well-meaning relative—loomed over us with a bowl of chicken soup or a plate of dry toast, reciting that age-old medical proverb. But the feed a fever and starve a cold meaning has become a bit of a linguistic mess over the last few centuries. Honestly, most people say it backward, or they misunderstand the biology behind it entirely.
It’s one of those bits of "folklore medicine" that feels like it should be buried in the 1800s alongside bloodletting and arsenic tonics. Except, strangely enough, modern science has started poking around the edges of this advice. Researchers are finding that the way our bodies handle nutrients during an infection isn't just a matter of "comfort food." It's an immunological strategy.
The Long, Weird History of the Phrase
Where did this even come from?
Most historians point back to John Withals’s A Short Dictionarie for Yonge Beginners published in 1574. He basically wrote that "fasting is a great remedy of sickness." The idea was rooted in the ancient theory of humors. Back then, medical "experts" believed a cold was caused by a drop in body temperature—literally a "cold" disposition—and that the body needed fuel (food) to generate heat. Conversely, a fever was seen as the body over-revving. If you fed a fever, you were essentially pouring gasoline on a fire.
The logic was simple: starve the fire, stoke the chill.
But here is the kicker. Over the centuries, the phrasing drifted. Some interpretations suggest the original intent was actually a warning: "If you feed a fever, you'll have to starve a cold later," implying that overeating while ill would lead to a longer recovery. Others argue it was meant as "If you feed a cold, you can prevent a fever." It’s a linguistic game of telephone that has left us all very confused about whether we should be reaching for the crackers or the fasting timer.
What Your Immune System Actually Wants
When you’re sick, your body is a literal war zone.
Your metabolism doesn't just sit idly by. It shifts. When you have a fever, your metabolic rate actually spikes. For every degree your body temperature rises, your energy expenditure goes up significantly. You’re burning calories just by lying there shivering under a duvet. This is why "starving" a fever is usually terrible advice. Your white blood cells are sprinting. They need ATP. They need glucose. If you don't eat, your body starts raiding its own stores, which can leave you feeling even more trashed than the virus intended.
🔗 Read more: In the Veins of the Drowning: The Dark Reality of Saltwater vs Freshwater
The Bacterial vs. Viral Divide
There’s a fascinating study from Yale University, led by Dr. Ruslan Medzhitov and published in the journal Cell in 2016, that totally flipped the script on this debate. They looked at how mice responded to food while fighting different types of infections.
The results were wild.
When the mice had a bacterial infection (the kind that often leads to high fevers), forcing them to eat was actually lethal. Their bodies needed to undergo a process called "ketogenesis"—burning fats instead of sugars—to survive the bacterial stress. However, when the mice had a viral infection (like the common cold or the flu), the exact opposite was true. The mice that were fed survived, while the mice that were fasted died.
Basically, the feed a fever and starve a cold meaning might be biologically flipped depending on what’s actually living in your lungs or gut.
- Viruses (The Cold/Flu): These guys generally require a glucose-rich environment for the host to survive the inflammatory response.
- Bacteria: These often thrive on the same nutrients you do, and your body might instinctively shut down your appetite to "starve" the invaders or protect your brain from oxidative stress.
Why You Lose Your Appetite Anyway
Ever noticed how the smell of bacon—usually the best thing on earth—becomes nauseating when you have the flu? That’s not an accident. It’s called sickness behavior.
Your brain, specifically the hypothalamus, is taking direct orders from your immune system. Cytokines (the messengers of your immune system) tell your brain to turn off the "hunger" switch. This saves energy. Digestion is expensive. It takes a lot of blood flow and muscular effort to move a sandwich through twenty feet of tubing. By shutting down your appetite, your body redirects that energy to the front lines.
So, if you’re forcing yourself to eat because "Grandma said so," you might be fighting your own internal biological wisdom.
💡 You might also like: Whooping Cough Symptoms: Why It’s Way More Than Just a Bad Cold
The Hydration Factor (The Non-Negotiable)
If there is one part of the "starve a cold" myth that is dangerously wrong, it's the implication that you don't need intake. You can survive without a cheeseburger for two days. You cannot survive without water, especially when your temperature is 102°F.
Fevers cause dehydration through sweating and increased respiration. When your mucous membranes dry out, they can’t trap viruses as effectively. Your "cilia"—the little hairs in your nose and throat—become less efficient at sweeping out the gunk.
Pro-tip: If your urine looks like apple juice, stop worrying about the "feed/starve" debate and start drinking water. Or broth. Or electrolyte drinks. Honestly, even a popsicle counts.
Breaking Down the "Feed a Fever" Logic
Let’s get practical. If you have a fever, you’re likely dealing with an increased heart rate and rapid breathing. Your body is trying to cook the pathogen out of existence.
- Fuel the fire: Since your metabolism is higher, you need easy-to-digest carbohydrates. Think bananas, rice, or applesauce.
- Protein for repair: Your immune system uses proteins to create antibodies. A little bit of Greek yogurt or a mild broth with some shredded chicken can go a long way.
- The "Starve" Misconception: If you "starve" a fever, you risk hypoglycemia, which makes the dizziness and body aches ten times worse.
What About the "Starve a Cold" Side?
Colds are usually mild. You don't typically run a massive fever with a standard rhinovirus. You’re just congested, tired, and annoyed.
The idea of "starving" here usually stems from the belief that digestion creates "excess mucus." There is zero scientific evidence that eating a normal meal makes your nose run more, with the exception of spicy foods (which actually help clear your sinuses) or perhaps dairy for a very small percentage of the population who find it makes their phlegm feel thicker.
In reality, starving a cold just weakens your defenses. You need vitamin C, zinc, and Vitamin D. You get those from food.
📖 Related: Why Do Women Fake Orgasms? The Uncomfortable Truth Most People Ignore
When to Actually Listen to Your Body
Sometimes the most "expert" advice is to stop overthinking the old wives' tales.
If you’re hungry, eat. If the thought of food makes you want to barf, don’t eat. It’s really that simple for 90% of minor illnesses. Your body has evolved over millions of years to signal exactly what it needs. The only caveat is for children and the elderly, where dehydration and caloric drops happen much faster and can become dangerous.
Real-World Food Choices for the Sick
Don't go for a 12-ounce steak. Your body won't thank you. Instead, look for:
- Warm liquids: They dilate blood vessels and help move mucus.
- Garlic and Ginger: These aren't just for flavor; they have genuine antimicrobial and anti-inflammatory properties.
- Honey: Better than most over-the-counter cough syrups for coating the throat.
The Verdict on the Old Saying
The feed a fever and starve a cold meaning is essentially a relic of a time when we didn't understand germs. We thought illnesses were about "heat" and "cold." While the Yale study suggests there's a kernel of truth regarding how we handle bacteria vs. viruses, the blanket advice is mostly junk.
Don't starve yourself.
Don't force-feed yourself until you're miserable.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Sick Day
- Monitor your temperature first. If it’s a low-grade fever, let it run. It's your body's natural defense. If it hits 103°F or higher, it’s time for fluids and a call to a professional.
- Prioritize fluids over solids. Dehydration mimics flu symptoms, making you feel worse than you actually are.
- Ignore the proverbs. Focus on "micro-meals." Small bites of calorie-dense, easy-to-digest foods (like toast with a bit of honey) provide a steady stream of energy without taxing your digestive system.
- Check your meds. Remember that many over-the-counter "cold and flu" meds contain pain relievers that can be hard on an empty stomach. If you’re taking ibuprofen, try to have at least a few crackers to protect your stomach lining.
The bottom line? Your grandma was a smart woman, but she didn't have access to a molecular biology lab. Use common sense, stay hydrated, and eat when your stomach gives you the green light.