If you walked up to a random person in 1944 and told them a president could only serve eight years, they’d probably look at you like you’ve lost your mind. At that point, Franklin Delano Roosevelt was deep into his third term and cruising toward a fourth. It felt permanent. He was the face of the Great Depression recovery and the voice on the radio during World War II. People literally couldn't imagine anyone else in the White House.
The fdr number of terms is the ultimate "glitch" in American political history. Technically, before 1951, there wasn't a law stopping anyone from running forever. George Washington just set a vibe by walking away after two, and everyone else basically followed suit because they didn't want to look like a king. Then came 1940. With Europe on fire and the U.S. economy still shaky, Roosevelt decided the "unwritten rule" didn't apply to him.
He stayed. And stayed.
The Breaking of the Two-Term Tradition
It’s kinda wild to think about how much the world changed between 1933 and 1945. When Roosevelt first took office, the "Bonus Army" of veterans was camping out in D.C. begging for money. By the time he was in his fourth term, the U.S. was dropping atomic bombs and redrawing the map of the globe.
Roosevelt won four presidential elections. Four.
👉 See also: Ethics in the News: What Most People Get Wrong
He beat Herbert Hoover in '32, Alf Landon in '36, Wendell Willkie in '40, and Thomas Dewey in '44. Each time, his opponents screamed about "dictatorship." They argued that the fdr number of terms was becoming a threat to democracy itself. Even some of his own supporters were nervous. But the voters? They didn't care. They wanted the guy who gave them the New Deal and the guy who was winning the war.
In the 1940 election, the slogan was "Better a Third Termer than a Third Rater." It worked. Roosevelt shattered the precedent set by Washington and Jefferson. He argued that in a time of "extraordinary" crisis, the people should have the right to keep their leader. It was a "don't change horses in the middle of a stream" argument, and honestly, it’s hard to argue with the results if you were a citizen back then.
Why Four Terms Led to the 22nd Amendment
Roosevelt died in April 1945, just months into his fourth term. He looked exhausted. If you look at photos of him from the Yalta Conference compared to his first inauguration, it’s haunting. The man was physically spent.
Once he was gone and the war ended, the political pendulum swung back hard. Republicans, who had been out of power for over a decade, were desperate to make sure another "President for Life" scenario never happened again. But it wasn't just a partisan thing. A lot of Democrats realized that having one person in power for 12 or 16 years concentrated way too much influence in one office.
✨ Don't miss: When is the Next Hurricane Coming 2024: What Most People Get Wrong
This led to the 22nd Amendment.
Ratified in 1951, it officially capped the presidency at two terms. It’s the direct legacy of the fdr number of terms. We went from an unwritten "gentleman's agreement" to a hard, constitutional "get out after eight years."
Some weird nuances about the 22nd Amendment:
- You can actually serve up to 10 years if you take over as VP mid-term.
- It specifically excluded Harry Truman (the sitting president at the time), but he decided not to run again anyway after a disastrous showing in the New Hampshire primary.
- It changed the way every president since has approached their "Lame Duck" period.
The Long-Term Impact on American Power
Was it a mistake to limit terms? Some historians, like Doris Kearns Goodwin, have touched on how Roosevelt’s long tenure allowed for a level of institutional knowledge that’s impossible today. He knew the world leaders personally. He knew every lever of the federal bureaucracy because he built half of it.
On the flip side, look at the health of the executive branch in 1944. Roosevelt was desperately ill. Because there was no term limit, he felt obligated to keep going, and his inner circle kept his declining health a secret from the public. If he had been forced to step down after two terms, the transition to a successor would have happened in 1941, likely under much more transparent circumstances.
🔗 Read more: What Really Happened With Trump Revoking Mayorkas Secret Service Protection
The fdr number of terms debate is really a debate about stability versus fresh blood. Do you want a seasoned captain who knows the ship, or do you want to ensure no one person becomes the ship? The 22nd Amendment decided we’d rather take our chances with fresh blood every eight years.
How FDR’s Terms Compare to Others
Before Roosevelt, only a few people even tried for a third. Ulysses S. Grant wanted one but his party said no. Teddy Roosevelt tried for a "third" (really a second full term after taking over for McKinley) under the Bull Moose ticket but lost.
FDR remains the only person to ever cross that line successfully. He served 12 years and 42 days. For comparison, the average modern president gets about 2,900 days. Roosevelt got over 4,400. That’s a massive gap in influence, judicial appointments, and cultural impact. He appointed eight Supreme Court justices. That’s almost an entire bench.
Actionable Insights for History Buffs and Students
If you're looking into this for a project or just to win a bar bet, keep these things in mind:
- Check the electoral maps: Roosevelt didn't just win; he dominated. The 1936 map is almost entirely blue. Understanding his term count requires looking at the sheer popularity he held.
- Read the 22nd Amendment text: It's surprisingly short. It doesn't mention "FDR" by name, but every word of it is written in response to his 1940 and 1944 campaigns.
- Visit the FDR Library online: They have the specific memos where his advisors debated whether he should run for the third term. It wasn't a foregone conclusion; he was actually quite hesitant at first.
- Compare the "Lame Duck" status: Note how modern presidents lose power in their 7th year. FDR never had that problem because everyone assumed he might just run again.
The era of the multi-term president is dead and gone, but the shadow of Roosevelt's twelve-year reign still defines how we view the limits of executive power today. It’s the reason why, no matter how popular a president is today, the clock is always ticking toward that final January 20th.