You’ve heard the noise. Everyone says the 2025 class is "weak" because it doesn’t have a Caleb Williams or a Marvin Harrison Jr. sitting at the top. Honestly? That's lazy analysis.
If you’re heading into a fantasy football rookie draft 2025, you need to stop looking for the "generational" savior and start looking at the depth of the running back room. It’s huge. This year is basically the inverse of 2024. Last year was all about the "Big Three" wide receivers and a historic quarterback class. This year is about the grinders. It’s about the guys who are going to see 15 carries a game and catch four passes out of the backfield.
The value is weirdly lopsided.
The Running Back Renaissance in the Fantasy Football Rookie Draft 2025
Let's talk about Ashton Jeanty. If you haven't watched Boise State tape, do it now. The guy is a video game character. He’s not just fast; he has this contact balance that makes pro scouts drool. In most fantasy football rookie draft 2025 scenarios, he’s the 1.01. Period. It doesn't matter if it's Superflex or 1QB.
Why? Because the bell-cow back is a dying breed in the NFL, but 2025 is bringing them back.
Then you have Quinshon Judkins and TreVeyon Henderson. It’s rare to see a single college backfield at Ohio State produce two legitimate first-round fantasy assets, but here we are. Judkins has that heavy-duty frame that screams "goal-line touches." Henderson is the lightning.
✨ Don't miss: Simona Halep and the Reality of Tennis Player Breast Reduction
You’ve also got Omarion Hampton from UNC. He’s a bowling ball. He finishes runs with a violence we haven't seen in a couple of years. If you are sitting at the 1.05 and any of these guys are there, you’re laughing. You're basically getting a starter for the next five years.
Compare that to the wideouts. Luther Burden III and Tetairoa McMillan are the headliners. Burden is built like Deebo Samuel—stocky, explosive, a nightmare after the catch. McMillan is a literal skyscraper. He’s 6'5" and moves like he’s 5'11". But after those two? The cliff is real. There is a massive drop-off in "sure-fire" talent compared to the 2024 class where you could find starters in the second round.
What Most People Get Wrong About the 2025 Quarterbacks
People are panicking about the QBs. "There’s no Jayden Daniels," they cry. "The talent is mid!"
Well, yeah, maybe.
But Shedeur Sanders is going to be a fascinating case study in fantasy value versus real-world NFL value. He’s accurate. He’s poised. He’s also going to have a massive spotlight on him which usually inflates ADPs. In your fantasy football rookie draft 2025, someone in your league is going to reach for him in the top three. Let them.
🔗 Read more: NFL Pick 'em Predictions: Why You're Probably Overthinking the Divisional Round
Unless you are desperate for a signal-caller in a Superflex league, this isn't the year to burn high capital on the position. Cam Ward has some incredible "wow" plays, but the turnover concerns are real. Jalen Milroe has the rushing floor that fantasy managers love—think Anthony Richardson lite—but the passing consistency remains the giant question mark.
If you're picking at the end of the first round, you're better off taking the RB4 or RB5 than the QB1 of this class.
The Tight End Sleeper You Can't Ignore
Colston Loveland. Write the name down.
Tight end is usually a wasteland in rookie drafts unless there’s a Brock Bowers involved. Loveland isn't Bowers, but he’s the closest thing we’ve got. He’s a focal point of the Michigan offense. In a year where the WR depth feels a bit "meh," Loveland offers a positional advantage that could be huge in TE-premium formats.
Most of your league-mates will be chasing some random WR from a big-name school. Don't be that guy. Take the elite tight end prospect who can actually run routes.
💡 You might also like: Why the Marlins Won World Series Titles Twice and Then Disappeared
Navigating the Second Round Slump
The second round of a fantasy football rookie draft 2025 is where things get ugly. Or beautiful, if you like gambling.
Usually, the second round is for "safe" floor players. Not this year. The 2025 class is top-heavy at RB and thin everywhere else. This means the 2.04 pick is going to feel a lot riskier than it did last year. You're looking at guys like Elic Ayomanor or Nicholas Singleton. High ceilings? Sure. Basement-level floors? Absolutely.
I’ve seen some analysts suggest trading 2025 seconds for 2026 picks already. That feels a bit extreme, but I get the logic. If you aren't in love with the players available at the turn, move the pick. Get a veteran who can help you win now.
Actionable Next Steps for Your Draft
- Prioritize RBs Early: This is the year to fix your backfield. If you have the 1.01 through 1.04, you should likely be looking at Jeanty, Judkins, or Henderson.
- Tier Your Wide Receivers: Don't get caught in a run. Once Burden and McMillan are gone, there is a significant tier break. If you miss them, pivot to the running backs.
- Fade the QB Hype: In 1QB leagues, don't even think about a quarterback until the third round. In Superflex, only take Sanders or Ward if the value is undeniable.
- Watch the Combine Closely: Because this class lacks "alpha" WR prospects, 40-yard dash times and agility drills will move the needle more than usual. A sub-4.4 speedster could jump from the third round to the late first overnight.
- Assess Your Window: If you are rebuilding, this is a great draft to grab 2-3 running backs and flip them mid-season to contenders when injuries inevitable strike. RBs are the liquid currency of fantasy football.
The 2025 draft isn't "bad." It’s just specialized. Understand that you're drafting for volume and floor at the RB position rather than swinging for the fences on a superstar wideout. Do that, and you'll dominate your league mates who are still trying to find the next Justin Jefferson in a class that doesn't have one.