Honestly, if you walked out of the third Fantastic Beasts movie feeling like someone had literally erased a main character, you aren't alone. It was weird. Porpentina "Tina" Goldstein went from being the emotional and moral anchor of the first two films to basically a framed photo on a desk. People were confused. They were annoyed. But when we look back at the whole messy timeline, Tina’s journey—and her eventual disappearance—is actually one of the most interesting parts of the entire Harry Potter spin-off saga.
She isn't just "the love interest." Not even close. Tina is a disgraced federal agent with a heart that’s way too big for her own career safety.
The Tina Goldstein Nobody Talks About
We first meet her in 1926 New York. She’s stalking Newt Scamander. Most people forget she was actually a high-ranking Auror for MACUSA before she got demoted to a soul-crushing job in the Federal Wand Permit Office. Why? Because she chose empathy over orders. She saw Mary Lou Barebone—a No-Maj—beating a kid named Credence. Tina didn't just file a report. She used magic to stop it.
That’s the core of who she is. She’s a rule-follower who breaks the rules the second they stop making sense.
Why she was the perfect foil for Newt
Newt is all about the creatures; Tina is all about the people. It’s a classic dynamic. He’s looking at a Niffler; she’s looking at the Statute of Secrecy and how many years in prison he’s about to get. But Katherine Waterston played her with this specific kind of "seesawing" energy—one minute she’s incredibly confident, the next she’s totally doubting herself. It made her feel human in a world of CGI monsters.
📖 Related: Gwendoline Butler Dead in a Row: Why This 1957 Mystery Still Packs a Punch
Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them: Tina Goldstein and the MACUSA Drama
The first movie really centers on her trying to get her job back. She brings Newt in because she thinks it’ll prove her worth. It backfires. Spectacularly. They end up in an execution chamber. If you remember that scene, it’s one of the darkest in the franchise. Tina’s memories—mostly of her and her sister Queenie—are being used to lure her into a literal death pool.
- Birth Date: August 19, 1901
- School: Ilvermorny (Thunderbird House)
- Wand: Simple, plain-Jane wood (Waterston’s choice to reflect Tina’s lack of vanity)
- Skill Level: High. She held her own against Grindelwald (while he was disguised as Graves).
By the end of the first film, she’s reinstated. She’s an Auror again. But the victory is hollow because she couldn't save Credence from the "death" everyone thought he suffered.
The Paris Incident and the "Engagement" Mess
In The Crimes of Grindelwald, things get messy. Tina goes rogue in Paris to find Credence because she still feels responsible for him. Then there’s that whole "Newt is engaged to Leta Lestrange" misunderstanding. It was a bit of a soap opera plot, honestly. But it showed how much she cared. She wasn't just chasing a criminal; she was chasing a boy she wanted to save and a man she was starting to love.
Then came the fire at Père Lachaise. Tina, alongside Newt and his brother Theseus, had to hold back Grindelwald's blue flames. That was the moment she transitioned from a local cop to a global soldier in the Wizarding War.
👉 See also: Why ASAP Rocky F kin Problems Still Runs the Club Over a Decade Later
The Mystery: Where Was Tina in "Secrets of Dumbledore"?
This is the big one. Why was Tina Goldstein barely in the third movie?
The official in-universe explanation is that she was promoted to Head of the American Auror Office. Apparently, she was "too busy" to help Dumbledore stop a magical election rig. It felt like a weak excuse.
Behind the scenes, the rumors were flying. Some thought it was because Katherine Waterston spoke out against J.K. Rowling’s social views. Others said it was just a scheduling conflict. Whatever the reason, her absence left a massive hole. We didn't get to see her reaction to Queenie joining Grindelwald. We didn't see the romance with Newt progress. We just got a 30-second cameo at a wedding at the very end.
What the future holds (according to canon)
Even though the movies seem to be on indefinite hiatus, we know how Tina’s story ends because of the original Fantastic Beasts textbook.
✨ Don't miss: Ashley My 600 Pound Life Now: What Really Happened to the Show’s Most Memorable Ashleys
- She marries Newt Scamander.
- They move to Dorset, England.
- They have at least one son.
- They have three pet Kneazles: Hoppy, Milly, and Mauler.
- Her grandson, Rolf Scamander, eventually marries Luna Lovegood.
Actionable Insights for Fans
If you're looking to dive deeper into Tina's lore, don't just stick to the movies.
- Read the Screenplays: J.K. Rowling included stage directions that explain Tina’s internal thoughts which didn't always make it to the screen.
- Check the "Wand Permit" Props: Real-world exhibitions of the movie props show Tina’s actual MACUSA ID and permit files, giving more detail on her early career.
- Revisit the First Movie: Pay attention to her apartment. The way she and Queenie live says more about their bond as orphans than any dialogue ever could.
Tina Goldstein is the heart of this series. She’s the one who reminds us that even in a world of magic, the most important thing you can be is kind. Even if it costs you your job. Even if it gets you thrown into a death pool. She’s a Thunderbird through and through—bold, brave, and a little bit stubborn.
If you want to understand the character better, look for the deleted scenes from the first film. They show a much more vulnerable side of her relationship with Queenie that makes her later "Head Auror" status feel even more earned.
All we can hope for is that if the franchise ever returns, we get to see Tina Goldstein back where she belongs: right next to Newt, helping him save the world one beast at a time.