Michael Rubin doesn't really do things halfway. If you’ve followed the trajectory of Fanatics over the last decade, you know the vibe: aggressive expansion, a near-monopoly on sports merchandise, and a database of sports fans that would make any marketing executive drool. But the pivot into Fanatics Betting and Gaming wasn't just a side quest. It was a calculated, multi-billion dollar bet that they could turn jersey buyers into parlay bettors.
Honestly, the industry was skeptical at first. People thought they were late. FanDuel and DraftKings had already sucked all the oxygen out of the room, right? Not exactly.
The strategy here is basically a giant ecosystem play. Most betting apps have to spend hundreds of dollars in "Customer Acquisition Cost" (CAC) just to get one person to download an app and lose twenty bucks on a Sunday. Fanatics? They already have your email. They know you bought a Jalen Hurts jersey three months ago. They have your credit card on file. That kind of leverage is terrifying for the incumbents.
The PointsBet Acquisition and the Tech Backbone
Building a sportsbook from scratch is a nightmare. It’s a glitchy, regulatory-heavy mess that eats capital for breakfast. Fanatics knew this, which is why they didn't just try to code their way out of the problem. They went shopping.
The $225 million acquisition of PointsBet’s US operations was the "all-in" moment. This wasn't just about getting more users; it was about the tech stack. PointsBet had a proprietary "Banach" engine that allowed for sophisticated in-play betting and cash-out features. By swallowing that infrastructure, Fanatics Betting and Gaming skipped about three years of developmental headaches.
It wasn't a smooth ride, though. Integrating a massive existing user base across multiple states—each with their own weird gaming commissions—is like trying to change the tires on a car while it's going eighty on the interstate. There were hurdles. Migration issues happened. But by mid-2024, the "Fanatics Sportsbook" was live in nearly every major legal market, including heavy hitters like New York, Pennsylvania, and Illinois.
💡 You might also like: Current Score of the Steelers Game: Why the 30-6 Texans Blowout Changed Everything
FanCash: The Secret Sauce Nobody Else Has
Let’s talk about why people actually use this thing instead of just sticking with the app they’ve used for three years. It’s the FanCash.
Basically, every time you place a bet, you earn a percentage back in FanCash. You can use that to buy a hat. Or a shirt. Or a signed helmet. It sounds simple, but it’s a psychological masterstroke. No other sportsbook can offer you a physical product as a reward for a losing streak.
If you bet $50 on a game and lose, you still see that $2.50 in FanCash sitting there. It keeps you in the "Fanatics" world. It blurs the line between being a consumer and being a gambler. Some critics argue this is a bit too "sticky," especially for younger fans, but from a business perspective, it's brilliant. It creates a closed-loop economy where the money never really leaves the Michael Rubin empire.
The Reality of Market Share in 2026
Look, we have to be real: DraftKings and FanDuel are still the kings. They own roughly 70% to 80% of the US market share depending on the month. Fanatics Betting and Gaming isn't trying to kill them overnight. They are playing for third place right now, battling it out with BetMGM and Caesars.
Why does third place matter? Because the market is still maturing.
📖 Related: Last Match Man City: Why Newcastle Couldn't Stop the Semenyo Surge
We are seeing a shift away from "burn money to get users" toward "how do we actually make a profit?" Since Fanatics doesn't have to spend as much on TV commercials (because they own the merch data), their path to profitability is actually shorter than many of their rivals. They aren't buying billboards in Times Square as much because they're sending you a push notification when your favorite player gets traded.
The Retail Experience and Casino Integration
It’s not just an app. They’ve been opening retail sportsbooks in places like FedExField and Ocean Casino Resort. It’s sort of a branding exercise. They want you to see the logo everywhere.
And then there's the "Gaming" part of the name. Online Casino (iGaming) is actually where the real money is made. Sports betting has thin margins—one bad weekend for the house can wipe out a month of profit. But Blackjack? Slots? The house always wins there, and the margins are massive. The Fanatics Casino is being rolled into the same app, creating a "one-stop shop" for digital entertainment.
What People Get Wrong About the Fanatics Strategy
Most analysts focus on the "handle" (the total amount of money wagered). But handle is a vanity metric. If I give you a $1,000 free bet and you wager it, the handle looks great, but I've made zero dollars.
Fanatics is focused on "Hold" and "LTV" (Life Time Value). They want the guy who bets $10 a week for twenty years and buys three jerseys a season. They aren't chasing the high-rollers who shop for the best lines and leave the second a promotion ends. They want the "casual" fan. The guy who just wants to have a little skin in the game while wearing his team's colors.
👉 See also: Cowboys Score: Why Dallas Just Can't Finish the Job When it Matters
There is a legitimate concern about the "merch-to-gambling" pipeline. Responsible gaming advocates have pointed out that using jersey sales data to target potential bettors is a grey area. Fanatics has responded by beefing up their "Responsible Gaming" tools, but the tension remains. It’s a powerful tool, and with great power comes a whole lot of regulatory scrutiny.
The Tech Stack vs. The Competition
- Proprietary Odds: Unlike some smaller books that "white label" their odds from companies like Kambi, Fanatics is moving toward in-house pricing. This allows them to offer unique markets.
- Search Integration: They are making it incredibly easy to find bets. The UI (User Interface) is cleaner than the cluttered mess you see on some older apps.
- The "Discover" Feed: They have a social-media style feed that shows you what’s trending, which is very much aimed at the Gen Z and Millennial demographic.
Where Does This Go From Here?
The next phase is likely deeper integration with live sports streaming. Imagine watching a game on a Fanatics-owned or partnered platform and having your bet slip right there on the side of the screen, pre-populated based on the jersey you bought last week.
It sounds like sci-fi, but it’s the logical conclusion of the "Super App" model.
The gambling industry is currently in a "consolidation phase." Small players are dying out. The big players are getting bigger. Fanatics Betting and Gaming has survived the initial "gold rush" and has emerged as a legitimate powerhouse. They have the cash, the data, and the hardware (the merch) to stay relevant for a very long time.
Actionable Insights for the Savvy User
If you’re looking to get the most out of the Fanatics ecosystem, you have to play the game smarter than the average fan.
- Bank the FanCash: Don't just let it sit there. Use it during the big sales (Black Friday or end-of-season clearances) to maximize the value of your betting rewards. You can essentially get your sports wardrobe for "free" if you’re a disciplined bettor.
- Watch the Lines: Because Fanatics uses their own tech now, their lines often deviate from the "market" (FanDuel/DraftKings). If you see a spread that looks off, it’s often because their internal model is seeing the game differently. Use that to your advantage.
- Check the Promos: They are still in "growth mode," which means they offer aggressive "odds boosts" on parlays. These are often +EV (Expected Value) bets designed to keep you engaged.
- Security First: Always use Two-Factor Authentication (2FA). Since your betting account is linked to your merch account—and likely your credit card—it’s a high-value target for hackers.
The landscape of sports in America has changed forever. It's no longer just about the score; it's about the "action." Fanatics didn't just join the party; they're trying to own the house where the party is happening. Whether you like the "gamblification" of sports or not, the Fanatics model is the blueprint for the future. Over the next few years, expect to see even more blurring of the lines between buying a ticket, buying a shirt, and placing a bet. It's all just one big "fan experience" now.