You've seen the clip. It was Sunday Night Football, October 2025. The Buffalo Bills were grinding against the New England Patriots. Josh Allen, a man whose arm is basically a pressurized air cannon, gets flushed out of the pocket. He rolls right, sees nothing but blue jerseys and grass, and absolute lasers a throwaway into the stands.
Then it happens.
A guy in a Matt Milano jersey—later identified as Brian Kemp—snags the ball. He doesn't cheer. He doesn't high-five his neighbor. He doesn't even look back. He just puts his head down and sprints up the concrete stairs like he just robbed a bank. Mike Tirico’s play-by-play was legendary: "He’s in row 15! He might get a beer! Milano, row 40... he’s going to take it the distance!"
Everyone watching thought they just saw a man pull off the heist of the century. But honestly? The story of the fan catches Josh Allen ball saga is way more complicated than a simple "grab and run."
The Physics of the Catch
Catching a ball from Josh Allen isn't like catching a pop fly at a baseball game. It's more like trying to catch a brick falling from a third-story window. Allen is known for having the "biggest gun in the league." Brian Kemp himself described it to WIVB-TV as a "bullet" with serious heat on it.
Most people don't realize that NFL game balls are surprisingly heavy and hard. When you add the velocity Allen puts on a throwaway to avoid a sack, you aren't just catching a souvenir. You’re absorbing a physical impact. Kemp was lucky he didn't break a finger. He managed to pull it in with a couple of cowbells in his hand, which is its own kind of athletic feat.
✨ Don't miss: What Place Is The Phillies In: The Real Story Behind the NL East Standings
Why He Actually Ran (It Wasn't What You Think)
The internet immediately assumed Kemp was running to avoid security. Or maybe he wasn't supposed to be in those seats. Mike Tirico speculated he was just trying to get to the concourse before someone took it back.
The truth? He wanted to give it to his friend Tim.
Kemp and his wife, Tara Halliwell-Kemp, had been buying tickets from Tim, a lifelong Bills superfan. Kemp’s first instinct when he felt that leather hit his palms was: I need to get this to the car so I can give it to Tim. It was a spur-of-the-moment decision fueled by pure adrenaline and "Bills Mafia" loyalty.
He literally told his wife, "I'll meet you at the car," and vanished.
The "Return the Ball" Policy
Here is the part that kills the magic for a lot of people. The NFL has a very strict policy regarding game balls. Unlike Major League Baseball, where a foul ball is yours to keep, the NFL wants their footballs back.
🔗 Read more: Huskers vs Michigan State: What Most People Get Wrong About This Big Ten Rivalry
- Proprietary Tech: Modern NFL balls contain K-balls technology and RFID chips. These chips track player speed, ball rotation, and location data.
- Inventory: Teams only have a limited number of "K-balls" (kicking balls) and game balls prepped for a specific matchup.
- Liability: The league generally discourages fans from fighting over balls in the stands to prevent injuries.
Security eventually approached Tara while Brian was MIA. They made a deal: bring the Josh Allen ball back, and we’ll give you a different, non-game-used ball in exchange.
The Disappearing Souvenir
Kemp did eventually return to his seat. He didn't actually make it to the parking lot before the realization set in that he couldn't just walk out with a piece of league property. He handed over the "bullet" Allen had thrown and received a standard team ball in return.
He told reporters later, "This ball unfortunately is not the actual ball that Allen threw... however, all is right with the world."
Some fans were annoyed by this. They felt a $6 billion organization like the Bills should have let a guy keep a $100 football. But the "fan catches Josh Allen ball" moment wasn't just about the physical object. It was about the 30 seconds of pure, unadulterated chaos that Mike Tirico turned into a national highlight.
Josh Allen's History of Giving
While that specific throwaway was a "forced" interaction, Josh Allen is actually one of the most prolific ball-givers in the NFL. Just a month or so after the Kemp incident, Allen was seen after a win over the Bengals specifically hunting for a kid in the front row to hand over a game ball.
💡 You might also like: NFL Fantasy Pick Em: Why Most Fans Lose Money and How to Actually Win
He has a history with the "Crucial Catch" campaign too. There’s a well-documented bond between Allen and young fans like Zack, a patient at Oishei Children’s Hospital. For Allen, a ball is a tool of the trade, but for the fans, it's a "hero" moment.
Realities of Snagging an Allen Pass
If you’re heading to Highmark Stadium with the hopes of being the next viral sensation, keep these things in mind:
- Don't run: It makes you look guilty and guarantees security will find you.
- Bring a glove? Maybe. But seriously, watch your face. An errant Josh Allen pass has been clocked at speeds that can cause real damage.
- The Swap is Standard: If you catch a ball, expect a "tapped shoulder." Be ready to trade the game ball for a gift-shop version and maybe some signed swag if you're lucky.
The Kemp story ended with no theft, no arrests, and a lot of laughs. It stands as a reminder that the NFL is a business, but the fans—especially the ones willing to sprint up 40 rows of stairs—are what make the game weird and great.
Actionable Steps for Fans
If you ever find yourself in the path of a Josh Allen throwaway, here is how to handle it like a pro. First, prioritize your safety; that ball is coming in fast. Second, if you do make the catch, stay in your seat. Running only draws the kind of attention that leads to a much faster visit from stadium staff. Lastly, be prepared to negotiate. If security asks for the ball back, ask for an autographed replacement or a field pass. Most teams are willing to make a fair trade to get their chipped equipment back without a PR nightmare.