Long Island is basically a giant celebrity factory. Honestly, if you grew up here, you probably have a "my cousin went to high school with..." story involving someone who now has an Oscar or a Grammy. It’s not just the Hamptons glitz either. We’re talking about real, gritty suburban roots that shaped some of the biggest names in history.
From the quiet streets of Massapequa to the shores of Huntington, the 118-mile stretch of land produces a very specific kind of person. They’re usually blunt, probably obsessed with a good bagel, and fiercely protective of their hometown.
Famous People From Long Island: The Legends You Definitely Know
You can’t talk about the island without mentioning Billy Joel. He’s the unofficial king. Born in the Bronx but raised in Hicksville, his music is basically a roadmap of Nassau County. Whether he’s singing about the "Italian Restaurant" (inspired by a spot in Syosset) or "The Downeaster Alexa," Joel's identity is fused with the local landscape. Even now, in 2026, he remains a permanent fixture in the local consciousness.
Then there’s Jerry Seinfeld. He grew up in Massapequa, a town that seems to churn out entertainers like a conveyor belt. Jerry often talks about his childhood spent biking around the Tackapausha Preserve. It’s that mundane, suburban observational humor that made Seinfeld a global phenomenon, and you can trace it all back to a kid sitting on a curb in Nassau.
Massapequa didn't stop with Jerry. It also gave us the Baldwin brothers. Alec, Daniel, Billy, and Stephen all hail from the area. Alec, the eldest, was actually born in Amityville before the family moved over. They’re the quintessential Long Island family—loud, talented, and everywhere.
The Voices That Changed Radio and Pop
- Howard Stern: Before he was the King of All Media, he was just a kid in Roosevelt and later Rockville Centre. He’s famously candid about his "introverted" years at South Side High School.
- Mariah Carey: The vocal powerhouse grew up in Huntington. She’s mentioned in interviews how her early years on the island weren't always easy, but they definitely built that legendary drive.
- Eddie Murphy: Another Roosevelt alum. It’s wild to think that Murphy and Stern both walked those same streets around the same time. Long Island was clearly doing something right in the water back then.
The "I Didn't Know They Were From There" List
Sometimes people get shocked when they find out where certain stars started. Natalie Portman? She’s a Syosset girl. Well, technically she went to Syosset High School and lived in Jericho. She was already filming Léon: The Professional while trying to navigate the halls of a Long Island public school.
📖 Related: Kendra Wilkinson Photos: Why Her Latest Career Pivot Changes Everything
Idina Menzel, the voice behind Frozen, grew up in Syosset too. Imagine being a drama teacher at that school and realizing you have a future Academy Award winner and a Broadway legend in the same decade.
Kevin James is another one. He’s a Stony Brook native and went to Ward Melville High School. Fun fact: he was actually on the wrestling team with Mick Foley, the WWE Hall of Famer. You can’t make this stuff up. Two of the most famous guys in their respective industries were literally grappling each other in a high school gym in Setauket.
The Literary and Historic Heavyweights
It's not just actors and singers. Long Island has a weirdly deep intellectual history.
- F. Scott Fitzgerald: He lived in Great Neck (the inspiration for "West Egg") while writing The Great Gatsby. If you drive through those North Shore neighborhoods today, you can still feel that old "Gold Coast" opulence that he skewered so well.
- Walt Whitman: Born in Huntington. You can still visit his birthplace today. It’s a tiny little farmhouse that stands in stark contrast to the Huntington Station shopping centers surrounding it.
- Theodore Roosevelt: The 26th President lived at Sagamore Hill in Oyster Bay. It was his "Summer White House." He loved the island’s rugged coastline, and honestly, who can blame him?
Why Do So Many Stars Stay?
There is a huge difference between being from Long Island and choosing to live there once you’re rich. But a lot of famous people do both. Billy Joel still has his place in Centre Island. Jennifer Lopez and Alex Rodriguez (before the split) were frequently spotted in the Hamptons, but J.Lo has deep NY roots that keep her tied to the area.
Then you have the Hamptons crowd. Steven Spielberg, Ina Garten, and Jerry Seinfeld (again) all have massive estates out east. It’s the ultimate escape from the city, but it’s more than that. There’s a level of privacy you get in a place like Amagansett or Montauk that you just can't find in Malibu.
👉 See also: What Really Happened With the Brittany Snow Divorce
Eli Manning bought a place in Westhampton Beach a few years back for over $8 million. Even Billy Porter recently had a spot in Bellport. The draw is simple: you get the beach, the privacy, and you’re still close enough to Manhattan to get to a meeting in ninety minutes (if the Long Island Expressway is behaving, which it never is).
The Sports Connection
We can't ignore the athletes. Jim Brown, arguably the greatest football player ever, grew up in Manhasset. He was a multi-sport star there, dominating in lacrosse just as much as football.
Craig Biggio, the MLB legend, is a Kings Park native. If you go to Kings Park today, people still talk about him like he’s a local deity. And let’s not forget Boomer Esiason, the pride of East Islip. Long Island athletes have this specific reputation for being "blue-collar," no matter how much money they eventually make.
What Most People Get Wrong About Long Island "Fame"
People think Long Island is just a suburb of NYC, like it’s just a place people sleep. But the culture here is distinct. When you look at famous people from Long Island, there’s a common thread of being "self-made."
Whether it’s LL Cool J (from Bay Shore) or Pat Benatar (from Lindenhurst), these are people who didn't necessarily have a silver spoon. They had to fight for attention in the shadow of the biggest city in the world. That produces a certain kind of edge. It’s why Howard Stern is so aggressive and why Alec Baldwin is so... well, Alec Baldwin.
✨ Don't miss: Danny DeVito Wife Height: What Most People Get Wrong
Where to Spot Them Today
If you’re looking to "celebrity hunt," don't go to the malls. You’ll have better luck at a random diner in the Hamptons or a high-end restaurant in Garden City.
- The American Hotel (Sag Harbor): A huge spot for writers and actors.
- The Golden Pear: You’ll likely see someone famous grabbing a coffee here in the summer.
- The Paramount (Huntington): Many local legends come back here to perform small shows.
Honestly, the best way to experience the "famous" side of the island is to visit the historic spots. Go to Sagamore Hill. Walk through the Walt Whitman Birthplace. See the Gold Coast mansions like Oheka Castle (where Taylor Swift filmed a music video).
Long Island isn't just a place where people are from; it’s a place that stays in their blood. That’s why Billy Joel keeps coming back to the Garden, and why Seinfeld still talks about those bike rides in Massapequa. It’s home.
To truly understand the impact of the island, start by visiting the Long Island Music and Entertainment Hall of Fame in Stony Brook. It’s a great way to see the sheer volume of talent the island has produced in one place. After that, take a drive down Route 25A—you'll pass through the hometowns of at least a dozen people who have changed the world.