Let’s be real: trying to summarize the chaos of the 21st century in a four-minute pop-punk song is a suicide mission. Billy Joel’s 1989 original was already a miracle of packing. It moved from Harry Truman to Coca-Cola with a rhythmic precision that felt like a history teacher having a very rhythmic breakdown. So when the We Didn't Start the Fire remake by Fall Out Boy dropped in 2023, the internet basically imploded. Some people loved the nostalgia trip. Others were genuinely offended that Pete Wentz didn’t keep the events in chronological order.
History is messy.
The remake covers 1989 to 2023. Think about that timeframe for a second. We went from the fall of the Berlin Wall to TikTok and global pandemics. It’s a lot to process. Fall Out Boy took a massive gamble here because the original isn't just a song; it's a cultural artifact that Gen X and Millennials have memorized like a second language. If you mess with the "Fire," you're gonna get burned. Honestly, though? The band knew that. They weren't trying to outdo Billy Joel. They were trying to update the diary.
What Actually Made the Cut (and What Didn't)
The lyrics are a fever dream of modern trauma and pop culture. You’ve got "Amazon Echo," "Deepfakes," "Elon Musk," and "Pokemon Go" all fighting for space. It’s weird hearing Patrick Stump belt out "George Floyd" in the same breath as "Stranger Things," but that is exactly how the 2020s felt. Relentless. Confusing. A bit too much all at once.
One of the biggest criticisms of the We Didn't Start the Fire remake was the lack of a timeline. Billy Joel’s version was a strict march through the years. Fall Out Boy? They went for vibes. They jumped from the 90s to the 2010s and back again. Pete Wentz defended this by saying they wanted the rhyme scheme to feel right, even if it meant sacrificing the "History 101" flow. It makes the song feel more like a chaotic news feed than a textbook.
- The Big Names: Jeff Bezos, Kim Jong-un, Trump’s impeachment, and LeBron James.
- The Tragedies: Sandy Hook, Fukushima, and the Great Recession.
- The Culture: MySpace, Harry Potter, Twilight, and SpongeBob.
It’s an odd list. No mention of the COVID-19 pandemic, which felt like a massive oversight to a lot of listeners. How do you summarize the last 30 years and leave out the one thing that stopped the entire world for two years? Some fans think it was because "pandemic" is a clunky word to rhyme. Others think we were all just too tired of hearing about it. Either way, its absence is the "elephant in the room" of this cover.
The Chronology Controversy
People on Twitter—well, X now—went feral over the order of events. In the 1989 version, you could practically use the song to study for a mid-term. With the We Didn't Start the Fire remake, you’d fail that test. You have "Iron Man" mentioned before "Kurt Cobain," even though the MCU didn't start until 14 years after Cobain passed.
Is it a dealbreaker? Depends on how much of a purist you are. If you view the song as a "vibe check" of the digital age, the jumbled order actually makes a weird kind of sense. Our brains don't process information chronologically anymore. We see a meme from 2012 right next to a news report from five minutes ago. The song reflects that digital noise. It’s loud, it’s fast, and it doesn't care about your timeline.
Billy Joel himself actually gave it the thumbs up. In an interview with BBC Radio 2, he admitted that even he couldn't keep up with the world anymore. He liked that someone else took the baton. He famously called his own song a "novelty" item, something he wrote by starting with the lyrics first, which is the opposite of his usual process. Fall Out Boy kept that spirit alive, focusing on the "wall of sound" rather than a delicate melody.
🔗 Read more: Why Suck on This by Primus Still Sounds Better Than Most Modern Studio Records
Why We Are Still Obsessed With the "Fire"
We love lists. Humans are obsessed with categorizing our own existence. The We Didn't Start the Fire remake works because it validates our collective stress. It says, "Yeah, a lot of stuff happened, and none of us are okay, but we didn't cause the fundamental chaos of the universe."
There’s a comfort in that.
The production on the Fall Out Boy version is heavy. It’s got that classic mid-2000s guitar crunch that makes you want to wear eyeliner and scream-sing in your car. It’s a specific kind of millennial energy. It bridges the gap between the boomers who grew up with Billy and the Gen Z kids who only know "Sugar, We're Goin Down."
- The Nostalgia Factor: Seeing names like "Tom DeLonge" and "MySpace" triggers an immediate dopamine hit for anyone who owned a Razr phone.
- The Information Overload: It captures the "doomscrolling" era perfectly.
- The Debate: Every time someone asks "Why did they include X but not Y?" the song gets more streams. It’s built for engagement.
The Technical Side of the Remake
Let's talk about the sound. Patrick Stump’s vocal range is objectively insane. He handles the rapid-fire delivery better than almost anyone else could. While Billy Joel’s version was more of a rhythmic chant, Stump actually sings these headlines. The key change at the end is a classic Fall Out Boy move—it ramps up the anxiety of the song until it just... stops.
They also had to navigate a much more polarized political world. Billy Joel talked about "Red China" and "JFK," which were massive events but had a different kind of cultural weight back then. Today, mentioning "Blue State, Red State" or "Fox News" (which they didn't, but you get the point) is a minefield. The We Didn't Start the Fire remake stayed relatively centrist, focusing more on the "events" than the "opinions," though some would argue that what you choose to include is an opinion in itself.
How to Digest the Modern History Lesson
If you're trying to make sense of the 118 references packed into these lyrics, don't try to do it in one sitting. It's too much. Instead, look at the clusters. The song spends a lot of time on the transition from analog to digital. It highlights the moment we stopped looking at each other and started looking at screens.
"World Trade Center" and "September 11th" are obviously the anchors of the song's darker side. It’s the pivot point. Everything before that feels like the "end of history" optimism of the 90s (Y2K, Windows 95), and everything after feels like the frantic, hyper-connected reality we live in now.
Actionable Ways to Engage With the Song
- Make your own "Bridge" playlist: Put the 1989 version and the 2023 version back-to-back. It’s a fascinating 75-year summary that takes less than ten minutes to hear.
- Fact-check the lyrics: Use a site like Genius to look up the more obscure references. Do you remember "Enron"? Do you know why "Balloon Boy" was a thing? It’s a great rabbit hole for a rainy afternoon.
- Analyze the omissions: Write down five things that happened between 1989 and 2023 that you think were more important than "Captain Planet." It’s a fun exercise in seeing what your personal history looks like.
- Check the credits: Look into the production. It was produced by the band along with long-time collaborators, which is why it sounds so much like their So Much (For) Stardust era.
The We Didn't Start the Fire remake isn't a replacement for the original. It’s a sequel that nobody asked for but everyone needed to talk about. It’s messy, it’s out of order, and it’s loud—which, honestly, is the most accurate way to describe the last thirty years of human history.
Don't expect it to be a perfect documentary. It's a rock song. It’s meant to be shouted in a stadium or hummed while you're stuck in traffic, thinking about how weird it is that we all lived through the "Murder Hornets" era. We're all just trying to keep the fire from burning us down.
To get the most out of this track, listen to it while looking at a lyric sheet. You'll catch references you missed the first ten times, like "Tiger Woods" or "Brexit." It’s a dense piece of media that rewards repeat listens, even if the lack of a timeline drives your inner history buff crazy.