The Atlanta Falcons have a complicated history with the Big Game. Two trips. Two very different eras. Honestly, when you look back at a Falcons Super Bowl roster, you aren’t just looking at names on a depth chart; you’re looking at two of the most explosive, yet ultimately tragic, teams in NFL history.
One was the 1998 "Dirty Birds" group that danced their way to Miami. The other was the 2016 offensive juggernaut that basically broke the league before breaking the hearts of every fan in Georgia. Both rosters were loaded. Both had MVPs or future Hall of Famers. And both came up just short.
The 2016 Juggernaut: Speed, Power, and Kyle Shanahan
Most people today focus on the "28-3" collapse, but they forget how terrifying that 2016 Falcons Super Bowl roster actually was. It wasn't just Matt Ryan having an MVP season. It was a perfect storm of coaching and talent.
Kyle Shanahan was the architect. He had a coaching staff that looks ridiculous in hindsight. Look at these names: Matt LaFleur was the QBs coach. Mike McDaniel was an offensive assistant. Even Raheem Morris was there. That’s a massive amount of brainpower on one sideline.
The Offense That Couldn't Be Stopped
Matt Ryan was the "Matty Ice" we all remember, throwing for 4,944 yards. He had a 117.1 passer rating that year. Insane. But he had help:
- Julio Jones: A literal alien. He had 1,409 yards in the regular season and then basically ate the Green Bay Packers alive in the NFC Championship.
- Devonta Freeman and Tevin Coleman: The "two-headed monster." Freeman was the shifty, powerful guy; Coleman was the lightning. They combined for nearly 2,500 yards from scrimmage.
- The Offensive Line: This was the secret sauce. Alex Mack, Andy Levitre, Jake Matthews, Chris Chester, and Ryan Schraeder started every single game together that year. Zero injuries to the starting five. That never happens.
A Young, Fast Defense
The defense was built on speed. Dan Quinn wanted "fast and physical." He got it, mostly through the draft. Keanu Neal was a rookie hitting like a truck at safety. Deion Jones was a rookie linebacker who could outrun most wideouts.
Vic Beasley Jr. led the NFL with 15.5 sacks that year. Grady Jarrett, who is still a legend in Atlanta, had three sacks on Tom Brady in the Super Bowl alone. They were flying around. For 45 minutes in Houston, they looked like the best defense in the world. Then, well... you know the rest. The lack of depth eventually showed as they played over 90 snaps in that heat.
🔗 Read more: Lawrence County High School Football: Why Friday Nights in Louisa Still Hit Different
1998: The Original Dirty Birds
If 2016 was about finesse and speed, the 1998 Falcons Super Bowl roster was about grit and Jamal Anderson.
That team went 14-2. They weren't supposed to be there. They had to go into Minnesota and beat a 15-1 Vikings team that was breaking scoring records. Gary Anderson missed a kick, Morten Andersen didn't, and the Falcons were in Super Bowl XXXIII.
Jamal Anderson and the Ground Game
Jamal Anderson was the heartbeat. 410 carries. 1,846 yards. 14 touchdowns. He did the "Dirty Bird" dance after every score, and by December, the whole city was doing it. He was a workhorse in an era of workhorses.
The quarterback was Chris Chandler. He was "fragile" but gritty. He made the Pro Bowl that year, throwing to Terance Mathis and Tony Martin. Both those guys went over 1,000 yards. People forget the '98 Falcons could actually sling it when they wanted to.
The Grits Blitz Mentality
The defense was led by Jessie Tuggle. "The Hammer." He’s the franchise leader in tackles for a reason.
You also had:
💡 You might also like: LA Rams Home Game Schedule: What Most People Get Wrong
- Ray Buchanan: A shutdown corner with a big mouth and the play to back it up.
- Chuck Smith: A nightmare off the edge.
- Eugene Robinson: An All-Pro safety whose Super Bowl story became a cautionary tale after an unfortunate incident the night before the game.
They ran into a buzzsaw named John Elway in his final game. The Broncos were just more experienced. But that 1998 roster remains the most beloved in Falcons history because they brought a swagger to Atlanta that hadn't existed before.
What Most People Get Wrong About These Rosters
There's a myth that these teams were "flukes." They weren't.
The 2016 team had the 7th-highest scoring offense in NFL history at the time. They were averaging 33.8 points per game. You don't fluke your way into that.
The 1998 team had the 4th-best defense in the league and a Hall of Fame kicker in Morten Andersen.
The real tragedy is how quickly these rosters dissolved. After 1998, Jamal Anderson suffered a devastating knee injury, and the team plummeted. After 2016, Kyle Shanahan left for San Francisco, and the offense never regained that historic rhythm under Steve Sarkisian.
Lessons from the Falcons Super Bowl History
Success in the NFL is incredibly fragile.
📖 Related: Kurt Warner Height: What Most People Get Wrong About the QB Legend
If you're looking at these rosters for fantasy insight or just general football knowledge, the takeaway is simple: offensive line continuity and coaching stability matter more than almost anything else.
In 2016, the Falcons had both. When they lost Mack to injury during the Super Bowl (he played on a broken fibula) and Shanahan to the 49ers, the magic evaporated.
If you want to track the current Falcons' trajectory, look at the trenches first. The skill players like Bijan Robinson and Drake London are great, but as the 2016 and 1998 teams showed, a Super Bowl roster is built on the guys who don't get the headlines.
To dig deeper into the current state of the team, compare the 2016 defensive stats against the current defensive EPA (Expected Points Added). It's a sobering look at how hard it is to build a championship-caliber unit.
You should also check out the career arcs of players like Grady Jarrett or Jake Matthews, the few remaining links to that 2016 squad. They provide the veteran leadership that connects the "what ifs" of the past to the hope of the future.