January hits different in college basketball. The gyms are louder, the legs are heavier, and honestly, the "experts" start sweating. Everyone wants to know who is going to be cutting down the nets in Indianapolis come April, but if you're just looking at the AP Top 25, you're basically guessing.
Bracketology right now is a chaotic mess. We’ve got a Michigan team that dominated non-conference play, an Arizona squad that looks nearly invincible, and a Vanderbilt team—yes, the Commodores—sneaking into the top 10 like they belong there. Finding expert march madness picks isn't about picking the team with the most wins; it's about finding the teams that won't crumble when a 12-seed starts raining threes in the second half.
The Michigan Problem and Why the Computers Love Them
Look at the NET rankings. Michigan has been sitting at No. 1 for what feels like forever. Dusty May didn't just rebuild this roster; he engineered a machine. They’ve already blown the doors off Gonzaga and Auburn by 30-plus points.
But then they lost to Wisconsin.
Most people saw that 91-88 score and thought the wheels were falling off. Wrong. The Badgers are a top-40 NET team, and the Big Ten is a literal meat grinder this year. If you're making your expert march madness picks based on a single January loss, you’re missing the forest for the trees. Michigan is still the betting favorite at +390 for a reason. They play the second-toughest schedule in the country, and their offensive efficiency—currently ranked 7th by KenPom—is a nightmare for anyone trying to zone them.
Arizona and the Big 12 Gauntlet
Arizona is currently sitting at No. 1 in the AP Poll, and honestly, it's hard to argue. They started 14-0, and Koa Peat is playing like a man possessed, averaging nearly 15 points a game. Tobe Awaka is a vacuum on the glass.
💡 You might also like: Jake Ehlinger Sign: The Real Story Behind the College GameDay Controversy
The concern? The Big 12 is brutal.
- Iowa State is lurking right behind them with a defense that makes you want to quit basketball.
- BYU has AJ Dybantsa, a freshman who is probably going to be the No. 1 or No. 2 pick in the NBA Draft.
- Houston still has Kelvin Sampson, which means they will out-rebound you and out-work you until you're exhausted.
If Arizona survives the Big 12 and takes the conference title, they are a lock for a 1-seed. But that's a big "if" when you have to play in Ames or Provo on a Tuesday night.
Expert March Madness Picks: The "Buy Low" Teams
While everyone is chasing the Michigan and Arizona hype, there are three teams that the sharps are quietly eyeing. These are the teams that had a rough December but are built for a three-week sprint in March.
1. Duke and the Cooper Flagg Factor
Duke slipped a bit. They lost to Texas Tech and had a "too close for comfort" win against Florida State. But don't be fooled. Jon Scheyer’s squad is currently 4th in the NET for a reason. They just beat a ranked Louisville team by double digits and handled SMU. They have the 5th toughest schedule of the top-10 teams. If they’re healthy, they’re a Final Four threat. Period.
2. Purdue's Consistency
Matt Painter just keeps winning. Braden Smith is a unanimous preseason All-American and he plays like it. Purdue is No. 4 in KenPom and No. 5 in the NET. They don't beat themselves. In a tournament where teams usually lose because of 20 turnovers or missed free throws, Purdue is the safest bet in the field. They might not be "flashy," but they’re effective.
📖 Related: What Really Happened With Nick Chubb: The Injury, The Recovery, and The Houston Twist
3. UConn’s Search for a Three-Peat
Dan Hurley’s Huskies are in a weird spot. The Big East is struggling, which means UConn doesn't get a lot of "quality win" opportunities in January. They’re basically playing high-stakes games where a win doesn't help much, but a loss is devastating. They’ve got Alex Karaban and Solo Ball, plus Georgia transfer Silas Demary Jr. If they can stay mentally sharp through a weak conference schedule, their tournament experience is unmatched.
The Injury Report: What No One Is Talking About
For the first time in 2026, the NCAA is requiring pregame injury reports. This is huge for anyone making expert march madness picks.
Keep an eye on Alabama. T. Bol Bowen and L. Wrightsell are both dealing with undisclosed injuries. The Crimson Tide plays a fast-paced, high-variance style that requires depth. If those guys aren't 100% by March, Bama is a prime candidate for an early exit.
Same goes for Louisville. They’ve got K. Fish out with appendicitis and J. Hart dealing with a foot issue. These small things matter. A foot injury in January becomes a "can't jump" injury in March.
Why Vanderbilt is the Ultimate Wildcard
Nobody had Vanderbilt at 16-0 and in the Top 10. They just toppled Alabama and LSU back-to-back. The computers still aren't entirely sold—they actually dropped in the NET after winning because of how the algorithm weights opponent strength—but they pass the eye test. They’re athletic, they’re disciplined, and they’re playing with a "nobody believes in us" chip on their shoulder.
👉 See also: Men's Sophie Cunningham Jersey: Why This Specific Kit is Selling Out Everywhere
Actionable Insights for Your Bracket
If you want to win your pool or make a smart play, stop looking at the record. Look at the Adjusted Efficiency Margin.
Historically, national champions almost always rank in the top 20 for both offensive and defensive efficiency. Right now, Michigan, Arizona, and Purdue are the only teams that truly fit that "championship profile" consistently.
Next Steps for Your Research:
- Track the "Last Four In": Teams like Indiana, Cal, and Oklahoma State are currently on the bubble. These teams often play their best basketball in February just to get a seat at the table.
- Watch the Big 12 Standings: Whoever comes out of that conference is battle-tested. If Iowa State or BYU jumps Arizona in the standings, their odds will skyrocket.
- Check the Availability Reports: With the new 2026 injury reporting rules, check the status of key bench players 60 minutes before tip-off. Depth wins in the second weekend of the tournament.
March is coming. The data is there. You just have to know where to look.