We tell little white lies all the time. You tell your barista you’re "doing great" when you actually have a pounding headache and three unpaid bills sitting on your kitchen counter. You tell your mother-in-law the casserole was "unique" because saying it tasted like wet cardboard feels a bit too aggressive for a Sunday afternoon.
But there is one place where we don't lie.
It isn't a confessional booth or a therapist's couch. It's that little rectangular box on your screen. When people type into Google, they aren't performing for an audience. They aren't trying to look smart, or woke, or successful. They are just looking for answers to the weird, dark, and sometimes embarrassing thoughts that keep them up at night. This is the core premise of the Everybody Lies book (officially titled Everybody Lies: Big Data, New Data, and What the Internet Can Tell Us About Who We Really Are) by Seth Stephens-Davidowitz.
✨ Don't miss: Why NYC MTA Subway Interior Live Cards are Finally Changing How We Commute
Honestly, the book is a bit of a wake-up call. It suggests that if you want to know what people really think, you should stop listening to what they say and start looking at what they search for.
The Digital Truth Serum
Seth Stephens-Davidowitz was a Harvard-trained economist working at Google when he realized something profound. The data he was seeing didn't match the world he saw on social media or in traditional polling. For years, social scientists relied on surveys. The problem? Humans are terrible at being honest in surveys. We suffer from something called "social desirability bias." Basically, we want to look like good people, so we lie to pollsters. We say we vote more than we do. We say we drink less than we do. We say we’ve read Infinite Jest when we’ve barely made it past the first twenty pages.
The Everybody Lies book argues that Big Data is the new "digital truth serum."
Take the 2016 election, for instance. Traditional polls were scratching their heads, but the search data was screaming. People weren't just searching for political platforms; they were searching for terms that revealed deep-seated racial anxieties and regional frustrations that they would never admit to a stranger on the phone. Data doesn't have a moral compass. It just reflects us.
Why the "Everybody Lies" Book Changed How We See Data
Data used to be boring. It was spreadsheets and census reports. But Seth turned it into a mirror. He looked at things like "digital breadcrumbs."
Did you know that search volume for "migraine" spikes on Monday mornings? Or that people search for "how to get away with murder" way more often than you’d comfortably like to believe (mostly after watching TV shows, thankfully)?
The book isn't just about the dark side, though. It's about the nuance of human behavior. Stephens-Davidowitz highlights that we are often more miserable, more curious, and more "human" than our curated Instagram feeds suggest. He points out that while people post photos of their "perfect" beach vacations, they are simultaneously Googling "how to stop a toddler from screaming" or "why am I so unhappy."
It’s a massive gap.
The Power of the N-Gram and Search Trends
One of the coolest parts of the book—if you're a nerd for linguistics—is how he uses tools like the Google Ngram Viewer. This tool lets you see how often specific words or phrases have appeared in books over centuries. It’s like a fossil record for human thought.
But the real meat is in the search queries.
- Social Reality vs. Search Reality: People claim they are interested in high-brow documentaries, but their search history is a graveyard of celebrity gossip and "is [insert actor] actually tall?"
- Health Anxiety: We are a nation of hypochondriacs. Google knows you think that freckle is a rare tropical disease before your doctor does.
- Implicit Bias: The book dives into uncomfortable territory regarding racism and sexism. It shows that even in areas we think are "progressive," the search data reveals a massive undercurrent of bias that people hide in public.
Stephens-Davidowitz doesn't just throw stats at you. He tells stories. He explains how a single data point—like the frequency of a certain joke being searched—can predict a region’s voting patterns better than a thousand-person phone survey. It’s kinda terrifying. It’s also incredibly useful for businesses and policymakers.
The Small Data vs. Big Data Debate
There’s a lot of talk about "Big Data" these days. Most people think it’s just about selling you shoes after you looked at them once. But the Everybody Lies book suggests it’s more about understanding the "why" behind human nature.
Sometimes, "small data" is just as important. Seth talks about how specific, niche datasets can provide "Aha!" moments. For example, by looking at the career paths of professional athletes, he found that coming from a wealthy, stable background is actually a better predictor of success in the NBA than coming from a "tough" neighborhood, despite the popular media narrative. Why? Because reaching the top requires resources, coaching, and nutrition that money provides.
The data kills the myth.
Is Privacy Dead?
This is the question everyone asks after reading. If Google knows our deepest fears and darkest secrets, are we doomed?
💡 You might also like: Silicon Valley Execs for Short: Why the Tech Elite is Obsessed with Biohacking Stature
Stephens-Davidowitz is surprisingly optimistic, or at least pragmatic. He argues that while the loss of privacy is a concern, the gain in "truth" is invaluable. We can use this data to identify mental health crises before they happen. We can use it to spot economic downturns or disease outbreaks in real-time.
However, there’s a catch.
The data is only as good as the person interpreting it. You can find a correlation between almost anything if you look hard enough. If you look for a reason to be cynical, the Everybody Lies book will give you plenty of ammunition. But if you look for a way to understand the human condition better, it’s a goldmine.
The Methodology of Truth
The book leans heavily on the idea that "the aggregate" is where the truth lives. One person's search for "how to lose 10 pounds in a weekend" is just a person being hopeful. A million people searching for it is a signal about our culture's relationship with body image and instant gratification.
Stephens-Davidowitz uses four "powers" of Big Data to explain why this works:
- Offering New Data: We can see things we couldn't see before.
- Providing Honest Data: People don't lie to the search bar.
- Allowing for "Zooming In": We can look at tiny sub-sections of the population.
- Enabling Causal Testing: We can run experiments to see what actually works.
Actionable Insights from the World of Data
You don't have to be a data scientist to get something out of this. The reality is that we are all living in a world shaped by these invisible algorithms and secret searches.
- Trust behavior over words: This applies to business and personal life. If someone says they value "innovation" but their calendar is filled with "status update" meetings, believe the calendar.
- Look for the "Digital Silence": Sometimes what people aren't searching for is just as telling. If a major news event happens and nobody is Googling it in a certain area, that's a massive demographic signal.
- Question your own filters: We all have them. We all curate. Understanding that everyone else is also curating can actually make you feel a lot less alone. You're not the only one who feels like a mess; you're just the only one who isn't posting about it.
What to Do Next
If you actually want to apply the lessons from the Everybody Lies book, start by being more critical of the "common knowledge" you see on social media. It’s almost always a performance.
- Audit your own "search" vs. "social" persona. Notice the difference between what you post on LinkedIn and what you actually wonder about when you're alone. It’s an eye-opening exercise in self-awareness.
- Use Google Trends. It’s a free tool. If you’re a business owner or a creator, stop guessing what people want. Look at what they are actually typing into that box. It’s the closest thing to a mind-reading device we will ever have.
- Read the source material. Seth Stephens-Davidowitz writes with a lot of humor and a bit of a "rogue" attitude toward traditional academia. It’s a fast read but a dense one in terms of how it changes your perspective on the people walking past you on the street.
The truth is out there. It’s just buried in the billions of keystrokes we make every single day. We are a species of liars, but our data is remarkably honest.