Erik Williams: Why the Meanest Dallas Cowboy Isn't in the Hall of Fame

If you were a defensive end in the early '90s, you didn't just play against the Dallas Cowboys; you survived them. And the guy you feared most wasn't Troy Aikman or Emmitt Smith. It was the man they called "Big E." Erik Williams was the human equivalent of a brick wall covered in barbed wire. He didn't just block people. He dismantled them.

Honestly, the way he played would probably get him arrested in today’s NFL. He was the literal definition of "nasty." We’re talking about a guy who Michael Strahan—one of the toughest dudes to ever put on pads—called the meanest player he ever faced. Strahan once joked that Williams should have been in jail after their games. It wasn’t just football; it was a street fight with a whistle.

The Night Reggie White Met His Match

Before 1992, Reggie White was the undisputed "Minister of Defense." He was untouchable. Then came a Sunday afternoon where a young Erik Williams basically turned White into a spectator. In a 20–10 Cowboys win, Williams held the future Hall of Famer to zero sacks. He didn't just hold him off; he bullied him.

This performance was so dominant that Williams became the first offensive lineman in Cowboys history to win the NFC Offensive Player of the Week award. Think about that for a second. An offensive tackle won an award usually reserved for quarterbacks throwing five touchdowns.

But how did he do it? Well, it wasn't exactly "textbook" technique.

🔗 Read more: Why Funny Fantasy Football Names Actually Win Leagues

• The Thumb: He was notorious for jamming a thumb into a pass rusher's eye through the facemask.
• The Punch: He’d hit guys in the throat to take their wind.
• The Leg Whip: If he got beat, he’d use whatever limb was available to trip you up.

The league eventually had to create the "Erik Williams Rule"—officially known as hands to the face—just to stop him from decapitating defenders.

The Great Wall of Dallas and the 1994 Tragedy

You’ve heard of the Great Wall of Dallas. It was the gold standard for offensive lines. You had Mark Stepnoski, Nate Newton, Mark Tuinei, and Kevin Gogan (and later Larry Allen). But Williams was the anchor at right tackle. He was the tone-setter. Between 1992 and 1994, he was arguably the best tackle in the world.

Then everything changed on October 24, 1994.

Williams was driving his Mercedes-Benz 500SEC when he crashed into a bridge abutment on the North Dallas Tollway. It was a near-fatal wreck. He suffered a shattered right knee, a broken rib, and facial lacerations that required plastic surgery.

💡 You might also like: Heisman Trophy Nominees 2024: The Year the System Almost Broke

He survived, but the "Big E" who could out-muscle any man on earth was gone.

He missed the rest of the '94 season—incidentally the only year in that four-year stretch where the Cowboys didn't win the Super Bowl. When he returned in 1995, he was still good. He made Pro Bowls and helped win Super Bowl XXX. But the elite, "move-the-earth" power was diminished. His knee just wasn't the same.

Why isn't Erik Williams in the Hall of Fame?

This is the big debate in Dallas sports circles. If you look at his peak, Erik Williams was a Hall of Fame player. He was a 3-time First-team All-Pro and a 4-time Pro Bowler. He has three rings.

So what's the hold-up?

📖 Related: When Was the MLS Founded? The Chaotic Truth About American Soccer's Rebirth

1. Longevity of Dominance: Critics argue his "God-tier" peak was too short because of the accident.
2. The "Mean" Factor: Some voters still hold his dirty playing style against him.
3. Off-Field Issues: He had some legal troubles, including a sexual assault accusation in 1995 (he was acquitted) and a later assault charge involving his wife in 2002.

It’s complicated. If you ask any defensive player from that era, they’ll tell you he belongs in Canton. If you ask the stat-heads, they see a career that was cut short just as it was becoming legendary.

What he’s doing now

After a brief, forgettable stint with the Baltimore Ravens in 2001, Williams walked away. He didn't chase the limelight like Michael Irvin or Deion Sanders. He’s stayed relatively low-profile, occasionally coaching or working with his foundation. He was inducted into the Black College Football Hall of Fame in 2020, which was a huge, well-deserved nod to his roots at Central State.

Basically, he’s a reminder of a different era of football. An era where the offensive line was the most feared unit on the field.

How to truly appreciate the Erik Williams legacy:

• Watch the 1992 Cowboys vs. Eagles tape: See how he handled Reggie White in his prime.
• Look for the "Erik Williams Rule": Next time you see a "Hands to the Face" penalty, remember the man who made it necessary.
• Advocate for the Ring of Honor: Jerry Jones has a long list of guys waiting for the Cowboys Ring of Honor, and many fans feel #79 is the biggest omission.

The story of Erik Williams is one of "what if." What if he hadn't crashed that night in 1994? We’d likely be talking about the greatest right tackle to ever play the game. Instead, he remains a terrifying legend of the '90s dynasty—a man who made the "Minister of Defense" look like a rookie.