You’re scrolling through Instagram at 11:30 PM, phone light searing your retinas, when you see it. A former coworker just posted a photo from a white-sand beach in the Maldives. They didn’t even work that hard when you were on the same team. Now they’ve got the promotion, the tan, and the seemingly perfect life, while you’re staring at a pile of laundry and wondering where your career went sideways. A sharp, hot spike of resentment hits your chest. Then comes the guilt. You think, envy am i wrong for feeling this way? Is there something fundamentally broken in my character because I can't just be happy for them?
Honestly? No. You aren't "wrong." You’re human.
We’ve been conditioned to view envy as a "deadly sin," a toxic trait that belongs only to villains in Disney movies. But psychologists and evolutionary biologists see it differently. They see a survival mechanism. Envy is basically a biological GPS. It’s a signal telling you what you value and where you feel you’re falling behind. If you didn’t care about success, travel, or stability, that post wouldn't bother you. The sting is just data. It’s uncomfortable data, sure, but it isn’t a moral failing.
The Science of Social Comparison
Why do we do this to ourselves? Leon Festinger, a renowned social psychologist, introduced Social Comparison Theory back in 1954. He argued that humans have an innate drive to evaluate themselves by looking at others. We don't have an internal "success meter" that works in a vacuum. Instead, we look at the person next to us. If they’re doing better, we feel "downward" pressure. If they’re doing worse, we feel a boost.
It’s wired into our circuitry.
Research published in the journal Science has shown that when we experience envy, the part of our brain responsible for registering physical pain—the anterior cingulate cortex—actually lights up. When you say envy "hurts," you aren't being dramatic. Your brain is literally processing social inferiority as a physical wound. It’s trying to keep you competitive within the "tribe" because, for most of human history, being at the bottom of the social ladder meant you were less likely to survive or find a mate.
Malicious vs. Benign Envy
Not all envy is created equal. Researchers often split the feeling into two distinct camps: benign and malicious.
Benign envy is that "I want what you have" feeling. It’s aspirational. It can actually motivate you to work harder. You see a friend’s fitness transformation and it pushes you to finally join that gym. It’s about leveling yourself up.
Malicious envy is the "I want you to lose what you have" feeling. This is the version that leads to "schadenfreude"—taking joy in someone else’s misfortune. This is where people get stuck. If you’re asking "envy am i wrong," you’re likely worried that you’re drifting into this second category. But even malicious envy is often just a defense mechanism against a bruised ego. It’s easier to hope someone fails than to face the reality that you feel inadequate.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Some Work All Play Podcast is the Only Running Content You Actually Need
Why Social Media Broke Our Brains
Before the internet, you only had to be jealous of the person in the cubicle next to you or your neighbor with the shiny new Cadillac. Now, you’re comparing your "behind-the-scenes" footage with everyone else’s "highlight reel."
You’re competing with the entire world.
Think about the sheer volume of data we consume. You see a billionaire’s jet, a fitness influencer’s abs, and a 22-year-old’s "day in the life" as a CEO all within five minutes. Your brain isn't designed to process that much perceived "failure" at once. It creates a state of perpetual lack.
Dr. Sherry Turkle, a professor at MIT, has written extensively about how digital life changes our self-perception. We start to perform our lives rather than live them. When we see others performing better, we feel like we’re losing a game we didn't even agree to play. This is why the question of envy am i wrong has become so prevalent in the last decade. We are living in an envy-production machine.
Is Envy Ever Actually "Right"?
Sometimes, your envy is actually a very rational response to injustice. Let's get real for a second. If you’ve been working 60-hour weeks and your boss’s nephew gets the promotion because of nepotism, feeling envious isn't a character flaw. It’s a recognition of unfairness.
In these cases, envy is a moral compass.
It tells you that the system you’re in is skewed. It’s not about you being a "hater"; it’s about you recognizing that your effort isn't being matched by the reward. If you suppress that feeling because you think you’re being "wrong," you might stay in a toxic environment far longer than you should.
The Gender Gap in Envy
Interestingly, studies suggest that men and women tend to envy different things, often based on societal pressures. A study from the University of California, San Diego, found that women were more likely to envy other women’s looks and social status, while men were more prone to envy professional success and wealth.
🔗 Read more: Why the Long Head of the Tricep is the Secret to Huge Arms
These aren't hard rules, but they show how our environment shapes our "envy triggers." If society tells you that your value lies in your career, you’ll feel "wrong" when someone else succeeds there. If it tells you your value is in your appearance, that’s where the sting will hit. Understanding the source of the pressure can help de-escalate the emotion.
How to Flip the Script
You can’t just "stop" feeling envy. That’s like trying to stop feeling hungry or tired. It’s an autonomic response. But you can change what you do with it.
The first step is radical honesty. Name it. Tell yourself, "I am feeling envious of Sarah’s new house right now." Just saying it out loud takes away some of its power. It moves the feeling from the emotional part of your brain to the logical part.
Next, look for the "under-feeling." Envy is almost always a mask for something else—usually fear or grief. Are you envious of your friend's marriage because you’re afraid you’ll be alone forever? Are you envious of a coworker’s raise because you’re grieving the goals you haven't met yet? Focus on the fear or the grief, not the other person. They aren't the problem. Your unmet need is.
The Myth of the Zero-Sum Game
One of the biggest reasons we feel "wrong" about envy is the belief that success is a limited resource. If they have a "slice of the pie," there’s less for you. This is "zero-sum" thinking.
In reality, most things aren't a pie. One person’s happiness doesn't actually delete yours. It feels like it does because of how we perceive status, but someone else’s thriving life isn't a critique of your own. It’s just another life happening at the same time as yours.
Actionable Steps to Manage the Green-Eyed Monster
Stop trying to be a saint. Start being a scientist.
Audit your triggers. If a specific person’s posts always make you feel like garbage, mute them. This isn't being "petty." It’s digital hygiene. You wouldn't keep walking into a room filled with smoke if you had asthma; don't walk into a digital space that chokes your self-esteem.
💡 You might also like: Why the Dead Bug Exercise Ball Routine is the Best Core Workout You Aren't Doing Right
Practice "Compersion." This is a term often used in polyamorous communities, but it applies everywhere. It’s the experience of feeling joy because someone else is feeling joy. It takes practice. Start small. When something good happens to someone you actually like, try to lean into their happiness for thirty seconds. It’s like a muscle you have to build.
Investigate the "Why." Use the envy as a career or life coach. If you’re jealous of a friend’s published book, maybe it’s time you actually started writing that manuscript you’ve been talking about for five years. Envy is often your potential screaming at you to pay attention.
Change your "Social Comparison" direction. If you’re constantly looking "up" at people who have more, try looking "down"—not to be arrogant, but for perspective. Remind yourself of the things you have that others are currently praying for. It sounds like a cliché, but neurologically, gratitude and envy cannot occupy the same space in the brain at the exact same moment.
Acknowledge the "Cost." We often envy the result without envying the process. You might envy the CEO’s paycheck, but would you envy their 80-hour work weeks, the high cortisol levels, and the missed time with their kids? Probably not. When you see a "win," remind yourself of the hidden "cost" that likely went into it.
The Reality of Human Nature
Look, you’re never going to be perfectly "pure." You’re going to have moments where you hear about someone’s failure and feel a tiny, shameful spark of relief. Or moments where a friend’s good news makes you want to throw your phone across the room.
That doesn't make you a bad person. It makes you a person.
The goal isn't to reach a state of Zen where you never feel a twinge of jealousy. The goal is to get to a place where that jealousy doesn't drive the bus. You can feel the envy, acknowledge it, and then go about your day without letting it turn into bitterness or self-hatred.
If you're asking envy am i wrong, the answer is a resounding no. You're just paying attention. Now, take that attention and turn it back toward your own life. What's one thing you can do today—not to beat someone else, but to satisfy that version of yourself that's currently feeling left behind? That’s where the real work happens.
Shift the focus from their path to your feet. The sting will fade eventually.
Next Steps:
- Identify the top three people or situations that trigger your envy right now.
- Write down specifically what they have that you want (be specific—is it the money, the freedom, or the recognition?).
- Create a single, small action plan to move toward one of those things for yourself this week.