Let’s be real. If you first met Envy Adams in the 2010 movie, you probably thought she was just a cold, robotic pop star with killer hair and a mean streak. She’s the girl who "kicked Scott’s heart in the ass." She's the villain in a red dress. But if you actually dig into the lore—the comics, the movie nuances, and the Scott Pilgrim Takes Off anime—you realize Envy isn't just some boss fight. She’s arguably the most successful person in the entire franchise, and honestly, Scott probably deserved most of what he got.
The Natalie V. Adams Nobody Talks About
Before she was Envy, she was just Natalie. A dork.
In the original graphic novels by Bryan Lee O'Malley, we get the backstory that the movie mostly glosses over. Natalie Adams was a "mousey" college girl at the University of Toronto. She had a room full of anime toys and a massive collection of nerdy books. She was the quiet one. Then she started dating Scott, and they formed a band called Kid Chameleon with Stephen Stills.
Here’s where it gets messy.
Scott likes to remember himself as the victim, but he’s an unreliable narrator. He remembers their breakup as this sudden, cruel betrayal. In reality? Natalie was the one with ambition. She saw that their band could actually go somewhere. She started changing her image, selling her nerd gear for high-end clothes, and pushing the band toward a professional sound. Scott hated it. He wanted to stay a slacker in a basement.
The name "Envy" literally comes from her initials: N.V. (Natalie V. Adams). It wasn’t just a stage name; it was a total reinvention. She realized that to survive the music industry, she had to stop being "nice" Natalie and start being someone people couldn't ignore.
📖 Related: Howie Mandel Cupcake Picture: What Really Happened With That Viral Post
Why Brie Larson’s Performance Still Hits
You can’t talk about Scott Pilgrim vs. the World Envy Adams without mentioning Brie Larson. It’s wild to think this was years before she was Captain Marvel or winning Oscars for Room.
In the film, Larson does something brilliant with the character. She plays Envy with this breathy, exaggerated "rock star" affectation that’s both hilarious and intimidating. When she delivers lines like, "Ramona, I like your outfit—affordable?" it’s pure, concentrated snark.
But the real magic is the music.
Brie Larson actually sang "Black Sheep." While the song was originally written and performed by the band Metric (who served as the real-life inspiration for Envy’s band, The Clash at Demonhead), Larson’s version is the one everyone remembers. It has this sinister, driving energy. Edgar Wright, the director, famously told his actors not to blink during takes to give the movie a "comic book" feel. If you watch the "Black Sheep" performance closely, Larson’s unblinking, predatory stare makes the character feel almost superhuman.
The Metric Connection
If you’ve ever wondered why Envy feels so authentic as a frontwoman, it’s because she was modeled after Emily Haines of Metric. The fashion, the stage presence, the synth-heavy indie-rock vibe—it’s all a love letter to the Canadian indie scene of the mid-2000s.
👉 See also: Austin & Ally Maddie Ziegler Episode: What Really Happened in Homework & Hidden Talents
The "Two Sides" of the Breakup
In Volume 6 of the comics, the truth comes out. Scott finally remembers the real reason they broke up. It wasn't just Envy "turning evil."
They were at a New Year’s Eve party. Scott got incredibly drunk and started a massive, screaming argument with her. He accused her of cheating (which, to be fair, she might have been doing with Todd Ingram) and vented all his insecurities about her success. He was the one who made it toxic.
Envy even tells him later that the heartbreak was mutual.
That’s a big deal. It reframes her entire character. She didn't just leave Scott because she got famous; she left because their relationship had become a dumpster fire of resentment. While Scott spent years moping and "forgetting" his own bad behavior, Envy moved on and built a career.
The Clash at Demonhead Dynamics
Envy’s relationship with Todd Ingram is basically a power struggle disguised as a romance. Todd is the "Third Evil Ex," a vegan bass player with psychic powers, but he’s also a total idiot.
✨ Don't miss: Kiss My Eyes and Lay Me to Sleep: The Dark Folklore of a Viral Lullaby
In the movie and comics, Envy knows Todd is cheating on her with Lynette Guycott (the drummer). She’s unhappy, but she stays because The Clash at Demonhead is a brand. It’s a business. This is where the tragedy of Envy Adams lies: she traded her nerdy, authentic self for a persona that brought her fame but left her surrounded by people she couldn't trust.
The Anime Twist
In the 2023 Netflix series Scott Pilgrim Takes Off, we see a totally different side of her. Since Scott "dies" in the first episode (spoiler alert for a three-year-old show), the timeline shifts. Envy ends up helping Ramona. She’s still a diva, but she’s more human. She actually shows vulnerability. It proves that without Scott there to act as a catalyst for her worst impulses, she’s actually a pretty reasonable person—just one who happens to be a global superstar.
How to Understand Envy's Evolution
If you're trying to piece together the "true" Envy Adams, look at these specific milestones across the media:
- The Hair Color: In the comics, her hair changes frequently, mirroring her shifting identity. In the movie, that platinum blonde look is iconic and static, representing her "finished product" celebrity persona.
- The Knee Weakness: During the big fight at the Lee's Palace, Ramona knows Envy’s weak point is the back of her knee. It’s a literal physical weakness, but it’s also a metaphor for how fragile her "cool" exterior actually is.
- The Reconciliation: In the books, Envy and Scott eventually have a moment of peace. She helps him prepare for the final fight against Gideon Graves. It’s a rare moment where the "Envy" mask slips, and Natalie comes back for a second.
Final Insights for Fans
Envy Adams is the "Final Boss" of Scott's past. She represents the person he couldn't keep up with, and the version of himself he was too scared to become.
If you're re-watching the movie or reading the books, stop looking at her as a villain. Look at her as a woman who realized the person she was with was holding her back, so she changed her entire world to get out. Was she a jerk? Yeah, definitely. But in a world full of "evil exes," she’s one of the few who actually found success on her own terms.
To get the full Envy experience, you really should listen to the "Black Sheep" vocal track by Brie Larson followed by the original Metric version. The difference in tone tells you everything you need to know about the character's "sinister" edge versus her indie-rock roots. Also, keep an eye out for the background details in the movie's phone call scene—you can literally see the photos of Natalie and Scott's relationship deteriorating in the background.
Check out the Scott Pilgrim Color Edition graphic novels specifically for the "Envy" chapters—the added color really emphasizes the transition from the dull greys of her college life to the vibrant, intimidating reds and purples of her rock star era.