Hollywood loves a good "replacement" narrative. It's basically the industry's favorite ghost story. For years, the internet has hummed with this specific theory: that Emma Stone essentially "stole" the career Lindsay Lohan was supposed to have. It's a tidy story. Two redheads with raspy voices and impeccable comedic timing, one rising just as the other’s personal life hit a very public wall. But honestly? That's a massive oversimplification that ignores how different their paths actually were.
The comparison really peaked around 2010. Emma Stone had just skyrocketed to A-list status with Easy A. People were calling her the "new" Lindsay, pointing to the freckles and the snark. It felt like a torch-passing moment, even if Lindsay hadn't actually agreed to hand the torch over.
The Redheaded Archetype and the 2010 Pivot
Let's look at the facts. Emma Stone isn't even a natural redhead. She’s a blonde who dyed her hair for Superbad on the advice of Judd Apatow. Lindsay, meanwhile, was the blueprint for the early 2000s "it-girl." She had The Parent Trap, Freaky Friday, and the cultural behemoth that was Mean Girls. By the time Emma was faking her way through high school rumors in Easy A, Lindsay was navigating a legal and personal storm that the paparazzi refused to let her weather in peace.
People saw Stone’s success in a smart, self-aware teen comedy and immediately drew a line back to Cady Heron. It’s an easy jump to make. Both actresses have that rare ability to be the prettiest girl in the room while also being the funniest. But where Lindsay’s early work was often about the "fish out of water" or the earnest teen, Emma’s breakout was defined by a certain "knowingness."
Interestingly, the industry itself leaned into this. In a 2010 episode of Saturday Night Live, Emma Stone actually played Lindsay Lohan in a sketch. She nailed the voice—the deep, slightly gravelly tone they both share. It was a meta-commentary on the comparison, showing that Emma was well aware of the "replacement" chatter.
Why the "Stolen Career" Theory Doesn't Hold Up
The "shower thought" that often goes viral is some version of: "If Lindsay Lohan had stayed on track, she’d have Emma Stone’s Oscars."
I’m not so sure.
Emma Stone’s career trajectory has been incredibly calculated in a way that feels very "modern Hollywood." She moved from teen comedies into gritty indies like Birdman and then into the eccentric, high-art world of Yorgos Lanthimos with The Favourite and Poor Things. She has two Academy Awards now. She’s become a producer. Her path is about reinvention and risk.
🔗 Read more: Celebrity SAS Who Dares Wins: What Really Happens Behind the Scenes
Lindsay’s career, until very recently, was rooted in a different era of stardom. She was a child star. That’s a whole different beast. As she mentioned in a 2025 interview with The Times, she still deals with extreme PTSD from the paparazzi culture of the mid-2000s. You can't just "swap" those two lives and expect the same outcome. Emma had a slower, more traditional climb starting in her late teens, which arguably gave her a more stable foundation to handle the weight of being a "prestige" actress.
The "Mean Girls" Connection and the Olive Branch
Despite the media trying to pit them against each other for a decade, the "drama" has been pretty one-sided or nonexistent. Lindsay actually tried to bridge the gap years ago. In 2017, she famously (and somewhat chaotically) tweeted at Emma, asking if they could film a Mean Girls 2 together. She even added, "I think we would be friends."
It never happened, obviously. Emma generally stays off social media and keeps her private life behind a very thick curtain. But that moment showed that Lindsay didn't view Emma as a rival, but rather as a peer she respected.
The 2026 Landscape: Both Stars on Top
Fast forward to right now, early 2026. The narrative has shifted again. We aren't talking about "replacements" anymore because there’s room for both.
- Lindsay Lohan's "Lohanaissance": Following the massive success of Freakier Friday in late 2025, Lindsay has officially transitioned from "nostalgia act" back to "working lead." Her Netflix deal proved she could still pull huge numbers.
- Emma Stone's Artistic Peak: Emma is currently coming off her second Oscar win and is reportedly looking for more "transformative" roles that move away from the "quirky girl" trope entirely.
It’s kind of wild to look back at 2010 and see how obsessed everyone was with finding the "next" version of a star. Hollywood is obsessed with archetypes. If you’re a redhead with a raspy voice, you’re put in a box. But both women broke out of those boxes in totally different ways.
One thing we often forget is that they actually have a lot of mutual respect. In various interviews over the years, Emma has been nothing but complimentary about Lindsay’s early talent, once calling her the "true redhead" of the two.
What We Can Learn From the Stone-Lohan "Beef"
The biggest takeaway here is that "stolen careers" aren't really a thing. Success in Hollywood isn't a zero-sum game. Emma Stone’s rise didn't cause Lindsay Lohan’s hiatus; the tabloid industry and personal struggles did. And Emma didn't just "step into" a vacant slot—she built a completely new type of career that focused on auteur-driven cinema.
If you’re still holding onto the idea that they hate each other, or that Emma is just a "refined" version of Lindsay, you’re missing the nuance of their individual talents.
Next Steps for Fans:
If you want to see how their styles actually diverge, do a double feature this weekend. Watch Easy A and then watch the original Mean Girls. Pay attention to the comedic timing. You'll notice that while the "vibe" is similar, the delivery is worlds apart. Also, keep an eye out for Lindsay’s upcoming projects—she’s reportedly in talks for a gritty drama that sounds like a major departure from her Netflix rom-com era.