You’ve probably seen the clip by now. It’s early 2025, and Elon Musk is standing on a stage at the Capital One Arena in Washington, D.C., celebrating Donald Trump’s inauguration. He’s fired up. He talks about the "fork in the road for human civilization." Then, he does something that set the internet on fire: he slaps his chest and extends his right arm upward, palm down.
Naturally, the world lost its mind. To some, it was an unmistakable Elon Musk "Heil Hitler" moment. To others, it was just a weird, socially awkward guy trying to be enthusiastic.
Social media erupted into two camps. You had people side-by-side with archival footage of 1930s rallies, and you had Musk’s defenders saying the "everyone is Hitler" trope is getting old. But where is the line between a clumsy gesture and a calculated dog whistle? To understand the weight of that one arm movement, we have to look at the messy trail of "almost-antisemitism" Musk has left behind over the last few years.
The January 2025 Incident: A Salute or a "Dab"?
Honestly, if it were anyone else, we might have ignored it. But Musk isn't anyone else. He was the guy newly tapped to lead the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE). When he made that gesture—stiff arm, palm down, angled toward the ceiling—he did it twice. Once to the front, once to the crowd behind him.
"My heart goes out to you," he said.
Democratic Congressman Jerry Nadler didn't buy it. He called it an "abhorrent gesture" that belongs in the darkest chapters of history. Ruth Ben-Ghiat, a historian from NYU who literally studies fascism for a living, was even more blunt. She called it a "belligerent" Nazi salute.
💡 You might also like: Robert Hanssen: What Most People Get Wrong About the FBI's Most Damaging Spy
But then the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) stepped in with a bit of a curveball. Despite having a history of feuding with Musk, they basically told everyone to take a breath. They called it an "awkward gesture in a moment of enthusiasm." Even Jon Stewart on The Daily Show joked that maybe Elon was just trying to "dab on the haters."
The problem? Neo-Nazi groups didn't see a "dab." Groups like the Blood Tribe and various "White Lives Matter" Telegram channels were popping champagne. They saw it as a signal. Whether he meant it or not, the people who actually subscribe to that ideology felt seen. That’s the tricky part about Musk—his intent is often a black box, but the impact is very real.
Why People Are So Quick to Believe the Worst
Context is everything. If a random guy at a grocery store raises his hand to wave, nobody calls him a fascist. But Musk has been flirting with controversial rhetoric for years.
Back in late 2023, he replied to a post on X that claimed Jewish communities push "dialectical hatred against whites." Musk’s response? "The actual truth." That was a disaster. Advertisers like Disney, Apple, and IBM didn't just walk away; they sprinted. Musk eventually called it his "dumbest ever social media post," but the damage was done. He even went to Israel and visited a kibbutz with Benjamin Netanyahu to try and smooth things over. It was a classic "apology tour" that he insisted wasn't an apology tour.
Then there was the Media Matters report. They found big-brand ads running right next to pro-Nazi content—literal images of Adolf Hitler and praise for the Third Reich. Musk didn't exactly take the criticism gracefully. He sued Media Matters and told fleeing advertisers to "go f*** yourself" during a live interview.
📖 Related: Why the Recent Snowfall Western New York State Emergency Was Different
The Auschwitz Visit: Sincere or Performance?
In January 2024, Musk took a private tour of the Auschwitz-Birkenau death camp. He brought his son, X Æ A-Xii, on his shoulders. He laid a wreath. He stood in silence at the Wall of Death.
But even this didn't land the way his PR team probably hoped. Gidon Lev, a Holocaust survivor who was part of the group, later described the visit as a "performance." He felt Musk was "uninterested" and more focused on the cameras than the gravity of the site.
"I was a prop," Lev said. It’s a harsh critique, but it highlights the central tension: Is Musk a "philo-semite" (as he claims) who just happens to be a free-speech absolutist, or is he someone who enjoys the "edge" of forbidden imagery?
The "Roman Salute" and the Asperger's Factor
One of the more nuanced defenses of Musk involves his self-diagnosis of Asperger's (now commonly referred to under the Autism Spectrum Disorder umbrella). People on the spectrum often have "stilted" or "unusual" motor movements. When Musk gets excited, he tends to jump, wave his arms, or move in ways that look physically awkward to neurotypical observers.
There’s also the historical "Roman Salute." Long before it was stolen by the Nazis, this was a gesture used in the Olympics and even the U.S. Pledge of Allegiance (the Bellamy Salute). Some argue Musk was aiming for a generic "heroic" gesture.
👉 See also: Nate Silver Trump Approval Rating: Why the 2026 Numbers Look So Different
But here’s the thing: Musk is one of the most informed people on the planet. He knows the history of symbols. He knows how his platform works. When you’re the richest man in the world, "oops, I accidentally did a Nazi salute" starts to feel like a thin excuse after the third or fourth time you’ve been accused of it.
What This Means for X and the Future of Discourse
Whether the Elon Musk "Heil Hitler" controversy was a literal salute or a massive misunderstanding, it has fundamentally changed how we view his platform.
- Advertiser Trust is Gutter-Level: Companies don't want to be within ten miles of this kind of controversy. Even if Musk is innocent, the "vibe" is toxic for brands like Coca-Cola or Procter & Gamble.
- The Rise of the "Edgelord" CEO: We are in an era where the heads of massive tech companies act more like internet trolls than corporate stewards. This creates a feedback loop where extreme content is engagement-gold.
- The Normalization Problem: When a person with 200 million followers makes a gesture that looks like a Nazi salute, it "breaks" the taboo. It makes the gesture a meme rather than a symbol of genocide. That, according to many activists, is the real danger.
How to Navigate the Noise
It’s easy to get sucked into the "Elon is a Nazi" or "Elon is a Savior" camps. Most of the time, the reality is somewhere in the boring middle. Musk is a guy who hates being told what to do and seems to get a kick out of "triggering" people he views as "woke."
If you're trying to figure out what's actually happening, look at the actions, not just the tweets. Look at who is being reinstated on X and who is being silenced. Check the transparency reports (when they actually release them).
Next Steps for Staying Informed:
- Verify the Source: When a video of a "salute" goes viral, watch the full 10-minute speech. Context often changes the energy of the movement.
- Follow Diverse Watchdogs: Don't just read the ADL or Media Matters. Look at what independent journalists on both the left and right are saying to see where they agree on the facts.
- Monitor Ad Placement: If you're a business owner, use third-party tools to see where your content is actually landing on social platforms to ensure your brand safety isn't being compromised by algorithm "accidents."