Let’s be honest for a second. The idea of never seeing a federal withholding line on your paycheck again sounds like a dream. It’s the kind of thing that makes people stop scrolling and lean in. Recently, Donald Trump has been leaning into it too, floating the idea that we could potentially replace the entire federal income tax system with revenue from massive tariffs.
He’s even called the current system a "mistake" and suggested returning to the way the U.S. ran things in the late 1800s. Back then, the government didn't touch your paycheck; it just taxed the crates coming off the ships. But can a president actually pull that off in 2026?
The short answer: It’s not just a policy shift; it’s a total dismantling of the American economic engine.
The $2 Trillion Math Problem
Here is the thing about the federal budget: it’s massive. In the 2024–2025 fiscal cycle, individual income taxes brought in roughly $2.4 trillion to $2.7 trillion. That money pays for everything from the F-35 fighter jets to the guys who process your passport.
Trump’s plan involves using tariffs—taxes on imported goods—to fill that hole. Currently, the U.S. is pulling in record tariff revenue, but it’s still only around $195 billion to $250 billion a year.
✨ Don't miss: Starting Pay for Target: What Most People Get Wrong
If you’re doing the math at home, you’ll notice a "small" gap. To replace the income tax entirely, you’d need to find about $2 trillion more. To get that from tariffs, you wouldn't just be looking at a 10% or 20% tax on Chinese electronics. You would likely need across-the-board tariffs of 60% to 100% on almost everything we import.
Why the "Laffer Curve" ruins the party
There’s a concept in economics called the Laffer Curve. Basically, if you tax something too much, people just stop doing it. If a toaster from overseas suddenly costs twice as much because of a tariff, you might just stop buying toasters. If people stop importing, the tariff revenue actually drops instead of goes up.
Economists like Erica York from the Tax Foundation have pointed out that there is a "hard cap" on how much you can squeeze out of tariffs. You eventually reach a point where you’ve killed the trade you’re trying to tax.
The Constitutional "Wall"
Even if Trump had the perfect math, he doesn't have a magic "delete" button for the IRS. The federal income tax isn't just a law; it’s backed by the 16th Amendment.
🔗 Read more: Why the Old Spice Deodorant Advert Still Wins Over a Decade Later
"The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived..."
Before 1913, the Supreme Court actually struck down income taxes because they weren't "apportioned" correctly among the states. It took a constitutional amendment to make the current system legal. While a president can't single-handedly "eliminate" an amendment, they can work with Congress to set the tax rate to 0%.
But think about the logistics. Trump’s current signature legislation—the "One Big Beautiful Bill" (OBBB) signed in July 2025—already made a lot of the 2017 tax cuts permanent. It even added "no tax on tips" and "no tax on overtime" for certain workers. But even that bill kept the core income tax brackets in place.
To go to zero, he’d need a massive majority in both the House and the Senate who are willing to risk a catastrophic deficit. Right now, even some Republicans are skeptical about the "tariff-only" model because of how it might spike inflation for the middle class.
💡 You might also like: Palantir Alex Karp Stock Sale: Why the CEO is Actually Selling Now
Who Actually Wins and Loses?
This is where it gets kinda messy. Income tax is progressive. That’s a fancy way of saying the more you make, the higher your percentage.
Tariffs are essentially a national sales tax. When a company like Apple or Walmart pays a tariff to bring goods into the U.S., they don't just eat that cost. They pass it to you. That means the price of your shoes, your phone, and your car parts goes up.
- Low-income families: Spend a huge chunk of their money on physical goods (clothes, electronics, food). They would feel the "tariff tax" every time they went to the store.
- High-income earners: Spend a smaller percentage of their total wealth on "stuff." They would save millions in income tax while barely noticing the extra $2.00 on a gallon of imported olive oil.
What’s Actually Happening in 2026?
While the total elimination of income tax remains a "north star" for the administration's rhetoric, the reality on the ground for 2026 is different. The One Big Beautiful Bill is the law of the land now. Here is what you’re actually looking at for this tax season:
- The Standard Deduction is huge. It’s jumped to about $16,100 for single filers.
- Specific Car Deductions: There's a new $10,000 deduction for interest on loans for American-made vehicles (with some income limits).
- The "Tariff Dividend": There has been talk of a $2,000 check sent to Americans funded by tariff revenue. This is a way to "offset" the higher prices at stores, but it's been stuck in legislative limbo.
The Verdict: Possible or Pipe Dream?
Can Trump eliminate the income tax? Technically, with a cooperative Congress, he could set the rates to zero. Realistically? Probably not. The U.S. government is too big, and the debt is too high to rely solely on the "Gilded Age" model of funding. We aren't a small agrarian nation anymore; we’re a global superpower with a $6 trillion annual budget.
Your Next Steps
If you're trying to plan your finances around these headlines, don't stop paying your estimated taxes just yet.
- Watch the 2026 Midterms: The fate of any further "radical" tax changes depends entirely on whether the GOP keeps the House. If they lose it, the "eliminate the income tax" conversation effectively ends.
- Audit your "Import" spending: If tariffs continue to rise, the "tax" you pay will be at the cash register. Look at your big-ticket purchases (cars, appliances) and consider if you should buy before new rounds of duties kick in.
- Check the new deductions: Make sure you're taking advantage of the "One Big Beautiful Bill" provisions, especially if you work overtime or in a tipped industry, as those are the "mini-eliminations" that are actually active right now.
The tax code is changing faster than it has in decades. It's a wild ride, but for now, the 1040 form isn't going anywhere.