It starts with a Sharpie. Or, if you’re being cautious, a dry-erase marker. You're standing over a sleeping child at 11:30 PM, heart racing, trying to decide if a mustache or a unibrow is funnier. This is the reality of the elf on the shelf drawing on face prank. It's the high-stakes gamble of the holiday season. One wrong move and you aren't just the "fun parent"—you're the parent scrubbing a permanent ink goatee off a screaming kindergartner before the school bus arrives.
I’ve seen this go sideways more times than I can count. People think it’s a simple gag. It isn't. It requires a steady hand, the right tools, and an exit strategy. If you’re going to let your Scout Elf take the blame for some facial graffiti, you need to know the physics of ink on skin and the psychology of a surprised toddler.
Why the Elf on the Shelf Drawing on Face Prank is a Holiday Staple
The tradition of the Scout Elf, which originated from the 2005 book by Carol Aebersold and Chanda Bell, was originally about observation. The elf sits. The elf watches. The elf reports to Santa. But as social media took over, the elf became a chaotic trickster. The "drawing on the face" move is peak elf mischief because it’s personal. It violates the "no touchy" rule in a way that feels daring to kids.
Basically, it’s the ultimate proof that the elf was actually there. When a child wakes up, looks in the mirror, and sees a red nose or "Ho Ho Ho" written across their forehead, the magic is instantaneous. It’s a core memory. But honestly, the line between a magical morning and a panicked trip to the bathroom with a washcloth is razor-thin.
The Chemistry of the Ink Matters
Don't use a Sharpie. Just don't. I know it’s the first thing you grab in the junk drawer, but permanent marker is designed to be, well, permanent. Human skin produces oils, and while those oils eventually break down the ink, it won't happen by 8:00 AM.
If you want to pull off the elf on the shelf drawing on face bit safely, you have a few specific options:
- Eyeliner pencils: These are the gold standard. They are designed for skin, they’re pigmented, and they smudge just enough to look like "elf work" without being impossible to remove.
- Washable markers: Crayola is your friend here. Specifically the "Ultra-Clean" line. They contain surfactants that make the ink lift off with just water.
- Lipstick: Great for rosy cheeks or a big red nose, but it can be greasy. It stays put, though.
- Dry-erase markers: A risky choice. They often contain alcohols that can irritate sensitive skin, and on some skin types, they actually stain worse than washable markers.
The Logistics of the Midnight Prank
You have to be a ninja. This isn't just about drawing; it’s about stealth. Most kids are heavy sleepers, but the "elf" needs to be careful about the tactile sensation of the marker.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Siege of Vienna 1683 Still Echoes in European History Today
Start with the forehead. It’s the least sensitive part of the face. If they don’t stir, move to the cheeks. Avoid the eyelids and the area directly under the eyes. The skin there is thin, and the risk of getting ink in the eye is too high.
Pro tip: Practice on your own hand first. See how much pressure you need to apply to get a visible line. You want a light touch. If you press too hard, the child will feel the "poke" and wake up. If they wake up while you’re holding a marker over them, the jig is up. You can't explain that away.
Handling the Reveal
The reveal is the best part. You have to play it cool. Don't tell them. Let them find it.
"Hey, you've got something on your face," is the classic line. Or just lead them to the bathroom for their morning teeth-brushing and wait for the scream of delight (or confusion). The elf should be positioned nearby, still holding the marker. This creates the "crime scene" aesthetic that makes the story believable.
When Things Go Wrong: The Cleanup
Sometimes the ink doesn't come off. Maybe you used a marker that was "washable" but decided to bond with your child's pores. Maybe you got overzealous with a mustache.
If soap and water fail, don't scrub. Scrubbing causes redness and irritation, which makes the "elf" look like a jerk. Instead, use oil-based products.
🔗 Read more: Why the Blue Jordan 13 Retro Still Dominates the Streets
- Micellar water: Excellent for breaking down makeup-grade pencils.
- Coconut oil or Olive oil: These dissolve the pigments in most markers.
- Rubbing alcohol: Use this sparingly and only on older kids. It dries out the skin fast.
- Baby wipes: Surprisingly effective, but check for fragrances if your kid has sensitive skin.
The Ethics of Drawing on a Sleeping Child
Some parents hate this. They think it's a violation of trust or just plain creepy. And honestly? I get it. If your child is a light sleeper or has anxiety about the elf, skipping the face-drawing is a smart move.
There are "safe" alternatives that still hit the elf on the shelf drawing on face vibe without the actual skin contact.
- The Mirror Trick: Draw the mustache or glasses on the bathroom mirror with a dry-erase marker. Position the elf so that when the child stands in front of the mirror, the drawing "lines up" with their reflection.
- The Framed Photo: Use a dry-erase marker to draw on the glass of a framed family photo. The elf "vandalizes" the picture instead of the person.
- The Banana: Draw faces on the fruit in the kitchen. It’s funny, it’s harmless, and nobody needs a bath afterward.
Expert Nuance: The Age Factor
Age matters. A three-year-old might be terrified to wake up with a different face. A seven-year-old will likely think it’s the funniest thing that has ever happened in their life. You have to know your audience. If your kid is in the "fear of clowns" phase, maybe don't draw a red nose on them while they sleep.
Setting Up the Scene for Maximum Impact
If you’re committed to the full elf on the shelf drawing on face experience, the staging is everything. The elf shouldn't just be sitting there. They should be "caught in the act."
Maybe the elf is tucked into the child's pajama pocket, still clutching the eyeliner pencil. Or perhaps the elf has drawn on their own face too, showing a bit of "solidarity" in the mischief. One of the funniest setups I've seen involved the elf drawing a "mustache" on a stuffed animal first, then moving on to the child. It tells a chronological story.
Common Misconceptions About Elf Pranks
People think the elf has to be "bad" to be funny. That’s not true. Mischief doesn't have to be mean. The drawing prank works best when it's whimsical. Avoid drawing anything "scary." Stick to:
💡 You might also like: Sleeping With Your Neighbor: Why It Is More Complicated Than You Think
- Mustaches (the classic)
- Monocles
- Hearts on the cheeks
- "Cat" whiskers
- Small stars
Avoid anything that resembles "dirt" or "bruises." You want them to look in the mirror and see a cartoon character, not someone who fell in the mud.
Strategic Execution Steps
If you are doing this tonight, follow this specific workflow to ensure you don't end up with a permanent mistake.
First, choose your tool. Go find an eyeliner pencil. If you don't have one, find a high-quality washable marker. Test it on your own inner wrist. Wait five minutes. Try to wipe it off with a damp paper towel. If it leaves a ghost of a mark, don't use it on the kid.
Second, wait for the deep sleep. Usually, this happens about 30 to 45 minutes after they fall asleep. Look for the "limp limb" stage. If you lift their hand and it drops like a rock, you’re in the clear.
Third, keep it simple. A single "mustache" line is enough. You don't need to draw a full pirate beard. The more ink you put on, the more you have to take off.
Fourth, place the elf. The elf needs to be the "culprit." Make sure the marker is positioned in the elf’s hands. Using a little bit of clear tape or a rubber band can help the elf "hold" the pen.
Fifth, have the cleaning supplies ready for the morning. Don't wait until you're running late for school to realize you're out of makeup remover. Have a pack of wipes or a bottle of micellar water sitting on the counter.
Actionable Next Steps
- Audit your markers: Go to your craft bin right now and pull out anything labeled "Permanent." Put those in a high cabinet where "the elf" (and your kids) can't reach them.
- Buy a dedicated "Elf Pen": Buy a cheap black eyeliner pencil specifically for this purpose. It’s a $2 investment that prevents a $200 headache.
- Check the skin: If your child has eczema or a history of skin reactions, pivot to the "Mirror Trick" mentioned above. It’s not worth a rash.
- Prepare the camera: This is a one-time reaction. Have your phone ready when they walk into the bathroom. You'll want the video of that first look in the mirror.
- Plan the cleanup: Make the cleanup part of the fun. Tell them the "elf magic" only washes off with "special elf soap" (which is just regular soap, but hey, branding).
This prank is a rite of passage for many families. It’s low-cost, high-impact, and perfectly captures the chaotic spirit of the Scout Elf. Just remember: the goal is a laugh, not a skin graft. Keep the lines light, the ink washable, and the camera rolling.