People always get a little weirded out when they hear the "cousin" thing. It’s the first question anyone asks when the topic of the 32nd President comes up. Were they actually related? Yes. Was it a scandal? Not really, at least not for the reasons you’d think. Honestly, the family tree of the American aristocracy in the early 20th century was more like a hedge—tightly knit, carefully pruned, and very, very interconnected.
When we talk about Eleanor and Franklin Roosevelt cousins, we’re talking about a fifth-cousin relationship. They shared great-great-great-great-grandparents, Nicholas Roosevelt and Heyltje Kunst. If you’re trying to do the math in your head, don't bother. It’s distant. Very distant. In the world of the New York "Knickerbocker" elite, this was basically like being total strangers who happened to share a famous last name and a few holiday dinners.
The Hyde Park vs. Oyster Bay Rivalry
You can't understand their relationship without understanding the two "clans." The Roosevelts were split. You had the Oyster Bay Roosevelts (the Republicans, like Theodore Roosevelt) and the Hyde Park Roosevelts (the Democrats, like Franklin). Eleanor was an Oyster Bay girl. She was TR’s favorite niece. Franklin was the pampered prince of Hyde Park.
Think about that for a second.
When they started dating, it wasn't the "cousin" part that made people talk. It was the politics and the social standing. Franklin’s mother, Sara Delano Roosevelt, was the real hurdle. She was a powerhouse. A titan. She didn't want anyone taking her "Boy" away, let alone a shy, tall, somewhat awkward cousin from the "other" side of the family. Sara actually took Franklin on a Caribbean cruise specifically to make him forget about Eleanor. It didn't work. Franklin was hooked. He saw something in Eleanor that most people missed—a steel spine and a massive heart.
That Wedding Day in 1905
The wedding was wild. Not because of the bride and groom, but because of the guest of honor. Since Eleanor’s father, Elliott (TR’s brother), had passed away years earlier, President Theodore Roosevelt gave the bride away.
👉 See also: Executive desk with drawers: Why your home office setup is probably failing you
It was St. Patrick’s Day, 1905.
The press went nuts. People weren't looking at the dress; they were trying to catch a glimpse of the sitting President. TR reportedly leaned over to Franklin and said, "Well, Franklin, there's nothing like keeping the name in the family." It was a joke, but it stuck. It also highlighted the fact that Eleanor didn't even have to change her signature after the ceremony. She was a Roosevelt, she married a Roosevelt, and she stayed a Roosevelt.
Why the "Cousin" Label is Misleading
Usually, when we hear "cousins," we think of people who grew up playing tag at the same family reunions every summer. That wasn't them. They barely knew each other as kids. They met again as adults at a horse show, and then later on a train. That’s when the spark happened.
Franklin was dashing. Eleanor was serious.
He was attracted to her mind. She was attracted to his energy. It’s kind of a bummer that history books focus so much on the bloodline when the actual dynamic was about two people from a specific social caste finding a partner who could handle the pressures of that life. They were intellectual equals in a time when that wasn't always the goal for a marriage.
✨ Don't miss: Monroe Central High School Ohio: What Local Families Actually Need to Know
The Lucy Mercer Scandal and the Shift
Their marriage wasn't a fairy tale. Far from it. In 1918, Eleanor found a packet of love letters in Franklin’s luggage. They were from Lucy Mercer, Eleanor’s own social secretary. This is the moment where the "cousin" dynamic actually matters in a weird way. Because of their shared family legacy and the political stakes involved, divorce was off the table. Sara Delano Roosevelt threatened to cut Franklin off financially if he left Eleanor.
So they made a pact.
They stayed together. They became a political partnership rather than a traditional romantic one. Eleanor became Franklin's "eyes and ears," especially after he contracted polio in 1921. She traveled the country. she went into coal mines. She went where a man in a wheelchair couldn't go. This partnership—born out of a family connection but forged in personal betrayal and shared ambition—changed the American presidency forever.
The Genetic Reality
If you're worried about the biology, fifth cousins share about 0.05% of their DNA. For context, you probably share more DNA with a random person in your neighborhood than they did. The "cousin" thing is a great headline, but genetically, it was a non-issue. The real "incestuous" part of the story was the New York social circle. Everyone knew everyone. Everyone was related to everyone else's aunt or uncle. It was a closed loop of wealth and influence.
Insights for History Buffs
If you're looking into the Roosevelt lineage, don't just stop at the family tree. Look at the letters. The FDR Library has digitized a huge amount of their correspondence. You can see the shift in their tone over the years—from the flowery, romantic notes of their youth to the sharp, strategic memos of the White House years.
🔗 Read more: What Does a Stoner Mean? Why the Answer Is Changing in 2026
What to Look For:
- The 1902-1905 Letters: These show a very different Franklin, one who was genuinely smitten and a bit intimidated by Eleanor's depth.
- The "Granny" Factor: Research Sara Delano’s influence. She lived with them for much of their marriage. Imagine living with your mother-in-law while also being the First Lady. It's a miracle Eleanor didn't lose her mind.
- The Oyster Bay Connection: See how TR’s children felt about Franklin. Hint: They weren't always fans. They saw him as a bit of a "featherweight" early on.
Moving Beyond the Family Tree
Ultimately, the story of Eleanor and Franklin Roosevelt as cousins is just the prologue. The real story is how two people used a shared name to build a platform that redefined the role of government and the First Lady. Eleanor wasn't just "the cousin who married the President." She was the woman who forced the President to care about civil rights, poverty, and women's issues when it wasn't politically convenient.
To really grasp the depth of this, you should visit the FDR Presidential Library and Museum in Hyde Park, New York. Seeing their separate bedrooms and their shared workspace puts the "partnership" into perspective. You can also dive into Doris Kearns Goodwin’s No Ordinary Time, which is arguably the best book on their White House years. It breaks down the complexity of their bond better than any genealogy chart ever could.
Stop focusing on the 0.05% shared DNA and start looking at the 100% shared commitment to public service. That’s where the real Roosevelt legacy lives.
Actionable Next Steps:
- Visit Hyde Park: If you're on the East Coast, tour Springwood (the estate) and Val-Kill (Eleanor's private retreat). The physical distance between their living spaces tells you everything about their relationship.
- Read the Correspondence: Check out the "My Day" columns by Eleanor Roosevelt. She wrote them almost every day for decades. They provide a raw look at her daily life and her interactions with "Franklin."
- Fact-Check the Trees: Use resources like the Roosevelt Institute to map out the Oyster Bay vs. Hyde Park split. It makes the 1912 and 1932 elections much more interesting when you see which family members supported which candidates.
- Explore the Lucy Mercer Files: If you’re interested in the "breaking point" of their marriage, research the correspondence between FDR and Lucy that continued until the day he died in Warm Springs. It adds a human, tragic layer to the Roosevelt story.