You're standing in the middle of a literal swamp, your health is ticking down from scarlet rot, and you've finally found that one NPC you've been looking for. You talk to them. They say three lines of vague poetry. You come back ten minutes later and they’re just... gone. No map marker. No quest log. Welcome to the Lands Between.
Honestly, Elden Ring npc questlines are basically the final boss of the game. You can slay a literal god, but god forbid you accidentally walk into Altus Plateau too early and break five different storylines simultaneously. It happens to everyone. You aren’t bad at the game; the game just doesn't care about your feelings.
The "Point of No Return" Everyone Misses
Most people think the game's big "no turning back" moment is burning the Erdtree. That's a huge one, sure. But the real quest-killer is much subtler. It's the Altus Plateau.
The moment you set foot on that golden grass—whether you take the Grand Lift of Dectus or climb the Ruin-Strewn Precipice—the game shifts. Several quests, like Roderika’s or Brother Corhyn’s, move into their next phase whether you're ready or not. If you haven't talked to Blaidd in the Mistwood or helped Alexander out of his first hole in Stormhill by then, you might have already missed some unique dialogue or items.
It’s frustrating. I’ve personally lost hours of progress because I wanted to "just go grab a map fragment" and ended up skipping the entire first half of a character's life story.
Ranni’s Quest is Actually the Easiest (If You’re Patient)
People hype up Ranni’s questline as this impossible, labyrinthine nightmare. It's long, yeah. It takes you through half the map and two underground cities. But it’s actually one of the most robust questlines because it’s hard to truly "break" it.
Why Ranni is the GOAT of Quests
Even if you ignore her for the first 40 hours, you can usually still start her quest. The main hurdle is Starscourge Radahn. You have to kill him to make the stars fall and open the way to Nokron.
If you're stuck, remember:
🔗 Read more: All Resources in Subnautica Common to Rare: Why You Keep Running Out of Copper
- Talk to the miniature doll at the Ainsel River Main site of grace.
- You have to talk to it three times. The first two times it says nothing. The third time, she finally cracks.
- Don't forget the Discarded Palace Key she gives you after you kill the Baleful Shadow. It opens the chest next to Rennala in the Raya Lucaria Library.
That last part? That's what trips everyone up. People get to the end of the Lake of Rot, find a locked door, and think their game is glitched. Nope. You just forgot the key in the library.
The Millicent Dilemma: Help or Betray?
Millicent’s quest is probably the most emotional one in the game, and also the one with the most "WTF" requirements. To finish it, you have to go to the Haligtree, which is basically a secret area hidden inside another secret area.
Toward the end, you're faced with two summoning signs: one gold (to help her) and one red (to fight her).
The choice matters more than you think. - Helping her gets you the Rotten Winged Sword Insignia. This is arguably the best talisman for fast-hitting builds (think katanas or twinblades).
📖 Related: How to Actually Get the Infinity Nikki Starlit Wings Without Losing Your Mind
- Killing her gets you Millicent’s Prosthesis. It's a slightly weaker damage boost but gives you +5 Dexterity.
Here’s the kicker: if you want to "cure" the Frenzied Flame ending, you must help her. You need the Unalloyed Gold Needle she leaves behind to get Miquella’s Needle. Without it, you’re locked into the "Lord of Frenzied Flame" ending unless you use the needle at Placidusax’s arena. It’s a whole thing.
Alexander the Iron Fist: The Heart of the Game
Alexander is basically the Onion Knight of Elden Ring. He’s a giant pot. He’s charming. He’s also doomed.
His quest takes him from Limgrave to Caelid, then to Mt. Gelmir (where you find him chilling in lava to "harden" his shell), and finally to Crumbling Farum Azula.
Pro-tip: If Alexander isn't appearing in the lava at Mt. Gelmir, it’s probably because you haven't summoned him for the Fire Giant fight or talked to him after the Radahn festival. He’s a stickler for etiquette.
The ending of his story is a gut-punch. But the reward, the Shard of Alexander, is non-negotiable for almost any build. It boosts skill damage by 15%. That’s massive. If you’re using Corpse Piler, Blasphemous Blade, or Moonveil, you need this jar in your life.
How to Actually Succeed in Elden Ring NPC Questlines
If you want to stop failing these quests, you need to change how you play.
- Exhaust dialogue. Keep clicking "Talk" until they repeat themselves.
- Rest often. A lot of NPC triggers happen only after you rest at a Site of Grace, not just when you visit it.
- Check the Roundtable. NPCs like Diallos or Fia move back and forth between the Hold and the world.
- Read item descriptions. Often, a key or a letter will tell you exactly where an NPC went.
There's a lot of talk about "intended" routes, but the truth is, the Lands Between are messy. You're going to miss things. On your first playthrough, that’s actually okay. It makes the world feel bigger, more alive.
🔗 Read more: Why No More Heroes 3 Switch Still Feels Like a Fever Dream Years Later
Next Steps for Your Journey
To make sure you don't miss the most critical rewards, go check the Saintsbridge in North Limgrave for Alexander or the Church of the Plague in Caelid for Millicent right now. These two provide the most powerful talismans in the game, and starting them early is the only way to ensure you don't get locked out by the time you reach the endgame.
Also, if you've already reached the Mountaintops of the Giants, go back to the Roundtable Hold and see if anyone has new dialogue—Gideon and Enia often have "hidden" triggers that only activate after you've cleared certain bosses.