Honestly, if you haven't seen a woman dancing with an American flag while wearing a sweater on her head, have you even experienced the 1970s?
The world of Edith Bouvier Beale movies is a rabbit hole that starts with a crumbling mansion and ends with a deep, somewhat uncomfortable reflection on what it means to be "staunch." Most people stumble into the Grey Gardens universe through a 30-second TikTok clip or a drag queen’s impression. They see the cats. They see the piles of empty pâté cans. They see the revolutionary fashion.
But there is a massive difference between the "kooky" aunt of Jackie O and the actual cinematic history of the Beales. It’s a timeline that spans fifty years of film, from 1970s "direct cinema" to high-budget HBO dramas.
The 1975 Masterpiece: Where It All Started
In 1975, Albert and David Maysles released Grey Gardens. It wasn't just a documentary. It was a cultural earthquake.
At the time, the Maysles brothers were pioneers of "direct cinema." Basically, they just showed up with cameras and let life happen. No narration. No "talking head" experts telling you how to feel. Just "Big Edie" (Edith Ewing Bouvier Beale) and "Little Edie" (Edith Bouvier Beale) bickering in a 28-room East Hampton mansion that was literally falling apart around them.
The backstory is wild. Before the Maysles made their own film, they were actually hired by Lee Radziwill—Jackie Kennedy’s sister—to make a movie about her childhood. When they got to the Hamptons and met her aunt and cousin living in a house infested with raccoons and fleas, they realized that was the real story. Lee eventually pulled the plug on her project, but the Maysles couldn't let it go. They came back, paid the women $5,000 each, and filmed 70 hours of footage.
🔗 Read more: Jack Blocker American Idol Journey: What Most People Get Wrong
You’ve probably heard the accusations of exploitation. Critics like Walter Goodman of The New York Times were disgusted back then. They called it a "freak show." But if you watch it closely, Little Edie isn't a victim. She is a performer. She is finally getting the audience she’s craved since her days as a debutante in 1936. She knows where the camera is every second.
The Lost Prequel: That Summer (2017)
For decades, the footage Lee Radziwill commissioned was thought to be lost or hidden away. Then, in 2017, Swedish director Göran Hugo Olsson released That Summer.
This is the "prequel" you didn't know you needed. It features the original 1972 footage shot by Peter Beard and the Maysles. It’s a totally different vibe. In Grey Gardens, the house is a wreck. In That Summer, you see the house being "raided"—that's the word the Beales used for the cleanup funded by Jackie Onassis.
You see a younger, slightly more connected version of the women. You also see Andy Warhol and Truman Capote floating around. It grounds the story in reality. It reminds you that these weren't just two eccentric hermits; they were at the center of the most elite social circle in American history before they retreated into their own world.
The 2009 HBO Drama: Fact vs. Fiction
If the documentaries give you the "what," the 2009 HBO film Grey Gardens tries to give you the "why."
💡 You might also like: Why American Beauty by the Grateful Dead is Still the Gold Standard of Americana
Drew Barrymore and Jessica Lange took on the roles of the two Edies. Usually, when Hollywood recreates a documentary, it feels stiff. This didn't. Barrymore actually spent months isolated, studying Little Edie’s specific "Social Register" accent—those long 'a' sounds and the weirdly formal way of speaking.
The movie is essential because it fills in the gaps the documentary couldn't touch:
- The 1930s: We see Little Edie as a stunning, hopeful young woman in New York.
- The Romance: Her alleged affair with Julius "Cap" Krug.
- The Decline: How the money actually ran out and how the house began to rot after "Big Edie" was left by her husband, Phelan Beale.
It’s a heartbreaker. It frames their life not as a comedy of errors, but as a long, slow-motion tragedy of codependency. It won six Emmys for a reason.
The "Sequel" You Probably Missed
In 2006, the Maysles released The Beales of Grey Gardens.
It’s entirely made of outtakes from the original 1975 filming. If the first movie felt like a gothic horror story, this one feels more like a tribute. It’s funnier. There’s more singing. More philosophy. Little Edie talks about God, astrology, and her "revolutionary costumes."
📖 Related: Why October London Make Me Wanna Is the Soul Revival We Actually Needed
It’s a deeper look into her mind. You realize she wasn't just "crazy." she was incredibly well-read, quoting poetry and talking about "Oriental philosophy." She was a woman who didn't fit into the 1950s housewife mold and decided that if she couldn't be a star in New York, she’d be the Queen of her own decaying castle.
Why These Movies Still Matter in 2026
The obsession with Edith Bouvier Beale movies isn't just about voyeurism. It’s about the "staunch" character.
In the queer community, Little Edie is a patron saint. Why? Because she took nothing—literally scraps of fabric and safety pins—and made herself iconic. She lived on her own terms when the world told her she was a failure.
We live in a world of curated Instagram feeds and perfect "aesthetic" homes. Grey Gardens is the opposite. It’s the raw, messy, beautiful reality of aging and refusing to let go of your spirit.
Actionable Ways to Experience the Beale Legacy:
- Watch in Order: Start with the 1975 Grey Gardens. Then watch the 2009 HBO film for context. Save That Summer for when you’re truly hooked.
- Look for the Details: In the documentaries, pay attention to the background. The portraits on the floor, the cats on the bed, the "costume of the day." It’s a masterclass in visual storytelling.
- Listen to the Philosophy: Don't just laugh at the bickering. Listen to what Little Edie says about independence and the "line between the past and the present." It’s surprisingly profound.
- Check Out the Musical: If you can find a recording of the 2006 Broadway musical, do it. Christine Ebersole’s performance is legendary.
The Beales are gone now. Big Edie died in 1977, and Little Edie passed away in Florida in 2002. But through these movies, they are more alive than ever. They proved that even if your house is falling down, you can still put on a show.
To truly understand the "Edie" phenomenon, start by streaming the original Criterion Collection restoration of the 1975 film. It provides the most authentic lens into a life that was lived entirely without apology. From there, explore the 2006 outtakes to see the lighter, more philosophical side of their isolation before moving into the dramatized versions of their history.