If you’re typing Edgartown Massachusetts zip code into a search bar, you’re probably either trying to mail a wedding invite to a shingle-style mansion, checking real estate prices that would make a Silicon Valley engineer faint, or you’re lost near the Triangle trying to figure out where the GPS stopped working.
It’s 02539. That’s it. Five digits.
But in the context of Martha's Vineyard, those five digits carry a heavy amount of weight. 02539 isn't just a postal routing number; it’s a lifestyle signifier for the largest town on the island. People get weird about zip codes here. While 02568 (Vineyard Haven) is the year-round hub and 02557 (Oak Bluffs) is the soul of the summer, 02539 is the prestige. It’s the white picket fences of North Water Street and the sprawling Great Ponds that look like something out of a Dutch landscape painting.
The Logistics of 02539: More Than Just Mail
Here is the thing most visitors don’t realize until they’ve been stuck in traffic behind a Chappy Ferry line for forty minutes: Edgartown Massachusetts zip code encompasses a massive geographic area that feels like three different planets.
👉 See also: Dallas Texas Area Map Explained: Why Most People Get It Wrong
First, you have the Village. This is the postcard. It’s where the 02539 mail gets delivered to those tiny brass P.O. boxes because, honestly, getting a mail truck through those narrow colonial streets during July is a nightmare. Then you have Katama. It’s flat, sandy, and smells like salt spray and expensive sunscreen. Finally, there’s Chappaquiddick. "Chappy" technically shares the zip code, but it’s separated by a sliver of water and a very stubborn ferry.
If you're sending a package to 02539, remember that FedEx and UPS usually find the house, but the USPS might require a P.O. Box if the residence is deep in the historic district. It’s an old-school system. It’s charming until you’re waiting in line at the post office on a Tuesday morning behind three different landscaping contractors and a guy trying to ship a literal sail.
Real Estate and the 02539 Premium
Money talks, but in Edgartown, it usually just whispers behind a privet hedge. When you look at the Edgartown Massachusetts zip code, you’re looking at some of the most expensive dirt in North America. According to data from the Cape Cod & Islands Association of Realtors, the median sales price in Edgartown frequently flirts with the $2 million to $3 million range, and that’s for "entry-level" (if you can even call it that) properties.
If you want a house on the harbor? You’re looking at $10 million plus.
Why? Because 02539 is the center of the Vineyard’s social universe. It’s where the yacht club is. It’s where the Fourth of July parade—a genuinely moving slice of Americana—marches past the Whaling Church. People pay for the zip code because they want the proximity to South Beach and the ability to walk to dinner at The Port Hunter or Atlantic without worrying about parking. Parking in Edgartown is basically a competitive sport.
The Chappaquiddick Factor
You can’t talk about 02539 without talking about the island-off-an-island. Chappaquiddick is technically part of Edgartown. It uses the same Edgartown Massachusetts zip code. But the vibe is entirely different.
There are no stores on Chappy. No paved roads once you get past a certain point. Just the Mytoi Gardens, the Wasque preserves, and a lot of privacy. If you’re living in 02539 on the Chappy side, your life is dictated by "The On-Time" ferry. If you miss the last boat, you’re sleeping in your car or finding a very generous friend with a couch on the "mainland" side.
It’s a point of pride for people over there. They share the zip code but they don't share the noise. They get the 02539 mail, but they live in a world of sand tracks and shorebirds.
Navigating the Seasons in the 02539
The population of the Edgartown Massachusetts zip code is a total lie. If you look at the census, it says there are maybe 5,000 year-round residents.
That is a fiction.
In August, that number swells to 40,000. The post office becomes a mosh pit. The Stop & Shop on Upper Main Street looks like a disaster movie. But then, come November, the 02539 goes quiet. The "Closed for the Season" signs go up on Main Street. The wind off the Atlantic starts to bite. This is when you see the "real" Edgartown. The locals gathering at the Rosewater Market for coffee, the hunters out in the state forest, and the sheer, breathtaking silence of the South Shore.
Common Misconceptions About the Area
- It’s all celebrities: Look, you’ll see some famous faces. You might see a former President getting ice cream at Mad Martha’s. But 02539 is also home to fishermen, carpenters, and teachers who have been here for five generations.
- The beach is private: While there are plenty of private lots, South Beach (Katama) is public and glorious. Anyone can enjoy the 02539 coastline if they can find a spot to put their towel.
- You need a car: In the Village? No. In the rest of the zip code? Absolutely. The TATVA bus system is decent, but 02539 is spread out.
Actionable Advice for Using the 02539 Zip Code
If you are planning a trip or a move to the Edgartown Massachusetts zip code, there are a few logistical realities you need to swallow.
- The Post Office is Social: If you move here, get a P.O. Box. It’s where you’ll actually meet your neighbors. Don't expect home delivery in the historic district; it’s just not how it works.
- Book Your Ferry Early: If you're bringing a car to 02539, the Steamship Authority reservations open in January. If you wait until May to book a July weekend, you’re walking.
- Understand the "Triangle": When people give you directions in 02539, they’ll mention "The Triangle." It’s where the roads to Oak Bluffs and Vineyard Haven split. It’s the closest thing we have to a highway interchange. Learn it.
- Respect the Plover: If you’re heading to the beaches in the 02539 during early summer, huge sections might be closed for nesting shorebirds. Don't argue with the rangers. The birds were here first.
02539 is a weird, beautiful, expensive, and deeply historic slice of the world. Whether you’re just visiting for a day trip from Falmouth or you’re looking to drop eight figures on a captain's house, understanding the layout of this specific zip code is the first step to not looking like a "washashore."
To get the most out of your time in Edgartown, download the "The Pit Stop" app for local parking updates or check the Steamship Authority’s real-time ferry status. If you are shipping items ahead of a rental, always confirm with your landlord if they have a physical mail drop or if you need to address your packages to "General Delivery" at the Edgartown Post Office on 236 Edgartown-West Tisbury Rd. This simple check prevents your luggage or supplies from being returned to sender before you even cross the Sound. For those looking at real estate, focus your search on the "B2" commercial district if you want walkability, or the "R-20" residential zones if you’re looking for the quiet, wooded outskirts near the airport. Each pocket of the 02539 offers a different version of the Vineyard dream.