Let’s be real for a second. If you look at the history of Eddie Murphy at the Oscars, it’s not just a list of nominations or red-carpet walks. It’s a decades-long saga of awkward tension, "what-if" hosting gigs, and a specific brand of blunt honesty that Hollywood usually tries to polite-away.
Most people remember the 2007 "storm out." Or maybe that 2023 Golden Globes joke where he brought up the Will Smith slap. But the relationship between the comedy legend and the Academy is way more tangled than just a few viral moments. Honestly, it’s a story about a guy who refused to play the industry game, even when a golden statue was dangling right in front of him.
The 1988 Call-Out: Eddie Didn't Hold Back
Long before #OscarsSoWhite became a hashtag, a 26-year-old Eddie Murphy stood on the stage of the 60th Academy Awards and basically threw a grenade into the room. He was there to present Best Picture. Simple enough, right?
Well, no.
Backstage, Robin Williams reportedly tried to talk him out of the speech he had planned. According to Murphy’s recent Netflix documentary Being Eddie, Williams wasn't worried about the politics—he was just worried it wouldn't be funny. But Murphy went for it anyway. He told the audience he’d initially told his manager he wasn't coming because the Academy hadn't recognized Black people in motion pictures enough.
He even cracked that Black actors only won about once every 20 years, so "we ain't due till about 2004." Looking back, he was surprisingly close to the mark. Denzel Washington wouldn't win his Best Actor Oscar until 2002. Murphy literally stood there and said, "I'll probably never win an Oscar for saying this," and for nearly forty years, he’s been right.
👉 See also: The Real Story Behind I Can Do Bad All by Myself: From Stage to Screen
That Infamous 2007 Exit and the "Norbit Effect"
If you were following the trades in 2007, the narrative was set: Eddie Murphy was the frontrunner for Best Supporting Actor for Dreamgirls. He had the Golden Globe. He had the SAG Award. He was James "Thunder" Early, and he was incredible.
Then Norbit happened.
Marketing for Norbit—a movie where Eddie plays multiple characters in prosthetic suits—hit its peak right as Oscar voting was happening. Critics called it the "Norbit Effect." The theory is that Academy voters saw those billboards of Rasputia and decided they couldn't give an Oscar to a guy who was currently making "fat suit" jokes.
When Alan Arkin’s name was called for Little Miss Sunshine, Eddie Murphy didn't just sit there. He left. For years, the rumor was that he "stormed out" in a fit of rage. But in a 2026 interview with Entertainment Weekly, Murphy finally cleared the air. He wasn't mad at Arkin. He just didn't want to be the "sympathy guy" all night.
He recalled Clint Eastwood coming over to rub his shoulder in a consoling way. "I was like, 'Oh, no, no, I'm not gonna be this guy all night. Let's just leave,'" Murphy explained. He basically skipped the rest of the show because he couldn't stand the pity-pats on the back. You've gotta respect the honesty—who wants to sit in a tuxedo for four hours while people look at you like your dog just died?
✨ Don't miss: Love Island UK Who Is Still Together: The Reality of Romance After the Villa
The Hosting Gig That Never Was
In 2011, it looked like the relationship was finally mending. Eddie was set to host the 2012 Oscars. It was a massive deal. People were hyped to see if we’d get the Raw energy or the Saturday Night Live polish.
But the universe had other plans. His creative partner and the show's producer, Brett Ratner, resigned after using a homophobic slur during a press event. Eddie, out of loyalty, stepped down too. Just like that, the most anticipated hosting gig in a decade vanished. It felt like a classic "Eddie Murphy at the Oscars" moment: right on the cusp of a big win, and then—poof—it’s gone.
Why the 2023 Joke Still Matters
Fast forward to the 2023 Golden Globes. Murphy is accepting the Cecil B. DeMille Award, and he delivers a "blueprint" for success. His three rules?
- Pay your taxes.
- Mind your business.
- Keep Will Smith’s wife’s name out your f***ing mouth!
It was a total callback to the 2022 Oscars slap, and it reminded everyone that even when he isn't at the Oscars, he is the one defining the conversation. He’s been in the industry long enough to know that the awards are "more art than science," as he puts it.
Understanding the "Art" of the Loss
Murphy's take on the Academy today is pretty cynical, but arguably very accurate. He’s noted that winning isn't just about the performance; it’s about the campaigning, the "what do they owe you" factor, and the politics of the moment.
🔗 Read more: Gwendoline Butler Dead in a Row: Why This 1957 Mystery Still Packs a Punch
He doesn't seem to have "sour grapes," though. He’s got a house full of awards and a legacy that most Oscar winners would trade their statues for in a heartbeat. Whether he ever actually takes home a competitive Oscar or gets an Honorary one down the line, his impact on that stage has always been about more than the trophy.
How to Look at Eddie Murphy's Legacy Differently
If you want to understand why Eddie Murphy at the Oscars is such a big deal for film history, don't just look at the win-loss record. Look at these specific shifts he caused:
- He broke the "polite" presenter mold. His 1988 speech paved the way for future hosts and presenters to be more critical of the industry.
- He defined the "Pre-Oscar Flop." The "Norbit Effect" is now a legitimate case study for PR teams during awards season.
- He prioritized loyalty over the gig. Walking away from the 2012 hosting job showed that he wasn't desperate for the Academy's validation.
If you’re a fan of his work, the best way to dive deeper isn't just re-watching Dreamgirls. Check out the Netflix documentary Being Eddie. It gives the most unfiltered look at these moments we’ve ever had, straight from the man who lived them. It's a reminder that in Hollywood, sometimes being the guy who walks out of the room is more memorable than being the guy who stays to give the speech.
Practical Next Steps:
Keep an eye on his upcoming projects, like the latest Beverly Hills Cop installments or his rumored comedy specials. The "Academy" might still be figuring out how to handle him, but for the rest of us, Eddie Murphy is already a winner. To see the 1988 speech for yourself, it’s easily found on YouTube—watch it and see just how quiet that room gets when he tells the truth. It’s a masterclass in "not giving a damn."